tragabigzanda wrote:i've somehow, organically, reached a point where i don't care what Ed sounds like, or if their new songs are great or not. I look forward to seeing them live once in a blue moon, and will always adore everything up through Riot Act (plus a handful of cuts after).
I hope they continue on as a band for as long as it makes them happy, and I'm thankful they're putting good into the world through their various philanthropic efforts.
This!
are you going to Missoula ?
are you talkin' to me?
I was but now you are being weird so never mind.
thought for sure you meant trag who if i'm not mistaken lives in that part of the map. i ain't going to missoula BUT I AM GOING TO BOTH WRIGLEY SHOWS GO THERE STRAT AND SLOW SET TO MEET!!
I listened to CDM about five total times the first two days it was out. Haven’t bothered to listen again. And I was one of the ones that didn’t instantly hate the song.
For me, the disappointment lies in the nothing new under the sun quality of it. Like I've said before, the first 40 seconds are fire and then it settles into paint by BOB numbers. That's just not good enough after 5 years. You've gotta try harder than that.
Would rather see them develop that solo Ed organ song or something along those lines.
The live performance takes it up a notch definitely. It sounds great. The live guitars in lieu of the studio production adds a needed dimension. Ed sounds better than usual as well, I like what he does with the vocals.
The problem is, I just don't think it's a very good song. The chorus is flat and plodding and unoriginal.
It's a first grade song structure without trying to do anything new.
hlniv wrote:I can't decide if I like this song or not.
The live performance takes it up a notch definitely. It sounds great. The live guitars in lieu of the studio production adds a needed dimension. Ed sounds better than usual as well, I like what he does with the vocals.
The problem is, I just don't think it's a very good song. The chorus is flat and plodding and unoriginal.
It's a first grade song structure without trying to do anything new.
The most uninspired bridge of any PJ song, ever.
So, in conclusion, I'm conflicted.
This is where I am right now. I do think it will work better in the context of a full album.
I was driving and Can't Deny Me came on the radio, it took on a whole new feel, it was basically Vedder calling out and insulting the president over the airwaves, it is pretty bad ass in that way.
hlniv wrote:I can't decide if I like this song or not.
The live performance takes it up a notch definitely. It sounds great. The live guitars in lieu of the studio production adds a needed dimension. Ed sounds better than usual as well, I like what he does with the vocals.
The problem is, I just don't think it's a very good song. The chorus is flat and plodding and unoriginal.
It's a first grade song structure without trying to do anything new.
The most uninspired bridge of any PJ song, ever.
So, in conclusion, I'm conflicted.
This is where I am right now. I do think it will work better in the context of a full album.
I hope it ends up on the cutting room floor as a nice little one off b side.
hlniv wrote:I can't decide if I like this song or not.
The live performance takes it up a notch definitely. It sounds great. The live guitars in lieu of the studio production adds a needed dimension. Ed sounds better than usual as well, I like what he does with the vocals.
The problem is, I just don't think it's a very good song. The chorus is flat and plodding and unoriginal.
It's a first grade song structure without trying to do anything new.
The most uninspired bridge of any PJ song, ever.
So, in conclusion, I'm conflicted.
This is where I am right now. I do think it will work better in the context of a full album.
I hope it ends up on the cutting room floor as a nice little one off b side.
That's the thing - I don't want to hear it on the radio or in the context of the album and think "well actually it's not quite that bad." My bar's a little higher than that.
I just want to be slightly inspired by them working at their craft in a slightly different way after all these years. I didn't think it was much to ask, but... we'll see.
I'm really not even expecting Binaural 2.0. I would just like hear some off-kilter sounds and themes. Like "My Father's Son" level stuff, but throughout the album. Surprise me just a little - that's all I ask!!
This is mainly why I wanted a new producer. Someone who would create a different air in the room.
Hopefully "Can't Deny Me" is just a quick number they dashed off a month or so ago in response to the Parkland shooting. I could totally see that being the case. And then all the other songs are produced by Daniel Lanois.
evenslow wrote:
Hopefully "Can't Deny Me" is just a quick number they dashed off a month or so ago in response to the Parkland shooting. I could totally see that being the case. And then all the other songs are produced by Daniel Lanois.
who needs Cialis when ideas like this are being made
didn't Ed like just do a live benefit with Will Ferrell like 2 weeks ago and WF played the cowbell? maybe CDM was written the day after
All posts by this account, even those referencing real things, are entirely fictional and are for entertainment purposes only; i.e. very low-quality entertainment. These may contain coarse language and due to their content should not be viewed by anyone
