Star Wars never suggested you couldn't be anyone and still have force abilities. But it did suggest that you needed training to defeat those who also had training, and it also a story closely connected to the Skywalkers. To just drop that would be a huge flaw in the overall saga.
Did it? Luke uses the force to blow up the death star with 15 minutes of training, and fights vader (twice!) without ever completing training. The JEDI emphasized training, but the message of this movie (explicilty)
and implicitly in the OT is that the ability to use the force is as much about your internal state of mind as it is practice
Star Wars never suggested you couldn't be anyone and still have force abilities. But it did suggest that you needed training to defeat those who also had training, and it also a story closely connected to the Skywalkers. To just drop that would be a huge flaw in the overall saga.
Did it? Luke uses the force to blow up the death star with 15 minutes of training, and fights vader (twice!) without ever completing training. The JEDI emphasized training, but the message of this movie (explicilty)
and implicitly in the OT is that the ability to use the force is as much about your internal state of mind as it is practice
Luke does have teachers, and gets a fair amount of training bedore facing Vader. He is still only saved because he is his son. He is also a fantastic pilot, probably partly because of his heritage.
Star Wars never suggested you couldn't be anyone and still have force abilities. But it did suggest that you needed training to defeat those who also had training, and it also a story closely connected to the Skywalkers. To just drop that would be a huge flaw in the overall saga.
Did it? Luke uses the force to blow up the death star with 15 minutes of training, and fights vader (twice!) without ever completing training. The JEDI emphasized training, but the message of this movie (explicilty)
and implicitly in the OT is that the ability to use the force is as much about your internal state of mind as it is practice
Luke does have teachers, and gets a fair amount of training bedore facing Vader. He is still only saved because he is his son. He is also a fantastic pilot, probably partly because of his heritage.
he's a fantastic pilot because it is convenient - where the hell would a farm boy get to practice flying, let alone something like an X-wing. And his heritage is just that he inherited a great proficiency for the force. We're not really that far off here.
The timing of empire is really weird, too. It's never clear how long Luke actually spends on dagobah. Maybe it was just a week
Star Wars never suggested you couldn't be anyone and still have force abilities. But it did suggest that you needed training to defeat those who also had training, and it also a story closely connected to the Skywalkers. To just drop that would be a huge flaw in the overall saga.
Did it? Luke uses the force to blow up the death star with 15 minutes of training, and fights vader (twice!) without ever completing training. The JEDI emphasized training, but the message of this movie (explicilty)
and implicitly in the OT is that the ability to use the force is as much about your internal state of mind as it is practice
Luke does have teachers, and gets a fair amount of training bedore facing Vader. He is still only saved because he is his son. He is also a fantastic pilot, probably partly because of his heritage.
he's a fantastic pilot because it is convenient - where the hell would a farm boy get to practice flying, let alone something like an X-wing. And his heritage is just that he inherited a great proficiency for the force. We're not really that far off here.
The timing of empire is really weird, too. It's never clear how long Luke actually spends on dagobah. Maybe it was just a week
Luke owned and flew a T-16 Skyhopper on Tatooine. "I used to bullseye womp rats in my T-16 back home. They're not much bigger than two meters."
Luke's initial training took a few weeks I believe, before he rushed off to face Vader the first time, which didn't go too well. That's all from the first two movies. Of course if we take all movies into consideration, Luke's reasons for being especially force sensitive is much larger, as his father had a very interesting childhood and birth.
I loved that he fucked with us as fans, just enough. The meta moments mostly didn't take me out of things. Again, a 2017 Star Wars movie. The only cheeky part that I had a tiny internal groan at was Luke doing the shoulder brush-off at Kylo. Although that was pretty consistent with his behavior throughout the movie, so whatever
The only cheeky part that I had a tiny internal groan at was Luke doing the shoulder brush-off at Kylo. Although that was pretty consistent with his behavior throughout the movie, so whatever
The only cheeky part that I had a tiny internal groan at was Luke doing the shoulder brush-off at Kylo. Although that was pretty consistent with his behavior throughout the movie, so whatever
Seems like a lot of the complaints I've read are that it didn't meet everyone's "expectations". Critiques of the plot, dialogue choices, etc. are one thing, but I find it fascinating how people are judging this movie based on whether or not it met their expectations.
Monkey_Driven wrote:Seems like a lot of the complaints I've read are that it didn't meet everyone's "expectations". Critiques of the plot, dialogue choices, etc. are one thing, but I find it fascinating how people are judging this movie based on whether or not it met their expectations.
Monkey_Driven wrote:Seems like a lot of the complaints I've read are that it didn't meet everyone's "expectations". Critiques of the plot, dialogue choices, etc. are one thing, but I find it fascinating how people are judging this movie based on whether or not it met their expectations.
I didn't love it. I walked out of TFA in love with Star Wars again. There are a lot of great things about this movie, but too many things bugged me and took me out of the movie, most which have already been mentioned here.
My least favorite thing aside from Super Leia - Snoke's robe. Looks like fucking millionaire Biff in Back to the Future 2.
My favorite part - Poe's "What the hell?" when his foot went through the floor.
I love John Boyega's facial expressions (like his reaction to the BB-8 reveal when we all expected Benicia). I hope he's given more to do in part 9.
