R1: My Own Prison vs. Innervision

[LoathedVermin72]

Creed - "My Own Prison"


System of a Down - "Innervision"

[LoathedVermin72]

"My Own Prison" is a boring, overlong slog. Another extremely obvious SOAD vote.

[BurtReynolds]

not Creed

[Jammer XCI]

LOL Creed

Get that shitty Jesus rock out of here.

[Kevin Davis]

I really liked "My Own Prison" when it came out. Scott Stapp really didn't begin to seem like a clown until Creed's second album, where he turned the whole spiritual messiah figure thing into a gaudy self-fulfilling prophecy. None of their music has aged well, but the familiar Scott Stapp caricature wasn't really a thing when they were making the rounds for their first record. They were just one more band riding grunge's coattails.

I'd vote for it over a lot of the other junk in this tourney, but I've gained a newfound respect for System of a Down through these matchups. I don't like this as well as "Chop Suey" or "Toxicity" but I'll pick it over Creed eight days a week.

[Birds in Hell]

Another SOAD vote.

[BurtReynolds]

Stapp at his most Eddie Vedder here.

[tree_]

My Own Prison: This is legitimately a very good song but I've always hated his voice so much. In the music video, why is the guitar player pretending to sing? It's obviously not him... Scott's face and personality make me angry. 2:47.

Innervision: Never heard it before. I love their singing. Not a fan of the song, though. 1:28.

Going with Innervision because I hate Scott Stapp.

[EJ]

Stapp at his most Eddie Vedder here.

some of the shots of him in this video are so blatantly copied from the Jeremy video. the only thing missing is the patented Vedder upwards eyeroll.

Scott does beat Ed in the lower jaw extension though.

[Jorge]

My Own Prison: This is legitimately a very good song

lol

In the music video, why is the guitar player pretending to sing? It's obviously not him...

It is him. It's a different voice than Stapp's.

[tree_]

My Own Prison: This is legitimately a very good song

lol

In the music video, why is the guitar player pretending to sing? It's obviously not him...

It is him. It's a different voice than Stapp's.

I think it would be pretty good with a different singer. It's my opinion. Jerk.

Well, he's imitating his voice then. It sounds like Stapp to me.

[Jorge]

I don't think I'd ever heard "My Own Prison" before today, and when that voice came in but before they showed the guitarist singing, I thought "oh, I didn't think Creed had second vocalists". It is clearly a different voice with a different timbre, but the delivery is similar because... well, they are Superserious Creed Boys

[Norah]

you've never heard my own prison before? it was a huge hit here.

[Jorge]

I know "One", "Higher", "Arms Wide Open", "My Sacrifice", "One Last Breath", and that heavy one with the CGI video of dragons fighting or whatever where Stapp goes "LOOK AT MEH!!!"

[Jorge]

that heavy one with the CGI video of dragons fighting or whatever where Stapp goes "LOOK AT MEH!!!"

This one



This video.

Probably the best of the songs, though

[tree_]

I don't think I'd ever heard "My Own Prison" before today, and when that voice came in but before they showed the guitarist singing, I thought "oh, I didn't think Creed had second vocalists". It is clearly a different voice with a different timbre, but the delivery is similar because... well, they are Superserious Creed Boys

You're right, it's a second vocalist. I am listening through my work computer speakers, so...
But, damn... would've been way funnier if he were pretending he was singing in the video...

That live performance is so bad... I just feel sorry for them. Mostly Scott. He's unbearable.

[Jorge]

You're gonna get yourself fired

[tree_]

You're gonna get yourself fired

Don't say that. I'm not the only one who does it and I've been doing it for years, so... Damnit now my hands are sweaty.

[Norah]

is there vomit on your shirt already?

[tree_]

is there vomit on your shirt already?

Huh?