Pick a song and sing: The STP tourney

[Iholdthepain]

I would have picked ILS yeah, Plush, while i love it, its kinda like picking Jeremy on a second round. I thought about picking it and nope, i prefer other songs.

Jeremy is first round talent, bub.

And for the record, I've never liked Plush all that much. Even when it was the only STP song that I'd heard, I was pretty luke warm on it. I like it a lot more now than I did back then. But still, it can't be denied that without that song we probably don't know who STP are. And that's huge.

Eff Plush... That song only existed because of Alice in Chains, Pearl Jam, and label pressures to sound like Seattle. I tend to think the real Weiland would have emerged to the masses regardless of that manufactured hit.

[Iholdthepain]

My Pick:

And So I Know

Noice!

Where the hell is PhatJ? Did you pm him?

[Jammer XCI]

I would have picked ILS yeah, Plush, while i love it, its kinda like picking Jeremy on a second round. I thought about picking it and nope, i prefer other songs.

Jeremy is first round talent, bub.

And for the record, I've never liked Plush all that much. Even when it was the only STP song that I'd heard, I was pretty luke warm on it. I like it a lot more now than I did back then. But still, it can't be denied that without that song we probably don't know who STP are. And that's huge.

Eff Plush... That song only existed because of Alice in Chains, Pearl Jam, and label pressures to sound like Seattle. I tend to think the real Weiland would have emerged to the masses regardless of that manufactured hit.

I don’t know about that, on the Core boxset the 1990 demo of Plush sounds pretty much the same musically, although it doesn’t have the same chorus and lyrics.

Which someone asked earlier about, I didn’t actually buy the box set but I downloaded all the live and demo material that was on it and it’s all classic STP. The live version of Where the River Goes on there ends with Weiland berating the crowd for throwing beer bottles and he tells them to throw drugs on stage instead.

[PHATJ]

My next pick is Ride the Cliche

[PHATJ]

My Pick:

And So I Know

Noice!

Where the hell is PhatJ? Did you pm him?

No pm and no thread title update. Wtf?!

[Bammer]

I would have picked ILS yeah, Plush, while i love it, its kinda like picking Jeremy on a second round. I thought about picking it and nope, i prefer other songs.

Jeremy is first round talent, bub.

And for the record, I've never liked Plush all that much. Even when it was the only STP song that I'd heard, I was pretty luke warm on it. I like it a lot more now than I did back then. But still, it can't be denied that without that song we probably don't know who STP are. And that's huge.

Eff Plush... That song only existed because of Alice in Chains, Pearl Jam, and label pressures to sound like Seattle. I tend to think the real Weiland would have emerged to the masses regardless of that manufactured hit.

I don’t know about that, on the Core boxset the 1990 demo of Plush sounds pretty much the same musically, although it doesn’t have the same chorus and lyrics.

Which someone asked earlier about, I didn’t actually buy the box set but I downloaded all the live and demo material that was on it and it’s all classic STP. The live version of Where the River Goes on there ends with Weiland berating the crowd for throwing beer bottles and he tells them to throw drugs on stage instead.

Can’t decide if totally badass or incredibly sad

[Chris_H_2]

a-hole troll post: whoever drafts "days of the week" deserves to lose this tourney regardless of his other picks.

[tragabigzanda]

[PHATJ]

I'm surprised to see people going single-crazy with their picks. Outside of Trippin' and Big Bang Baby, I wouldn't put many of their singles at the top of the food chain. No Way Out and Regeneration are still up for grabs?!

I haven’t picked a single yet.

1. Still Remains
2. Glide
3. Ride the Cliche

[EJ]

My next pick is Ride the Cliche

One of my favorite bridges. Love the guitar work in it.

[PHATJ]

My next pick is Ride the Cliche

One of my favorite bridges. Love the guitar work in it.

Totally agree. That my favorite part too.

[Jammer XCI]

I haven’t picked any singles yet either.

I’m totally living up to my “I’m only here for the RAWK “ reputation so far though.

[PHATJ]

You do you, jammer

[bada]

We are entering the best part of these drafts. Almost all the obvious songs are gone. You could take a song now that could be there in round 6 or bet on a song being there a couple rounds from now and it gets gobbled up early. This could be a reach, it might last a few more rounds but I think its their last great song and I want it.

Take A Load Off

[PHATJ]

Take a Load Off is definitely a reach, but also the best song from the last album without a doubt. Glide and Ride the Cliche are both probably reaches for me, but I love those songs and I’m happy to have them.

[wease]

And now, the inevitable LMS wait.

[Iholdthepain]

My Pick:

And So I Know

Noice!

Where the hell is PhatJ? Did you pm him?

No pm and no thread title update. Wtf?!

Reid clearly stated that he would be away from rm today for a memorial service, which is why the thread title and song list have not been updated.

[Iholdthepain]

And now, the inevitable LMS wait.

Nope...

I’m hitting bed. If my turn comes up draft me Too Cool Queenie.

...carry on...

[epilogue]

Thank god, LMS!

[wease]

And now, the inevitable LMS wait.

Nope...

I’m hitting bed. If my turn comes up draft me Too Cool Queenie.

...carry on...

Goddammit. That was going to be my next pick.



Heaven & Hot Rods