Gigaton: Official album thread

[Jorge]

And that crappy Basmati Blues song

[McParadigm]

Ed has released one tune the past 6 years....'Out of Sand'. Stone has released close to nothing since LB (only those 2 brad tracks).

Grim

tho I still say, “great. retire. be a dad instead of a rockstar. it’s the right choice.”

[joostone]

And that crappy Basmati Blues song

Oh yeah...Haha, well then he released 3 songs. Three times more than Eddie.....

[joostone]

R.E.M worked differently. After 'out of time' and 'automatic' Peter Buck wanted a rock record to tour. So he wrote most of 'Monster'. Mike Mills worked very hard on 'Reveal' and 'Around the Sun'. Around the Sun was a huge flop. Peter even stated in interviews that he did not like that record. Well, they grew apart. They acknowledged that and talked about it. They came back as inspired as ever with 'Accelerate'. Why I tell this? Well, from on outside perspective on PJ it seems that they are not talking about it, maybe they don't even acknowledge they are not functioning creatively as a band. Nor does Ed let Jeff take the wheel for the next record. REM did seem to acknowledge when they were on a low point. Also in that band it seemed that they gave each other creative control over the band at times. At this moment PJ could clearly benefit from both.

Can you imagine that this could even happen in Pearl Jam? That jeff would go on record saying that he doesn't like 'LB'? Or that Ed's hand the creative control over to Jeff for the next record?

[bodysnatcher]

guys, why are we pushing them to write new songs? they're gonna suck and we'll just get further depressed and angry.

[verb_to_trust]

Ed doesn't have a creative bone in his body at this point only unlike Stipe he will not let go of the wheel.

[EJ]

he should just buy, and then manage a baseball team

[McParadigm]

Maybe he can help out with North Korea. I understand that his emotional support was reeeeal valuable to Dennis. Award speech shoutout-level helpful.

[bodysnatcher]

Maybe he can help out with North Korea. I understand that his emotional support was reeeeal valuable to Dennis. Award speech shoutout-level helpful.

now i'm just imagining "Black Red Yellow" with a Kim Jong-un voicemail

[VinylGuy]

I was happy with Stone´s involvement in the cornell show. Specially with him and Jeff talking about moving forward with the new PJ album.

[dprival78]

stone hasn't written a good riff since do the evolution

[Strat]

stone hasn't written a good riff since do the evolution

*Rival

[McParadigm]

stone hasn't written a good riff since do the evolution

*Rival

I don’t know that I had ever really noticed how absent he is from post-Binaural writing credits, until this post. Odd that he powered down for their “return to form” phase, of all things.

[dprival78]

stone hasn't written a good riff since do the evolution

*Rival

Of course.. how did I forget that one?

[bodysnatcher]

stone hasn't written a good riff since do the evolution

*Rival

Of course.. how did I forget that one?

waiting for PHATJ to come in here spewing his bullshit about "Amongst the Waves"

[tree_]

I guess, now that I think about it, stone might be the most talented

[tree_]

When he's on

[digster]

Especially when you consider those solo albums, I think even BS/LB fans would agree that there are aspects to the outside work that could strengthen the albums the bands are making, and expand what they're capable of doing. But it's impossible to imagine songs like those making a PJ record right now. I'm just curious as to what part of the decision-making process is leading to a relatively narrow framework they're working off of? Is it just Eddie is not interested in that kind of music? It just seems like they've narrowed what they allow onto a PJ record into a relatively narrow box, which is all the more odd because they were never a band known for a particular, identifiable musical trademark (like Edge's guitar with U2, for example).

[tree_]

Yes. And I think that's what's left the sort of fan I was feeling abandoned and disinterested. I liked them for their sense of rebellion and relentlessness and strength in the face of adversity. Now it feels like they have forsaken all their great qualities. For what? It feels lazy and empty.

[McParadigm]

They just need to get into rap battles