MadTIGERmaN wrote:
Jimi live from the Winterland is a pretty awesome 4 disc set. Get that and the Band of Gypsys 2 disc set and complete opening show set. The rest is for us diehards
Winterland box is a weird anomoly in that is some of the absolute best
and absolute
worst playing by the Experience.
It's also bullshit how they presented the stuff as compilations from each night and then left some of the best stuff as "bonus" stuff on the 4th disc. They also edited many things that didn't need to be edited. I have a friend who threw that set in the garbage can, he was so angry when he heard it.
It should have/could have been a really tight 2-disc set of unedited performances and probably would have sold a lot more copies too.
The BOG first set is excellent and probably the best of the 4 sets overall.
The BOG 2-disc set is a mixed bag, with some low fidelity stuff mixed in with rough mixes and stuff mixed by Hendrix too, since the multi-tracks were not yet available at the time it came out. Not essential.
I highly reccommend Miami Pop Festival 1968. It's up there with San Diego and London in terms of performance quality, and there is no embarrassing stuff like on the Winterland box.