Cover of the Moment: Comfortably Numb

[Iholdthepain]

I like this cover. Fuck you.

+1

[Birds in Hell]

I like the covers most of the time. I think sometimes we forget that the purpose of the shows is not the bootleg but the experience for the people in attendance. I’d say a majority of the crowd in the building would rather hear C Numb than any PJ deep cuts.

I find this very hard to believe. Last Kiss aside, which was a significant hit for the band, most of the other covers I’ve seen the band play have gone down like a lead balloon, particularly Mother. Nobody cares, and I wager they’d much prefer to hear less-played album tracks from Ten or Vs (e.g. Garden, Deep, Rats) than FM radio staples from 30-40 years ago.

[Iholdthepain]

I think they just want to play whatever the fuck they want to play... and they think CN is fun to play... Is that such a difficult concept?

[Birds in Hell]

No, but here’s another non-difficult concept: it sucks.

[Iholdthepain]

Yeah, well that's just your opinion, man...

I love hearing it, playing it, and hearing pj play it.

[E.H. Ruddock]

I like the covers most of the time. I think sometimes we forget that the purpose of the shows is not the bootleg but the experience for the people in attendance. I’d say a majority of the crowd in the building would rather hear C Numb than any PJ deep cuts.

Why do they have to substitute a cover for a deep cut? Why can't they just play another one of their good songs?

[Jeez]

It’s dreadfully laboured and a bollock hair short of woeful.

I get they might enjoy playing it and that’s cool, but it’s probably only cool to suckers who are in Pearl Jam or have never listened to the original.

Retire the covers by numbers approach, or if they can’t, then cover something within your range.

Fucking shameful turn this band has taken. Vedder inc.

[numbers]

I like the covers most of the time. I think sometimes we forget that the purpose of the shows is not the bootleg but the experience for the people in attendance. I’d say a majority of the crowd in the building would rather hear C Numb than any PJ deep cuts.

Why do they have to substitute a cover for a deep cut? Why can't they just play another one of their good songs?

I was just trying to make the point that a lot of the people in attendance are not PJ diehards like we are, they are there to hear Alive and Even Flow and would rather hear C Numb than anything off Binaural.

[Strat]

I like the covers most of the time. I think sometimes we forget that the purpose of the shows is not the bootleg but the experience for the people in attendance. I’d say a majority of the crowd in the building would rather hear C Numb than any PJ deep cuts.

Why do they have to substitute a cover for a deep cut? Why can't they just play another one of their good songs?

I was just trying to make the point that a lot of the people in attendance are not PJ diehards like we are, they are there to hear Alive and Even Flow and would rather hear C Numb than anything off Binaural.

I should have these people killed

[EJ]

I like the covers most of the time. I think sometimes we forget that the purpose of the shows is not the bootleg but the experience for the people in attendance. I’d say a majority of the crowd in the building would rather hear C Numb than any PJ deep cuts.

Why do they have to substitute a cover for a deep cut? Why can't they just play another one of their good songs?

I was just trying to make the point that a lot of the people in attendance are not PJ diehards like we are, they are there to hear Alive and Even Flow and would rather hear C Numb than anything off Binaural.

Only PJ diehards want to hear PJ songs at a PJ concert?

[Strat]

I like the covers most of the time. I think sometimes we forget that the purpose of the shows is not the bootleg but the experience for the people in attendance. I’d say a majority of the crowd in the building would rather hear C Numb than any PJ deep cuts.

Why do they have to substitute a cover for a deep cut? Why can't they just play another one of their good songs?

I was just trying to make the point that a lot of the people in attendance are not PJ diehards like we are, they are there to hear Alive and Even Flow and would rather hear C Numb than anything off Binaural.

Only PJ diehards want to hear PJ songs at a PJ concert?

Only pj diehards want to hear deeper pj cuts at a pj concert

[Captain Termite]

most of the other covers I’ve seen the band play have gone down like a lead balloon, particularly Mother.

How can you tell? I'd guess that if someone was excited to hear a song like Mother, they wouldn't be yelling and jumping up and down like for Baba or something. It's not that type of song.

[---]

no band should ever aim higher than catering to the whims of the softheaded, tasteless boors that encourage their indulgence in the particular brand of disposable schlock so appealing to middle-aged idlers with a waning interest in their craft

[numbers]

For example, I’ve been to a few DMB shows with friends. I don’t really like DMB, I don’t hate them, but I only know the hit songs. One of those shows they played Petty- Running Down a Dream and I remember and enjoyed that a lot more than any of the songs I didn’t know. It doesn’t mean I’m angry they didn’t play more covers, or angry that they played songs I didn’t know.

[numbers]

no band should ever aim higher than catering to the whims of the softheaded, tasteless boors that encourage their indulgence in the particular brand of disposable schlock so appealing to middle-aged idlers with a waning interest in their craft

A crowd full of people with the above sentiment surely wouldn’t be an awful group to be around.

[Biff Pocoroba]

I don't mind them playing couple covers but 7-8 in a 30 song concert is too many. And some certainly work better than others, I don't even think about it when I hear Baba or Free World at the end anymore and personally I wouldn't mind seeing Timeless Melody return from time to time.

[numbers]

I’d like to see them start doing Harvest Moon again.

[mikejasond]

I have to agree with those who brought up you shouldn't cover Pink Floyd. This song is so quirky and distinctive that it's just a strange choice to me besides that mike is good on it. I do think Mother is worse as it's just a weird song to sing as a cover. If they're gonna do classic rock staples I'd rather they pick something different.

[PHATJ]

I have to agree with those who brought up you shouldn't cover Pink Floyd. This song is so quirky and distinctive that it's just a strange choice to me besides that mike is good on it. I do think Mother is worse as it's just a weird song to sing as a cover. If they're gonna do classic rock staples I'd rather they pick something different.

Great insight

[run2death]

Everyday in Lubbock

This was fucking great.