The Official Neil Young Thread

[doug rr]

me and my buddies did this about 6 years ago to prepare fo the Neil and Horse shows at red rocks. Made a spreadsheet withr ankings and commentary for each album.

[Kevin Davis]

I think a LAL to the Neil Young catalog might be a good beginning-of-2019 project act of pure immersive delight

I would be on-board with this. Start with Disc 1 of Archives Vol. 1, then Buffalo Springfield before getting into his solo stuff? Sprinkle in the live archive albums as you go through? We might get through the '70s by May.

I was thinking start with the first solo album (too much non-Neil BS material for my taste, plus all the best songs reappear on his own albums anyway), but I could be swayed.

[Simple Torture]

I think a LAL to the Neil Young catalog might be a good beginning-of-2019 project act of pure immersive delight

I would be on-board with this. Start with Disc 1 of Archives Vol. 1, then Buffalo Springfield before getting into his solo stuff? Sprinkle in the live archive albums as you go through? We might get through the '70s by May.

I was thinking start with the first solo album (too much non-Neil BS material for my taste, plus all the best songs reappear on his own albums anyway), but I could be swayed.

Archives Vol. 1 Disc 2 probably has the most essential BS songs.

[bodysnatcher]

With Neil just make sure to start with "Landing on Water"

i'll admit that i've never listened to this album

[Strat]

With Neil just make sure to start with "Landing on Water"

i'll admit that i've never listened to this album

[bodysnatcher]

just queued up this album, let's see here

[Simple Torture]

Look what you made me do, KD:

[doug rr]

just queued up this album, let's see here

dont do it

[Strat]

just queued up this album, let's see here

dont do it

Godspeed

[doug rr]

just queued up this album, let's see here

dont do it

Godspeed

what a horrible thing to do to someone..poor snatch

[Strat]

just queued up this album, let's see here

dont do it

Godspeed

what a horrible thing to do to someone..poor snatch

Its better than anything he's recorded with Promise of the Real.....

[doug rr]

just queued up this album, let's see here

dont do it

Godspeed

what a horrible thing to do to someone..poor snatch

Its better than anything he's recorded with Promise of the Real.....

i think we lost him..hope you're happy

[Birds in Hell]

Landing on Water has some great songs, particularly Hippie Dream.

I’m definitely down/up for a catalogue review.

[doug rr]

its as if i don't know you guys anymore

[Strat]

its as if i don't know you guys anymore

Here you go doug

[YouTube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fZ1yigpTRA&t=1s[/YouTube]

[doug rr]

its as if i don't know you guys anymore

Here you go doug

[YouTube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fZ1yigpTRA&t=1s[/YouTube]

that scratches my itch, thank you

[bodysnatcher]

just queued up this album, let's see here

dont do it

Godspeed

what a horrible thing to do to someone..poor snatch

it's ok, i turned it off midway through the second song

[Kevin Davis]

Nice list, ST. I would make a list like that of my own, but I can just look at the spines of my CD's and get the same information

[Simple Torture]

Nice list, ST. I would make a list like that of my own, but I can just look at the spines of my CD's and get the same information

I like you.

I would still have to make a mix of the unreleased songs on the other Archives Vol. 1 discs. And I didn't include any CSNY, either. Then there are a couple of random singles as well.

[bodysnatcher]

Neil Old