43. Porcelina of the Vast... vs. Trippin on a Hole...

[stip]

[stip]

Porcelina is one of those songs i think should have been cut from Mellon Collie for 3 superior b-sides. Trippin is a lot of fun. One of the best songs from Tiny Music

[LoathedVermin72]

You're a strange man, stip. Porcelina is great; no way in hell is it B-side material. That said, I still voted for Trippin'.

[stip]

I don't think I really like any of the Pumpkins songs in this style, to be honest.

[Anders]

Porcelina for me, Trippin just doesn't sit right.

[VinylGuy]

Such a difficult match.

Im going with Porcelina.

[chewm]

Porcelina is incredible, easy vote even if it's going to lose because this board hates the Pumpkins.

[PHATJ]

Trippin is a great song. Easy vote.

[Jammer XCI]

What the fuck is wrong with you guys?

Porcelina of fhe Vast Oceans is the best song on Mellon Collie, fucking epic next level shit. The STP song is good and all but Porcelina is something else.

[BurtReynolds]

Trippin' easily. One of their best songs.

Porcelina is... long.

[PHATJ]

jammer, I think our musical tastes are close to polar opposites.

[Jammer XCI]

jammer, I think our musical tastes are close to polar opposites.

Nah, we both think Pennyroyal Tea is a great song.

Porcelina is almost like prog rock or some shit though so I get why people on a grunge board wouldn't be super into it. I think its one of many masterpieces SP cranked out back in the day.

[PHATJ]

jammer, I think our musical tastes are close to polar opposites.

Nah, we both think Pennyroyal Tea is a great song.

Porcelina is almost like prog rock or some shit though so I get why people on a grunge board wouldn't be super into it. I think its one of many masterpieces SP cranked out back in the day.

Pennyroyal Tea is awesome

Actually, I don't dislike prog rock. I like Rush for god's sake. And I don't dislike Porcelina either, I just vastly prefer Trippin. But you almost always prefer heaviest, sludgiest, metal songs, and those are usually the last characteristics I seek out in a song.

[LetMeSleep]

Trippin' is top shelf.