Pearl Jam - Definitive Live Versions (a Green Habit sequel)

[Wendy Carlos's Twin]

The (probably) best version of Sad (San Fran III 2006) flows into the next track, so requires some minor editing to make give it a proper ending.

You can splice on the ending from the other SF version and it works fine.

[ridleybradout]

The (probably) best version of Sad (San Fran III 2006) flows into the next track, so requires some minor editing to make give it a proper ending.

You can splice on the ending from the other SF version and it works fine.

I could... or I could just take the file you’ve already done that to and use that

[doone]

I've all but finalised the selections for Ten, but I wanted some feedback on a thought I had.

The Drop In The Park version of Porch is amazing (slightly better than Atlanta 94 in my opinion - the other contender), however, it comes in at a whopping 12:38.

What do people think about deftly cutting out a chunk of the breakdown to make it a bit shorter for the purpose of this compilation? Would that be wrong?

There are other such not-quite-true-to-actual-performance things that will come up:

- I've already pretty much decided I'm going to use the LO2L version of Do The Evolution, however as many know some of the vocals for this version were flown in from another.

- The (probably) best version of Sad (San Fran III 2006) flows into the next track, so requires some minor editing to make give it a proper ending.

Thoughts?...

Yes, cut Porch down or find a shorter version that works. Lo2L DTE is fine by me and I think you and WCT have Sad all figured out already.

[E.H. Ruddock]

Idk, I kind of like the longer (older) Porch versions. That Zurich '92 one is like 10 minutes long and it is my favorite version. I'd vote to keep it as is. As much as I hate disagreeing with doone.

And yeah, Lo2L DTE is great

[doone]

Our first disagreement!

I absolutely don't like the long jams on Porch unless I'm watching a video and can see monkey boy Eddie climbing around like a lunatic.
Brad, if you must include a long jam, please make it an interesting one.

[rimb]

If these are supposed to be considered definitive versions, how can you possibly be in favour of editing out whole portions of them??

[ridleybradout]

Brad, if you must include a long jam, please make it an interesting one.

It definitely is - great Tearing tag among others

If these are supposed to be considered definitive versions, how can you possibly be in favour of editing out whole portions of them??

I'm going to keep DITP Porch as is - was just putting the idea out there. And you're right, no need to think about CD-burning as this is going to be a digital collection.

[MattA75]

2003 Champaign should be considered for DTE...haven't listened to it in a while but I remember it being a great great version

[raven2001]

2003 Champaign should be considered for DTE...haven't listened to it in a while but I remember it being a great great version

The band plays pretty good, but if I remember correctly, there's a lyric screw up by Ed.

[thespaniard]

Hi Brad

Just wondering if you'll be releasing this in drips 'by album' or keeping it all under wraps for one big reveal at the end?

ta

[ridleybradout]

Hi Brad

Just wondering if you'll be releasing this in drips 'by album' or keeping it all under wraps for one big reveal at the end?

ta

[ridleybradout]

The finished Ten era discs are not too far away, but in the mean time I thought we should get started on Vs. Here are the nominations I have so far - please post any and all comments or further suggestions in this thread



Go
- Las Vegas 1993-11-30
- Atlanta 1994-04-03

Animal
- MTV VMAs 1993-09-02
- Berlin 1996-11-03
- Las Vegas 1993-11-30

Daughter
- Cleveland 2006-05-20 (It's Okay tag)
- Milan 2000-06-22 (no tag, awesome call and response)
- Jones Beach 2000-08-24 (It's Okay tag)
- Rotterdam 1993-07-16 (WMA tag)
- Washington DC 1998-09-19 (LO2L - RITFW/WMA tags)

Dissident
- Washington DC 1998-09-19
- Toronto 2000-10-05

Glorified G
- Washington DC 1995-01-14
- Atlanta 1994-04-03

W.M.A.
- Atlanta 1994-04-03

Blood
- Indio 1993-11-05
- Orpheum 1994-04-12
- Melbourne 1995-03-17
- Auckland 1995-03-25 (PJ20 OST)

Rearviewmirror
- SNL 1994-04-16
- Washington DC 1995-01-14
- Las Vegas 2000-10-22
- Saratoga 2000-08-27
- Atlanta 1994-04-03

Rats
- Orpheum 1994-04-12
- Gorge 2006-07-23

Leash
- Las Vegas 1993-11-30
- Pinkpop 1992-06-08
- Rotterdam 1993-07-16

Elderly Woman Behind A Counter In A Small Town
- Madrid 2006-09-07
- Orpheum 1994-04-12

Indifference
- Bologna 2006-09-14 (PJ20 OST)
- Indio 1993-11-05
- Atlanta 1994-04-03

Crazy Mary [*Still unsure whether this should go on the Vs or covers disc, given PJ released their version before Victoria Williams]
- Phoenix 2000-10-21
- Gorge 2006-07-23
- Indianapolis 2000-08-18
- MSG 2003-07-08

Hard to Imagine
- Orpheum 1994-04-12
- Gorge 2005-09-01
- E. Rutherford 2000-06-03

[E.H. Ruddock]

Definitely the Vegas Go!

[rimb]

Definitely the Vegas Go!

Atlanta - "This song's for Kurt..."

Can't top that for an intro to such a powerful song.

[E.H. Ruddock]

That's nice and all, but I'm not in it for the intro. That Vegas version is hot fire

[rimb]

That's nice and all, but I'm not in it for the intro. That Vegas version is hot fire

True, just re-listened to Vegas and hard to argue.

[Norah]

Saratoga RVM

[Norah]

And definitely a 2000 Crazy Mary.

[Monkey_Driven]

And definitely a 2000 Crazy Mary.

Yup

[rimb]

And definitely a 2000 Crazy Mary.

Yup

Yeah, definitely no Boom required here.