March Madness 2019: Best Live Song!* Go Wins!

[PHATJ]

This tournament has inspired me to cheat and listen to more of ridleybradout’s collection. This has been a pleasure to listen to, man. Thank you.

How can listening constitute as cheating?

I wasn’t being literal. I’m listening to songs before they come up in the tournament. Usually I play along as they are posted, but surprisingly, this has re-interested me in listening to live PJ, which hasn’t happened in a few years. And mostly I’ve been sticking with ridley’s compilation because it’s really solid.

[stip]

Im away from home. I should be back to close out the round this afternoon.

[stip]

Round is closed

37. Whipping over Getaway (21-1)
38. Undone over Comatose (11-10)
39. Unemployable over Sleeping By Myself (16-5)
40. Black Red Yellow over Bu$hleaguer (14-4)

[stip]

Round is closed

41. Untitled over Let Me Sleep (9-7)
42. Brain of J over Once (14-6)
43. Leash over Wash (10-10) - staying open another round
44. Betterman over Down (14-4)

[stip]

That was a fantastic version of Let Me Sleep, btw. It had no business losing that match. I wasn't familiar with that performance prior to this, but it was gorgeous.

[stip]

Why isn't Eddie signing and recording everything in that register?

[stip]

I mean, are you people even listening to these songs?!

[PHATJ]

Not chud

[Norah]

Stip on 2016 Eddie Vedder: Why hasn't he always sang like this!?

[stip]

that is peak Eddie Vedder on that track. I wish we got that all the time in 2016

[stip]

i will not have time to close this out until tomorrow evening, so it’ll stay open until then

[PHATJ]

I’m glad this round has been open forever, I’m finally getting a chance to listen to these now. I’ve already changed one vote after having a chance to actually hear the version chosen.

[stip]

Round is closed

43. Wash over leash 16-10
45. Around the Bend over Johnny Guitar 15-6
46. Who You Are over Lightning Bolt 12-8
47. All Those Yesterdays over Fatal 11-10
48. Why Go over Long Road 10-10(staying open another round)

[stip]

Round is closed

49. Oceans vs Let the Records Play (12-0)
50. Tremor Christ over Bee Girl (15-0)
51. Jeremy over Half Full (10-2)
52. Rats over Rival (8-5)


Why Go vs. Long Road is open 1 more round

[VinylGuy]

that is peak Eddie Vedder on that track. I wish we got that all the time in 2016

You should get the Padova 2018 bootleg.

[stip]

Round is closed

48. Long Road vs. Why Go is open one more round
53. Strangest Tribe over Hold On 11-7
54. Mind Your Manners over Sweet Lew 9-7
55. Got Some over I’m Open 13-4
56. Smile over I am Mine 10-6

[stip]

Round is closed

48. Why Go over Long Road 12-11 (finally!)
57. Hard to Imagine over Push Me/Pull Me 14-3
58. Light Years over Parachutes 13-5
59. Come Back over Soon Forget 8-5
60. State of Love and Trust over Off he Goes 10-9

[stip]

Round is closed

61. Even Flow over Dean man (17-5)
62. Indifference over Severed Hand (12-8)
63. Alone over Just Breathe (14-5)
64. All or None over I Got Shit (11-7)
'



All or None's win feels like the biggest upset thus far

[stip]

Round is closed:

65. Elderly Woman vs. Animal 12-4
66. Breakerfall vs. Thin Air 13-6
67. Grievance vs. Falling Down 18-1
68. Alive vs. Last Soldier 12-3

[doone]

That should read:
65. Animal VS. Elderly Woman 12-4