Near Death Experiences

Engage in discussions about news, politics, etc.
Harry Lime
Future Drummer
Posts: 2508
Joined: Wed January 02, 2013 7:52 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by Harry Lime »

--- wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:In all times in its history, science has been shamelessly arrogant.
Fucking LOL at this nonsense.

I'm happy I didn't need a dictionary to help understand this response.
User avatar
surfndestroy
Future Drummer
Posts: 2870
Joined: Wed January 02, 2013 2:21 am

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by surfndestroy »

The mmost logical explanation I've heard for near death experiences is that this is how the brain experiences a shutting off of it's existence. The conformity of experiences is due to the chemicals being released as death nears which universal.

That said, my son flatlined for a bit when he was 10 or so and came out of it saying "God eats buttered popcorn at the movies". I was like WTF. Then my kid explained "God eats buttered popcorn at the movies. He's tried to reach down to grab me to join him a couple times but he keeps losing his grip due to the butter on his fingers." It did leave my kid thinking that he had a purpose to fulfill but with no idea what that purpose was/is.
Think I’m going to try being kind to everyone a chance.
User avatar
---
Future Drummer
Posts: 2439
Joined: Tue February 12, 2013 5:03 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by --- »

.
Last edited by --- on Mon January 11, 2021 6:36 am, edited 1 time in total.
Harry Lime
Future Drummer
Posts: 2508
Joined: Wed January 02, 2013 7:52 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by Harry Lime »

--- wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
--- wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:In all times in its history, science has been shamelessly arrogant.
Fucking LOL at this nonsense.

I'm happy I didn't need a dictionary to help understand this response.
You also clearly didn't need a science book to help you with your previous response.
And if you've read what I meant by that statement then you'd understand a little of what I was getting at. But instead you look for your conceited response which has no importance to me in the overall discussion. I don't even know why I'm spending my time writing this to you. Good day, sir.
surfndestroy wrote:The mmost logical explanation I've heard for near death experiences is that this is how the brain experiences a shutting off of it's existence. The conformity of experiences is due to the chemicals being released as death nears which universal.

That said, my son flatlined for a bit when he was 10 or so and came out of it saying "God eats buttered popcorn at the movies". I was like WTF. Then my kid explained "God eats buttered popcorn at the movies. He's tried to reach down to grab me to join him a couple times but he keeps losing his grip due to the butter on his fingers." It did leave my kid thinking that he had a purpose to fulfill but with no idea what that purpose was/is.
Interesting.
User avatar
Norah
Poster of the Year
Posts: 37327
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:04 pm
Location: September 2020 Poster of the Month

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by Norah »

Harry Lime wrote:What I do know, based on the cases that I've read about, the people who have had them come out totally different people. Their attitude towards life and others changes dramatically for the better. So whatever they experienced obviously had a profound effect. To tell them that all they were doing was hallucinating would be an insult to them.
People have come out of really good acid trips with the same profound change.
Harry Lime
Future Drummer
Posts: 2508
Joined: Wed January 02, 2013 7:52 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by Harry Lime »

cutuphalfdead wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:What I do know, based on the cases that I've read about, the people who have had them come out totally different people. Their attitude towards life and others changes dramatically for the better. So whatever they experienced obviously had a profound effect. To tell them that all they were doing was hallucinating would be an insult to them.
People have come out of really good acid trips with the same profound change.
Aldous Huxley I suppose would be one of them, but the two I've known didn't take their acid trip experience in a positive direction. But if you have your own personal story, or a friend's account, do tell.
User avatar
harmless
10Club Complaint Department
Posts: 17337
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:41 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by harmless »

Harry Lime wrote:
cutuphalfdead wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:What I do know, based on the cases that I've read about, the people who have had them come out totally different people. Their attitude towards life and others changes dramatically for the better. So whatever they experienced obviously had a profound effect. To tell them that all they were doing was hallucinating would be an insult to them.
People have come out of really good acid trips with the same profound change.
Aldous Huxley I suppose would be one of them, but the two I've known didn't take their acid trip experience in a positive direction. But if you have your own personal story, or a friend's account, do tell.
Is the direction they took their experience actually relevant? Profound doesn't have to mean positive. A war experience is profound and entirely negative.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
User avatar
harmless
10Club Complaint Department
Posts: 17337
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:41 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by harmless »

I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
Harry Lime
Future Drummer
Posts: 2508
Joined: Wed January 02, 2013 7:52 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by Harry Lime »

harmless wrote:I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.

Probably so. Maybe I was afraid it'd fall in the category of an organized religion, which is where a lot of NDE cases end up.
User avatar
harmless
10Club Complaint Department
Posts: 17337
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:41 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by harmless »

Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.

Probably so. Maybe I was afraid it'd fall in the category of an organized religion, which is where a lot of NDE cases end up.
What, seriously? This screams conspiracy theory to me.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
Harry Lime
Future Drummer
Posts: 2508
Joined: Wed January 02, 2013 7:52 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by Harry Lime »

harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.

Probably so. Maybe I was afraid it'd fall in the category of an organized religion, which is where a lot of NDE cases end up.
What, seriously? This screams conspiracy theory to me.
Is this sarcasm?
User avatar
harmless
10Club Complaint Department
Posts: 17337
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:41 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by harmless »

Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.

Probably so. Maybe I was afraid it'd fall in the category of an organized religion, which is where a lot of NDE cases end up.
What, seriously? This screams conspiracy theory to me.
Is this sarcasm?
My apologies, I thought you meant drug experiences ('NDE' was an abbreviation I had to look up). But still, you've lost me completely. The response was about drugs, right? I wasn't aware that drug experiences lead to organised religion.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
Harry Lime
Future Drummer
Posts: 2508
Joined: Wed January 02, 2013 7:52 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by Harry Lime »

harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.

Probably so. Maybe I was afraid it'd fall in the category of an organized religion, which is where a lot of NDE cases end up.
What, seriously? This screams conspiracy theory to me.
Is this sarcasm?
My apologies, I thought you meant drug experiences ('NDE' was an abbreviation I had to look up). But still, you've lost me completely. The response was about drugs, right? I wasn't aware that drug experiences lead to organised religion.
I meant the Near Death Exerience being associated with those who end up finding God in their life, and make wilful efforts to improve not only their appreciation for their own life, but of the lives of those close to them. A lot of them latch on to an organized faith. Some become preachers; the Howard Storm story as example. On a side note, being a good person is tough work.

Involving drugs? The two I know had their lives spiral out of control. They'd reminisce about their experience and how they saw their dead grandparents etc, but no real impact in their life afterwards. It's just those two that I heard personally though, so I don't know.
User avatar
harmless
10Club Complaint Department
Posts: 17337
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:41 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by harmless »

Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.

Probably so. Maybe I was afraid it'd fall in the category of an organized religion, which is where a lot of NDE cases end up.
What, seriously? This screams conspiracy theory to me.
Is this sarcasm?
My apologies, I thought you meant drug experiences ('NDE' was an abbreviation I had to look up). But still, you've lost me completely. The response was about drugs, right? I wasn't aware that drug experiences lead to organised religion.
I meant the Near Death Exerience being associated with those who end up finding God in their life, and make wilful efforts to improve not only their appreciation for their own life, but of the lives of those close to them. A lot of them latch on to an organized faith. Some become preachers; the Howard Storm story as example. On a side note, being a good person is tough work.

Involving drugs? The two I know had their lives spiral out of control. They'd reminisce about their experience and how they saw their dead grandparents etc, but no real impact in their life afterwards (?). It's just those two that I heard personally though, so I don't know.
That seems like a pretty big impact afterwards. No?
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
Harry Lime
Future Drummer
Posts: 2508
Joined: Wed January 02, 2013 7:52 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by Harry Lime »

harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.

Probably so. Maybe I was afraid it'd fall in the category of an organized religion, which is where a lot of NDE cases end up.
What, seriously? This screams conspiracy theory to me.
Is this sarcasm?
My apologies, I thought you meant drug experiences ('NDE' was an abbreviation I had to look up). But still, you've lost me completely. The response was about drugs, right? I wasn't aware that drug experiences lead to organised religion.
I meant the Near Death Exerience being associated with those who end up finding God in their life, and make wilful efforts to improve not only their appreciation for their own life, but of the lives of those close to them. A lot of them latch on to an organized faith. Some become preachers; the Howard Storm story as example. On a side note, being a good person is tough work.

Involving drugs? The two I know had their lives spiral out of control. They'd reminisce about their experience and how they saw their dead grandparents etc, but no real impact in their life afterwards (?). It's just those two that I heard personally though, so I don't know.
That seems like a pretty big impact afterwards. No?
Yeah but positive or negative impact? Perhaps it's all subjective, but I know for sure that one of the two has his regrets.
User avatar
harmless
10Club Complaint Department
Posts: 17337
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:41 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by harmless »

Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.

Probably so. Maybe I was afraid it'd fall in the category of an organized religion, which is where a lot of NDE cases end up.
What, seriously? This screams conspiracy theory to me.
Is this sarcasm?
My apologies, I thought you meant drug experiences ('NDE' was an abbreviation I had to look up). But still, you've lost me completely. The response was about drugs, right? I wasn't aware that drug experiences lead to organised religion.
I meant the Near Death Exerience being associated with those who end up finding God in their life, and make wilful efforts to improve not only their appreciation for their own life, but of the lives of those close to them. A lot of them latch on to an organized faith. Some become preachers; the Howard Storm story as example. On a side note, being a good person is tough work.

Involving drugs? The two I know had their lives spiral out of control. They'd reminisce about their experience and how they saw their dead grandparents etc, but no real impact in their life afterwards (?). It's just those two that I heard personally though, so I don't know.
That seems like a pretty big impact afterwards. No?
Yeah but positive or negative impact? Perhaps it's all subjective, but I know for sure that one of the two has his regrets.
You keep wandering away from your original arguments. You originally replied to CHUD, who said "People have come out of really good acid trips with the same profound change." He said nothing about positive or negative... All he was arguing was that hallucinations did not preclude a profound life change. Nothing positive or negative was implied, that was something you added, as if a life change was only profound if it was positive.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
Harry Lime
Future Drummer
Posts: 2508
Joined: Wed January 02, 2013 7:52 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by Harry Lime »

harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.

Probably so. Maybe I was afraid it'd fall in the category of an organized religion, which is where a lot of NDE cases end up.
What, seriously? This screams conspiracy theory to me.
Is this sarcasm?
My apologies, I thought you meant drug experiences ('NDE' was an abbreviation I had to look up). But still, you've lost me completely. The response was about drugs, right? I wasn't aware that drug experiences lead to organised religion.
I meant the Near Death Exerience being associated with those who end up finding God in their life, and make wilful efforts to improve not only their appreciation for their own life, but of the lives of those close to them. A lot of them latch on to an organized faith. Some become preachers; the Howard Storm story as example. On a side note, being a good person is tough work.

Involving drugs? The two I know had their lives spiral out of control. They'd reminisce about their experience and how they saw their dead grandparents etc, but no real impact in their life afterwards (?). It's just those two that I heard personally though, so I don't know.
That seems like a pretty big impact afterwards. No?
Yeah but positive or negative impact? Perhaps it's all subjective, but I know for sure that one of the two has his regrets.
You keep wandering away from your original arguments. You originally replied to CHUD, who said "People have come out of really good acid trips with the same profound change." He said nothing about positive or negative... All he was arguing was that hallucinations did not preclude a profound life change. Nothing positive or negative was implied, that was something you added, as if a life change was only profound if it was positive.
Obviously CHUD needs to explain more then. I was only responding to his response to my original words.

"Same profound change". I just explained how they're different in regards to the limited research that I'm familiar with. Why are we making this difficult?
User avatar
harmless
10Club Complaint Department
Posts: 17337
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:41 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by harmless »

Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.

Probably so. Maybe I was afraid it'd fall in the category of an organized religion, which is where a lot of NDE cases end up.
What, seriously? This screams conspiracy theory to me.
Is this sarcasm?
My apologies, I thought you meant drug experiences ('NDE' was an abbreviation I had to look up). But still, you've lost me completely. The response was about drugs, right? I wasn't aware that drug experiences lead to organised religion.
I meant the Near Death Exerience being associated with those who end up finding God in their life, and make wilful efforts to improve not only their appreciation for their own life, but of the lives of those close to them. A lot of them latch on to an organized faith. Some become preachers; the Howard Storm story as example. On a side note, being a good person is tough work.

Involving drugs? The two I know had their lives spiral out of control. They'd reminisce about their experience and how they saw their dead grandparents etc, but no real impact in their life afterwards (?). It's just those two that I heard personally though, so I don't know.
That seems like a pretty big impact afterwards. No?
Yeah but positive or negative impact? Perhaps it's all subjective, but I know for sure that one of the two has his regrets.
You keep wandering away from your original arguments. You originally replied to CHUD, who said "People have come out of really good acid trips with the same profound change." He said nothing about positive or negative... All he was arguing was that hallucinations did not preclude a profound life change. Nothing positive or negative was implied, that was something you added, as if a life change was only profound if it was positive.
Obviously CHUD needs to explain more then. I was only responding to his response to my original words.

"Same profound change". I just explained how they're different in regards to the limited research that I'm familiar with. Why are we making this difficult?
Tell you what, never mind.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
Harry Lime
Future Drummer
Posts: 2508
Joined: Wed January 02, 2013 7:52 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by Harry Lime »

harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.

Probably so. Maybe I was afraid it'd fall in the category of an organized religion, which is where a lot of NDE cases end up.
What, seriously? This screams conspiracy theory to me.
Is this sarcasm?
My apologies, I thought you meant drug experiences ('NDE' was an abbreviation I had to look up). But still, you've lost me completely. The response was about drugs, right? I wasn't aware that drug experiences lead to organised religion.
I meant the Near Death Exerience being associated with those who end up finding God in their life, and make wilful efforts to improve not only their appreciation for their own life, but of the lives of those close to them. A lot of them latch on to an organized faith. Some become preachers; the Howard Storm story as example. On a side note, being a good person is tough work.

Involving drugs? The two I know had their lives spiral out of control. They'd reminisce about their experience and how they saw their dead grandparents etc, but no real impact in their life afterwards (?). It's just those two that I heard personally though, so I don't know.
That seems like a pretty big impact afterwards. No?
Yeah but positive or negative impact? Perhaps it's all subjective, but I know for sure that one of the two has his regrets.
You keep wandering away from your original arguments. You originally replied to CHUD, who said "People have come out of really good acid trips with the same profound change." He said nothing about positive or negative... All he was arguing was that hallucinations did not preclude a profound life change. Nothing positive or negative was implied, that was something you added, as if a life change was only profound if it was positive.
Obviously CHUD needs to explain more then. I was only responding to his response to my original words.

"Same profound change". I just explained how they're different in regards to the limited research that I'm familiar with. Why are we making this difficult?
Tell you what, never mind.
Fine. But I feel as if we have stopped work on the transatlantic bridge between you and I. YOu are a Brit, right?
User avatar
harmless
10Club Complaint Department
Posts: 17337
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:41 pm

Re: Near Death Experiences

Post by harmless »

Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:
Harry Lime wrote:
harmless wrote:I think you're trying to attach morality to your arguments without declaring that, Harry.

Probably so. Maybe I was afraid it'd fall in the category of an organized religion, which is where a lot of NDE cases end up.
What, seriously? This screams conspiracy theory to me.
Is this sarcasm?
My apologies, I thought you meant drug experiences ('NDE' was an abbreviation I had to look up). But still, you've lost me completely. The response was about drugs, right? I wasn't aware that drug experiences lead to organised religion.
I meant the Near Death Exerience being associated with those who end up finding God in their life, and make wilful efforts to improve not only their appreciation for their own life, but of the lives of those close to them. A lot of them latch on to an organized faith. Some become preachers; the Howard Storm story as example. On a side note, being a good person is tough work.

Involving drugs? The two I know had their lives spiral out of control. They'd reminisce about their experience and how they saw their dead grandparents etc, but no real impact in their life afterwards (?). It's just those two that I heard personally though, so I don't know.
That seems like a pretty big impact afterwards. No?
Yeah but positive or negative impact? Perhaps it's all subjective, but I know for sure that one of the two has his regrets.
You keep wandering away from your original arguments. You originally replied to CHUD, who said "People have come out of really good acid trips with the same profound change." He said nothing about positive or negative... All he was arguing was that hallucinations did not preclude a profound life change. Nothing positive or negative was implied, that was something you added, as if a life change was only profound if it was positive.
Obviously CHUD needs to explain more then. I was only responding to his response to my original words.

"Same profound change". I just explained how they're different in regards to the limited research that I'm familiar with. Why are we making this difficult?
Tell you what, never mind.
Fine. But I feel as if we have stopped work on the transatlantic bridge between you and I. YOu are a Brit, right?
:lol: Yes I am.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
Post Reply