4. Black vs. Spaceboy

[stip]

[stip]

I'm curious how Pearl Jam will stack up against the other grunge sacred cow bands, primarily if we get mid tier PJ songs against the best of the other bands. But Black crushes Spaceboy (which is a very pretty song, and good in its own right, but is hardly Mayonaise or Soma or Cherub Rock or Geek USA or one of the other Siamese Dream titans) on its merits

[doone]

but is hardly Mayonaise or Soma or Cherub Rock or Geek USA or one of the other Siamese Dream titans)

I don't know if I've heard any of these "titans"

I'm bored with Black but it gets my vote here

[stip]

Then you are in for a treat. They're all 5+ minute songs (Cherub Rock may clock slightly underneath that) but they're all just amazing. You may recognize Cherub Rock, which was a single, though not (iirc) not one of the bigger ones.

[Anders]

Would have voted for Black against almost anything.

[PHATJ]

Black

[Jammer XCI]

Oh yeah this is a really fair match

I'm going to be the lone vote for Spaceboy, because that song is also great and deserves some love. Black honestly bores me, it's my mom's favorite Pearl Jam song and it shows.