What Can PJ Do to Bring You Back?

[epilogue]

I care about this band deeply. Always have. I'm all in. For life.

that's how cult leaders develop, joey

Here, drink this.

[epilogue]

I care about this band deeply. Always have. I'm all in. For life.

What if they did an album with St. Vincent? Would you explode?

Yes. Yes, I would literally explode.

[Monkey_Driven]

I care about this band deeply. Always have. I'm all in. For life.

What if they did an album with St. Vincent? Would you explode?

Yes. Yes, I would literally explode.

RM would shut down in remembrance.

[tyweed]

Allow Stone to have more creative influence and songwriting responsibilities.

Well get lots of Supersonics, Let The Record play and Amongst The Waves.

Get Josh Homme to produce the next record.

But I'm up for that.

Re: Stone -- He's due for a corker.

Re: Homme -- Thanks. Ed can't push him around.

[epilogue]

I care about this band deeply. Always have. I'm all in. For life.

What if they did an album with St. Vincent? Would you explode?

Yes. Yes, I would literally explode.

RM would shut down in remembrance.

I doubt it. But I'm sure Dev would make a poll.

[Birds in Hell]

Generate a feeling as though there’s some kind of compelling creative purpose for the band to exist.

Tough ask, I know.

[Monkey_Driven]

I care about this band deeply. Always have. I'm all in. For life.

What if they did an album with St. Vincent? Would you explode?

Yes. Yes, I would literally explode.

RM would shut down in remembrance.

I doubt it. But I'm sure Dev would make a poll.

I didn't say for good Joey. At least for a couple hours though.

[epilogue]

I care about this band deeply. Always have. I'm all in. For life.

What if they did an album with St. Vincent? Would you explode?

Yes. Yes, I would literally explode.

RM would shut down in remembrance.

I doubt it. But I'm sure Dev would make a poll.

I didn't say for good Joey. At least for a couple hours though.

Please set up a memorial account in my honor.

[Monkey_Driven]

I care about this band deeply. Always have. I'm all in. For life.

What if they did an album with St. Vincent? Would you explode?

Yes. Yes, I would literally explode.

RM would shut down in remembrance.

I doubt it. But I'm sure Dev would make a poll.

I didn't say for good Joey. At least for a couple hours though.

Please set up a memorial account in my honor.

It will feature nothing but artistic/contemplative portraits of you.

[epilogue]

I care about this band deeply. Always have. I'm all in. For life.

What if they did an album with St. Vincent? Would you explode?

Yes. Yes, I would literally explode.

RM would shut down in remembrance.

I doubt it. But I'm sure Dev would make a poll.

I didn't say for good Joey. At least for a couple hours though.

Please set up a memorial account in my honor.

It will feature nothing but artistic/contemplative portraits of you.

I accept these terms.

[daft twat]

I never left. I owe them my life - not in the literal I would have killed myself way. But they helped shape my identity in high school, they were the reason I got into music beyond top 40 radio, they are the cause of a couple really important friendships, and many of my most dear memories involve listening to their records or attending their shows.

All that said, a great record. Not a last great record. They can follow it with more mediocre records so long as they're accompanied by intermittent tours. I'd just like one more great collection of songs that all sound critical to the larger work. With the passing of Chris and the state of the country, now seems like the perfect time. I just don't think they like each other enough to put the time in the same room together to get it right.

[bodysnatcher]

I care about this band deeply. Always have. I'm all in. For life.

What if they did an album with St. Vincent? Would you explode?

Yes. Yes, I would literally explode.

RM would shut down in remembrance.

I doubt it. But I'm sure Dev would make a poll.

I didn't say for good Joey. At least for a couple hours though.

Please set up a memorial account in my honor.

It will feature nothing but artistic/contemplative portraits of you.

I accept these terms.

[Monkey_Driven]

I never left. I owe them my life - not in the literal I would have killed myself way. But they helped shape my identity in high school, they were the reason I got into music beyond top 40 radio, they are the cause of a couple really important friendships, and many of my most dear memories involve listening to their records or attending their shows.

All that said, a great record. Not a last great record. They can follow it with more mediocre records so long as they're accompanied by intermittent tours. I'd just like one more great collection of songs that all sound critical to the larger work. With the passing of Chris and the state of the country, now seems like the perfect time. I just don't think they like each other enough to put the time in the same room together to get it right.

Well said. I think they have another great record in them. The question is, do they want to put in the work necessary to make said record.

[epilogue]

You guuuuys!

[Jammer XCI]

Make a good album again, like even King Animal or The Devil Put the Dinosaurs Here level would be satisfying.

Also stop fanboying out about the whack ass Chicago Cubs.

[Anders]

I just want one last really strong album. I know that is subjective as hell, so I guess what I mean by that is an album that calls upon No Code / Binaural / Riot Act a bit more, and stretches the music in cool sonic directions. I like "calm chaos", Sonic Youth is good at that stuff (see "Rain on Tin"), and I like the wall of sound I hear in "Help Help".

Stuff like that tickles my fancy and I'd like to see PJ make progressions towards that. We have seen glimpses as with "Help Help" or the jam at the end of "Present Tense", or the slow tension of a song like "Can't Keep" and in "Insignificance". I think there is more room for them to explore that sound, and I'd like for them to go down that road again but make it new, not "Present Tense pt 2 that isn't quite as good".

Or another way of saying it, they need to put a little bit of fixin' on it.

[WaitingForBluey]

"Hey guys, we're working on a new album but this one is going to be vastly different than anything we've ever done in the past. No pre-written material this time. Hell, not even using a producer either. Instead, we're renting a cabin in the woods out on the Olympic Peninsula for a month. We're just gonna jam, have fun, party hard, hang out and see what we come up with. No studio trickery. The best of the raw takes will be released as is. If Eddie comes up with some lyrics on the spot, that's great, otherwise expect a lot of experimental jams. Wish us luck. We're hoping it doesn't suck but we'll release something even if we don't feel it's up to par with our recent output. Take care, see you in a few months."

[96583UP]

Do another album wih Neil Young. Then tour with him.

[Sgt. Crackpot]

Swap all of their roles.

[bodysnatcher]

Swap all of their roles.

now that Ed has the short hair, Stone has the long hair, and Stone is singing on the latest track ("Obey the Law of the Heart"), you might be onto something here