Superblood Wolfmoon

[96583UP]

it's pretty clear though, based on how the drum beat starts off, that PJ lacks self-awareness of how many times when they get together to write songs, that they come in all 'excited' and this tempo is what comes out (edit: or that they do: and really don't care)

'time to jam, guys!' and then a quasi-Ramones wuss track starts playing

and they all do their Ramones/Who impression

and totally lose sight of the fact that they have put a song to print that sounds exactly like it 10 times before

'OK we did it! what a fun track! can't wait for people to hear this!'

[griffinxi]

some of pearl jam's best songs are simple power chord progressions. its a bad argument and makes you sound snotty. its one thing to not like a song, its another to pretend your opinion holds more weight b/c you "play guitar".

Why is "play guitar" in quotes? Do you disbelieve the statement?

DO YOU, SIR, IN FACT PLAY GUITAR AS YOU HAVE ALLEGED

[stip]

I was going to go through the whole song and pick out the words and how he actually sings them... I stopped after this because I can't make out much of anything else and didn't feel like trying that hard..

distance = dee-uh-stunce

If only could return to the perfect enunciation that was the hallmark of his prime

[96583UP]

a lot of funny posts over the last 47 pages

so much dischord

so many tortured souls

I love it

[tree_]

Yeah, I don't know how many of you play guitar but this power chord progression and how it's played is just so simple and predictable it's insulting

This is something i would have said when i was 18. (i play guitar)

Is it not true, though?

Yes, but what does that have to do with whether the song is good or not? It doesn't.

I'd agree if the song went somewhere.. showed any creativity... evoked emotion... They just keep repeating this boring progression though and it's hard to overlook.

I'm not arguing that you should like the chord progression, just that the basis of whether you do or don't should not come down to whether it's simple to play.

You're right. It's not why I don't like the song, but it's something that probably sticks out to most people who play guitar. In a song like Back in Black you don't have that problem because it's actually a good song. I noticed a lot of other comments on YouTube and elsewhere, in which people are pointing out the chords... it's just one of those progressions you always come up with right away when you learn power chords. I doubt anyone stumbled across the rhythm and feel of Back in Black.

[96583UP]

'word salad' might win it all

[96583UP]

Matt's hi-hat sounds like a chlamydic dick squirting out little bits of fiery peepee in those first few bars

LOL

[Ms Harmless]

if they had to start it with that basic drum beat, why couldn't they have added some background sounds behind Matt like we get right at the end? like weird noise bookends; the beat in the intro serves no purpose other than to "count them in", which um, there's no need for in studio

[tree_]

some of pearl jam's best songs are simple power chord progressions. its a bad argument and makes you sound snotty. its one thing to not like a song, its another to pretend your opinion holds more weight b/c you "play guitar".

Why is "play guitar" in quotes? Do you disbelieve the statement?

DO YOU, SIR, IN FACT PLAY GUITAR AS YOU HAVE ALLEGED

haha... yeah.. just offering insight.. the chords are indeed as easy to stumble across as you'd think, which gets a 0 for creativity

[stip]

I've always thought Shakespeare is overrated because his words use the same 26 letters everyone else does.

[stip]

And I'm a published author so I am excellent at identifying when letters of the alphabet are used.

[96583UP]

yeah but he uses an 'f' instead of an 's'

[tree_]

I've always thought Shakespeare is overrated because his words use the same 26 letters everyone else does.

Wow. That's not at all like what I am saying. That's as if I said this song sucks because they're playing guitars.

[Ms Harmless]

I've always thought Shakespeare is overrated because his words use the same 26 letters everyone else does.

do you bite your guitar pick at me, sir?

[Ms Harmless]

And I'm a published author so I am excellent at identifying when letters of the alphabet are used.

this was funny

[tree_]

And I'm a published author so I am excellent at identifying when letters of the alphabet are used.

I'm not saying I'm a great guitar player. That's exactly my point. I'm saying any dooface who picks up a guitar and googles how to play a power chord and strum in 4/4 will probably stumble across this progression in 5 minutes.

[stip]

well to be fair, I didn't say I'm a great author either.

[stip]

[tree_]

well to be fair, I didn't say I'm a great author either.

Still weren't fairly representing my actual point.

[VinylGuy]

And I'm a published author so I am excellent at identifying when letters of the alphabet are used.

I'm not saying I'm a great guitar player. That's exactly my point. I'm saying any dooface who picks up a guitar and googles how to play a power chord and strum in 4/4 will probably stumble across this progression in 5 minutes.

why is that a bad thing? ramones had great songs that were easy. My main problem with the song is that its not that interesting nor new. I like the chaotic element on in, love the production but its just an ok song for me.