RANK THE ALBUMS

[Ms Harmless]

Gigaton will be my 8th favourite album

[Hatfield]

TEN

1. Once - 4
2. Even Flow - 4.5
3. Alive - 5
4. Why Go - 4
5. Black - 5
6. Jeremy - 4.5
7. Oceans - 4
8. Porch - 5
9. Garden - 4
10. Deep - 4
11. Release - 5

Average: 4.45

VS.

1. Go - 5
2. Animal - 5
3. Daughter - 5
4. Glorified G - 4
5. Dissident - 4.5
6. W.M.A. - 5
7. Blood - 4.5
8. Rearviewmirror - 5
9. Rats - 4.5
10. Elderly Woman... - 4.5
11. Leash - 3.5
12. Indifference - 4.5

Average: 4.3
VITALOGY

1. Last Exit - 4
2. Spin the Black Circle - 4
3. Not for You - 5
4. Tremor Christ - 5
5. Nothingman - 5
6. Whipping - 4.5
7. Pry, To - 3
8. Corduroy - 5
9. Bugs - 3
10. Satan's Bed - 4.5
11. Better Man - 5
12. Aye Davanita - 4
13. Immortality - 5
14. Stupid Mop - N/A

Average: 4

NO CODE

1. Sometimes - 5
2. Hail, Hail - 5
3. Who You Are - 5
4. In My Tree - 5
5. Smile - 4.5
6. Off He Goes - 5
7. Habit - 4
8. Red Mosquito - 5
9. Lukin - 4
10. Present Tense - 4.5
11. Mankind - 4
12. I'm Open - 4
13. Around the Bend - 4

Average: 4.53

YIELD

1. Brain of J. - 5
2. Faithfull - 5
3. No Way - 4
4. Given to Fly - 5
5. Wishlist - 5
6. Pilate - 3.5
7. Do the Evolution - 5
8. Red Dot - 3
9. MFC - 4
10. Low Light - 4.5
11. In Hiding - 5
12. Push Me, Pull Me - 4
13. All Those Yesterdays - 5

Average: 4.46

BINAURAL

1. Breakerfall - 4
2. Gods' Dice - 4
3. Evacuation - 2
4. Light Years - 4
5. Nothing as It Seems - 3
6. Thin Air - 3.5
7. Insignificance - 4
8. Of the Girl - 5
9. Grievance - 5
10. Rival - 4
11. Sleight of Hand - 4
12. Soon Forget - 4
13. Parting Ways - 5

Average: 3.88

RIOT ACT

1. Cant Keep - 4
2. Save You - 4
3. Love Boat Captain - 4
4. Cropduster - 4
5. Ghost - 3.5
6. I am Mine - 4.5
7. Thumbing My Way - 3.5
8. You Are - 3.5
9. Get Right - 4
10. Green Disease - 4
11. Help Help - 3.5
12. Bu$hleaguer - 4
13. 1/2 Full - 4
14. Arc - 5
15. All or None - 5

Average: 4

PEARL JAM

1. Life Wasted - 4.5
2. World Wide Suicide - 3
3. Comatose - 4
4. Severed Hand - 5
5. Marker in the Sand - 5
6. Parachutes - 4
7. Unemployable - 4
8. Big Wave - 1
9. Gone - 3
10. Wasted Reprise - 3
11. Army Reserve - 3.5
12. Come Back - 4
13. Inside Job - 2

Average: 3.54

BACKSPACER

1. Gonna See My Friend - 3.5
2. Got Some - 2
3. The Fixer - 1
4. Johnny Guitar - 4
5. Just Breathe - 4
6. Amongst the Waves - 3.5
7. Unthought Known - 3.5
8. Supersonic - 3.5
9. Speed of Sound - 3.5
10. Force of Nature - 1
11. The End - 5

Average: 3.13

LIGHTNING BOLT

1. Getaway - 3.5
2. Mind Your Manners - 3
3. My Father's Son - 3.5
4. Sirens - 3
5. Lightning Bolt - 4
6. Infallible - 3
7. Pendulum - 4
8. Swallowed Whole - 5
9. Let the Records Play - 3
10. Sleeping by Myself - 3
11. Yellow Moon - 3
12. Future Days - 3

Average: 3.4

Overall:

1. No Code
2. Yield
3. Ten
4. Vs.
5. Vitalogy
6. Riot Act
7. Binaural
8. Lightning Bolt
9. Backspacer

I've never done this before. That was fun! I'd put Vs. higher than 10 if I was going on pure enjoyment, but this looks accurate to me.

[giveway]

1)Yield 4.375
2)Vitalogy 4.3
3)No Code 4.166
4)Binaural 4.111
5)Ten 4.090
6)VS 3.833
7)Riot Act 3.465
8)Lightning Bolt 3.25
9)Avocado 3.166
10)Backspacer 2.636

Gigaton
DOTC: 4.5 (this one has a potential of becoming a 5, if it stands the test of time)
SBWM: 3.5

Ten

Once: 4
Evenflow: 4
Alive: 4.5
Why Go: 4
Black: 5
Jeremy: 4.5
Oceans: 3.5
Porch: 4,5
Garden: 4
Deep: 2
Release: 5

Ten AVG : 4.090

Vs.

Go: 4
Animal: 4
Daughter: 4
Glorified G: 3
Dissident: 3
W.M.A.: 3.5
Blood: 3,5
Rearviewmirror: 5
Rats: 4
Elderly Woman: 4
Leash: 3
Indifference: 5

Vs. AVG: 3.833

Vitalogy

Last Exit: 5
Spin The Black Circle: 4
Not For You: 4
Tremor Christ: 5
Nothingman: 5
Whipping: 3.5
Corduroy: 5
Satan’s Bed: 2
Better Man: 4.5
Immortality: 5

Vitalogy AVG: 4.3

No Code

Sometimes: 4
Hail Hail: 5
Who You Are: 4.5
In My Tree: 5
Smile: 4,5
Off He Goes: 5
Habit: 2.5
Red Mosquito: 4.5
Lukin: 4
Present Tense - 5
Mankind: 2
Around The Bend: 4

No Code AVG: 4.166

Yield

Brain of J: 4.5
Faithful: 5
No Way: 4.5
Given to Fly: 5
Wishlist: 4.5
Pilate: 2.5
Do the Evolution: 5
MFC: 4
Low Light: 5
In Hiding: 5
Push Me, Pull Me: 3
All Those Yesterdays: 4.5

Yield AVG: 4.375

Binaural

Breakherfall: 4
God’s Dice: 3.5
Evacuation: 2.5
Light Years: 4,5
Nothing As It Seems: 4.5
Thin Air: 3.5
Insignificance: 5
Of the Girl: 4,5
Grievance: 5
Rival: 4.5
Sleight of Hand: 4
Soon Forget: 3.5
Parting Ways: 4.5

Binaural AVG: 4.111

Riot Act

Can’t Keep: 3.5
Save You: 3.5
Love Boat Captain: 4
Cropduster: 3.5
Ghost: 2.5
I Am Mine: 4
Thumbing My Way: 3.5
You Are: 3.5
Get Right: 3
Green Disease: 4
Help Help: 3.5
Bu$hleaguer: 3.5
1/2 Full: 3
All or None: 3.5

Riot Act AVG: 3.465

Self-Titled:

Life Wasted: 4
World Wide Suicide: 3.5
Comatose: 3
Severed Hand: 3.5
Marker in the Sand: 3.5
Parachutes: 4
Unemployable: 2.5
Big Wave: 2
Gone: 2
Army Reserve: 3
Comeback: 3.5
Inside Job: 3.5

Self Titled AVG: 3.166

Backspacer

Gonna See My Friend: 3
Got Some: 4
The Fixer: 3
Johnny Guitar: 2
Just Breathe: 1
Amongst the Waves: 2
Unthought Known: 5
Supersonic : 1
Speed of Sound: 1
Force of Nature: 4
The End: 3

Backspacer AVG: 2.636

Lightning Bolt

Getaway: 4
Mind Your Manners: 3.5
My Father’s Son: 4
Sirens: 4
Lightning Bolt: 4
Infallible: 3.5
Pendulum: 3.5
Swallowed Whole: 2.5
Let the Records Play: 1
Sleeping By Myself: 3.5
Yellow Moon: 4.5
Future Days: 1

Lightning Bolt AVG: 3.25

[Parrhesia]

Binaural
No Code
Yield
Vitalogy
Riot Act
Vs
Ten
Avocado
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

[PHATJ]

Binaural
No Code
Yield
Vitalogy
Riot Act
Vs
Ten
Avocado
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

GIGATRON!!!

[Jaeti]

Looking at this, there's a clear window for Gigaton to become my #6 album. Hard to imagine that actually coming to pass, but there's room. (Also, I'm arbitrarily deciding to rank/ignore certain "filler" tracks.)

1. Vitalogy - 4.1
2. Yield - 4.00
3. Ten - 3.95
4. No Code - 3.92
5. Vs. - 3.88
6. Binaural - 3.46
7. Riot Act - 3.40
8. S/T - 3.31
9. Lightning Bolt - 3.29
10. Backspacer - 3.18

Ten
1. Once - 2
2. Even Flow - 4
3. Alive - 4
4. Why Go - 2.5
5. Black - 5
6. Jeremy - 5
7. Oceans - 4.5
8. Porch - 5
9. Garden - 3
10. Deep - 3.5
11. Release - 5

Vs.
1. Go - 4.5
2. Animal - 3.5
3. Daughter - 4.5
4. Glorified G - 3
5. Dissident - 3
6. WMA - 3
7. Blood - 4
8. Rearviewmirror - 5
9. Rats - 4
10. Elderly Woman - 4.5
11. Leash - 3.5
12. Indifference - 4

Vitalogy
1. Last Exit - 4.5
2. Spin the Black Circle - 3.5
3. Not For You - 5
4. Tremor Christ - 4.5
5. Nothingman - 4.5
6. Whipping - 3
7. Pry, To - n/a
8. Corduroy - 5
9. Bugs - 2
10. Satan's Bed - 4
11. Betterman - 4
12. Aye Davanita - n/a
13. Immortality - 5
14. Stupid Mop - n/a

No Code
1. Sometimes - 5
2. Hail, Hail, - 5
3. Who You Are - 3.5
4. In My Tree - 5
5. Smile - 5
6. Off He Goes - 4.5
7. Habit - 3
8. Red Mosquito - 3.5
9. Lukin - 4
10. Present Tense - 5
11. Mankind - 1.5
12. I'm Open - 2
13. Around the Bend - 4

Yield
1. Brain of J - 4.5
2. Faithfull - 4
3. No Way - 3
4. Given to Fly - 5
5. Wishlist - 3.5
6. Pilate - 2
7. Do the Evolution - 5
8. Red Dot - n/a
9. MFC - 3.5
10. Lowlight - 4.5
11. In Hiding - 5
12. Push Me, Pull Me - 3
13. All Those Yesterdays - 4

Binaural
1. Breakerfall - 3
2. God's Dice - 2.5
3. Evacuation - 3
4. Light Years - 4
5. Nothing As It Seems - 4.5
6. Thin Air - 3
7. Insignificance - 5
8. Of the Girl - 3.5
9. Grievance - 5
10. Rival - 4
11. Sleight of Hand - 3.5
12. Soon Forget - 1.5
13. Parting Ways - 3.5

Riot Act
1. Can't Keep - 4.5
2. Save You - 4
3. Love Boat Captain - 4
4. Cropduster - 4.5
5. Ghost - 3.5
6. I Am Mine - 3
7. Thumbing My Way - 3
8. You Are - 3.5
9. Get Right - 1.5
10. Green Disease - 3
11. Help, Help - 4
12. Bushleaguer - 3
13. Half Full - 3.5
14. Arc - 3
15. All or None - 3

S/T
1. Life Wasted - 4
2. World Wide Suicide - 2.5
3. Comatose - 3.5
4. Severed Hand - 3
5. Marker in the Sand - 4
6. Parachutes - 4.5
7. Unemployable - 3
8. Big Wave - 3
9. Gone - 2.5
10. Wasted Reprise - 3
11. Army Reserve - 3
12. Come Back - 4
13. Inside Job - 3

Backspacer
1. Gonna See My Friend - 3
2. Got Some - 3
3. The Fixer - 2
4. Johnny Guitar - 4
5. Just Breathe - 3
6. Amongst the Waves - 3
7. Unthought Known - 4.5
8. Supersonic - 1.5
9. Speed of Sound - 3.5
10. Force of Nature - 4
11. The End - 3.5

Lightning Bolt
1. Getaway - 3
2. Mind Your Manners - 3
3. My Father's Son - 3
4. Sirens - 4
5. Lightning Bolt - 4.5
6. Infallible - 3.5
7. Pendulum - 3.5
8. Swallowed Whole - 3.5
9. Let the Records Play - 2
10. Sleeping By Myself - 3
11. Yellow Moon - 3.5
12. Future Days - 3

[PHATJ]

Superblood Wolfmoon took her away too soon

[Birds in Hell]

Did this pretty quickly and instinctively, borrowing Jaeti's well-organised list.

No half points.

Ten (AVG 3.72)
1. Once - 5
2. Even Flow - 4
3. Alive - 3
4. Why Go - 3
5. Black - 3
6. Jeremy - 4
7. Oceans - 5
8. Porch - 4
9. Garden - 3
10. Deep - 4
11. Release - 3

Vs. (AVG 4.16)
1. Go - 5
2. Animal - 5
3. Daughter - 5
4. Glorified G - 4
5. Dissident - 3
6. WMA - 4
7. Blood - 4
8. Rearviewmirror - 4
9. Rats - 5
10. Elderly Woman - 3
11. Leash - 3
12. Indifference - 5

Vitalogy (AVG 3.28)
1. Last Exit - 5
2. Spin the Black Circle - 3
3. Not For You - 4
4. Tremor Christ - 5
5. Nothingman - 3
6. Whipping - 3
7. Pry, To - 4
8. Corduroy - 5
9. Bugs - 2
10. Satan's Bed - 4
11. Better Man - 3
12. Aye Davanita - 1
13. Immortality - 3
14. Stupid Mop - 1

No Code (AVG 4.15)
1. Sometimes - 5
2. Hail, Hail, - 5
3. Who You Are - 3
4. In My Tree - 4
5. Smile - 5
6. Off He Goes - 5
7. Habit - 4
8. Red Mosquito - 4
9. Lukin - 4
10. Present Tense - 4
11. Mankind - 4
12. I'm Open - 3
13. Around the Bend - 4

Yield (AVG 3.76)
1. Brain of J - 5
2. Faithfull - 5
3. No Way - 4
4. Given to Fly - 4
5. Wishlist - 3
6. Pilate - 3
7. Do the Evolution - 5
8. Red Dot - 3
9. MFC - 3
10. Lowlight - 2
11. In Hiding - 3
12. Push Me, Pull Me - 5
13. All Those Yesterdays - 4

Binaural (AVG 3.46)
1. Breakerfall - 3
2. God's Dice - 4
3. Evacuation - 5
4. Light Years - 3
5. Nothing As It Seems - 3
6. Thin Air - 3
7. Insignificance - 5
8. Of the Girl - 4
9. Grievance - 3
10. Rival - 3
11. Sleight of Hand - 5
12. Soon Forget - 2
13. Parting Ways - 2

Riot Act (AVG 3)
1. Can't Keep - 3
2. Save You - 2
3. Love Boat Captain - 3
4. Cropduster - 5
5. Ghost - 4
6. I Am Mine - 2
7. Thumbing My Way - 3
8. You Are - 3
9. Get Right - 4
10. Green Disease - 2
11. Help, Help - 4
12. Bushleaguer - 2
13. Half Full - 2
14. Arc - 2
15. All or None - 4

S/T (AVG 3.23)
1. Life Wasted - 4
2. World Wide Suicide - 2
3. Comatose - 4
4. Severed Hand - 2
5. Marker in the Sand - 3
6. Parachutes - 4
7. Unemployable - 5
8. Big Wave - 5
9. Gone - 3
10. Wasted Reprise - 2
11. Army Reserve - 3
12. Come Back - 2
13. Inside Job - 3

Backspacer (AVG 2.09)
1. Gonna See My Friend - 2
2. Got Some - 1
3. The Fixer - 3
4. Johnny Guitar - 4
5. Just Breathe - 2
6. Amongst the Waves - 2
7. Unthought Known - 2
8. Supersonic - 1
9. Speed of Sound - 3
10. Force of Nature - 1
11. The End - 2

Lightning Bolt (AVG 2)
1. Getaway - 2
2. Mind Your Manners - 2
3. My Father's Son - 4
4. Sirens - 1
5. Lightning Bolt - 2
6. Infallible - 2
7. Pendulum - 2
8. Swallowed Whole - 3
9. Let the Records Play - 3
10. Sleeping By Myself - 1
11. Yellow Moon - 1
12. Future Days - 1

Which makes my album ranking:

Vs. (AVG 4.16)
No Code (AVG 4.15)
Yield (AVG 3.76)
Ten (AVG 3.72)
Binaural (AVG 3.46)
Vitalogy (AVG 3.28)
S/T (AVG 3.23)
Riot Act (AVG 3)
Backspacer (AVG 2.09)
Lightning Bolt (AVG 2)

Almost exactly how I'd rank them otherwise, though I'd move Vitalogy above Binaural.

My five star songs:

Once
Oceans
Go
Animal
Daughter
Rats
Indifference
Last Exit
Tremor Christ
Sometimes
Hail, Hail
Off He Goes
Brain of J.
Faithfull
Push Me Pull Me
Evacuation
Insignificance
Sleight of Hand
Cropduster
Unemployable
Big Wave

[Anders]

This thread has really been excellent lately. Enjoy both the ratings and the stories.

[BootsToAsses]

My girlfriend wanted to do this, so here goes

TEN

1. Once - 4
2. Even Flow - 4
3. Alive - 5
4. Why Go - 3
5. Black - 5
6. Jeremy - 3.5
7. Oceans - 3
8. Porch - 5
9. Garden - 5
10. Deep - 5
11. Release - 5

Average: 4.31

VS.

1. Go - 4
2. Animal - 5
3. Daughter - 4
4. Glorified G - 2
5. Dissident - 5
6. W.M.A. - 3
7. Blood - 4
8. Rearviewmirror - 5
9. Rats - 4
10. Elderly Woman... - 5
11. Leash - 4
12. Indifference - 5

Average: 4.16

VITALOGY

1. Last Exit - 4.5
2. Spin the Black Circle - 4
3. Not for You - 3
4. Tremor Christ - 5
5. Nothingman - 4.5
6. Whipping - 3.5
7. Pry, To - 2
8. Corduroy - 4.5
9. Bugs - 5
10. Satan's Bed - 3.5
11. Better Man - 5
12. Aye Davanita - 2
13. Immortality - 5
14. Stupid Mop - N/A

Average: 3.96

NO CODE

1. Sometimes - 4
2. Hail, Hail - 4.5
3. Who You Are - 3.5
4. In My Tree - 4.5
5. Smile - 4
6. Off He Goes - 4.5
7. Habit - 4
8. Red Mosquito - 5
9. Lukin - 4.5
10. Present Tense - 5
11. Mankind - 4
12. I'm Open - 1
13. Around the Bend - 3

Average: 3.96

YIELD

1. Brain of J. - 5
2. Faithfull - 5
3. No Way - 3.5
4. Given to Fly - 5
5. Wishlist - 4.5
6. Pilate - 4.5
7. Do the Evolution - 5
8. Red Dot - 4
9. MFC - 4
10. Low Light - 3.5
11. In Hiding - 4.5
12. Push Me, Pull Me - 3
13. All Those Yesterdays - 3.5

Average: 4.23

BINAURAL

1. Breakerfall - 4.5
2. Gods' Dice - 4
3. Evacuation - 4
4. Light Years - 3.5
5. Nothing as It Seems - 3.5
6. Thin Air - 4
7. Insignificance - 4
8. Of the Girl - 4.5
9. Grievance - 4.5
10. Rival - 4
11. Sleight of Hand - 4
12. Soon Forget - 3.5
13. Parting Ways - 4

Average: 4

RIOT ACT

1. Cant Keep - 4.5
2. Save You - 4
3. Love Boat Captain - 4.5
4. Cropduster - 4
5. Ghost - 4
6. I am Mine - 5
7. Thumbing My Way - 4.5
8. You Are - 4.5
9. Get Right - 2.5
10. Green Disease - 4.5
11. Help Help - 3.5
12. Bu$hleaguer - 4
13. 1/2 Full - 5
14. Arc - 1
15. All or None - 4

Average: 3.96

PEARL JAM

1. Life Wasted - 5
2. World Wide Suicide - 4.5
3. Comatose - 5
4. Severed Hand - 5
5. Marker in the Sand - 4.5
6. Parachutes - 3.5
7. Unemployable - 3.5
8. Big Wave - 3
9. Gone - 5
10. Wasted Reprise - 3
11. Army Reserve - 3.5
12. Come Back - 4.5
13. Inside Job - 4.5

Average: 4.192

BACKSPACER

1. Gonna See My Friend - 3.5
2. Got Some - 3.5
3. The Fixer - 1.5
4. Johnny Guitar - 1.5
5. Just Breathe - 2
6. Amongst the Waves - 3
7. Unthought Known - 4.5
8. Supersonic - 4
9. Speed of Sound - 3.5
10. Force of Nature - 3
11. The End - 3.5

Average: 3.04

LIGHTNING BOLT

1. Getaway - 4
2. Mind Your Manners - 4
3. My Father's Son - 3
4. Sirens - 3.5
5. Lightning Bolt - 5
6. Infallible - 4.5
7. Pendulum - 5
8. Swallowed Whole - 2
9. Let the Records Play - 2.5
10. Sleeping by Myself - 3
11. Yellow Moon - 2.5
12. Future Days - 3

Average: 3.5

Overall ranking:

1. Ten
2. Yield
3. Vs
4. Avocado
5. Binaural
6. Vitalogy/No Code/Riot Act
7. Lightning Bolt
8. Backspacer

[taffer]

Binaural (56 - 4,3)
Riot Act (59 - 3,93)
No Code (47 - 3,61)
Ten (39 - 3,54)
S/T (45 - 3,46)
Yield (41 - 3,41)
Vitalogy (40 - 3,33)
Vs. (37 - 3,08)
Lightning Bolt (36 - 3)
Backspacer (32 - 2,90)
==========================

Ten (39 - 3,54)
1. Once - 3
2. Even Flow - 3
3. Alive - 3
4. Why Go - 2
5. Black - 5
6. Jeremy - 4
7. Oceans - 1
8. Porch - 5
9. Garden - 5
10. Deep - 5
11. Release - 3

Vs. (37 - 3,08)
1. Go - 4
2. Animal - 4
3. Daughter - 2
4. Glorified G - 2
5. Dissident - 1
6. WMA - 5
7. Blood - 4
8. Rearviewmirror - 5
9. Rats - 5
10. Elderly Woman - 1
11. Leash - 3
12. Indifference - 1

Vitalogy (40 - 3,33)
1. Last Exit - 3
2. Spin the Black Circle - 5
3. Not For You - 5
4. Tremor Christ - 5
5. Nothingman - 1
6. Whipping - 4
7. Pry, To - n/a
8. Corduroy - 5
9. Bugs - 1
10. Satan's Bed - 3
11. Betterman - 1
12. Aye Davanita - n/a
13. Immortality - 4
14. Stupid Mop - 3

No Code (47 - 3,61)
1. Sometimes - 1
2. Hail, Hail, - 5
3. Who You Are - 3
4. In My Tree - 5
5. Smile - 5
6. Off He Goes - 1
7. Habit - 5
8. Red Mosquito - 4
9. Lukin - 4
10. Present Tense - 5
11. Mankind - 3
12. I'm Open - 5
13. Around the Bend - 1

Yield (41 - 3,41)
1. Brain of J - 4
2. Faithfull - 4
3. No Way - 5
4. Given to Fly - 3
5. Wishlist - 2
6. Pilate - 2
7. Do the Evolution - 4
8. Red Dot - n/a
9. MFC - 3
10. Lowlight - 1
11. In Hiding - 4
12. Push Me, Pull Me - 5
13. All Those Yesterdays - 4

Binaural (56 - 4,3)
1. Breakerfall - 3
2. God's Dice - 5
3. Evacuation - 5
4. Light Years - 5
5. Nothing As It Seems - 5
6. Thin Air - 3
7. Insignificance - 5
8. Of the Girl - 5
9. Grievance - 5
10. Rival - 5
11. Sleight of Hand - 5
12. Soon Forget - 1
13. Parting Ways - 4

Riot Act (59 - 3,93)
1. Can't Keep - 3
2. Save You - 4
3. Love Boat Captain - 4
4. Cropduster - 4
5. Ghost - 5
6. I Am Mine - 3
7. Thumbing My Way - 1
8. You Are - 5
9. Get Right - 4
10. Green Disease - 5
11. Help, Help - 5
12. Bushleaguer - 5
13. Half Full - 5
14. Arc - 4
15. All or None - 2

S/T (45 - 3,46)
1. Life Wasted - 4
2. World Wide Suicide - 3
3. Comatose - 3
4. Severed Hand - 5
5. Marker in the Sand - 3
6. Parachutes - 5
7. Unemployable - 4
8. Big Wave - 4
9. Gone - 3
10. Wasted Reprise - 4
11. Army Reserve - 2
12. Come Back - 1
13. Inside Job - 4

Backspacer (32 - 2,90)
1. Gonna See My Friend - 3
2. Got Some - 4
3. The Fixer - 3
4. Johnny Guitar - 5
5. Just Breathe - 1
6. Amongst the Waves - 2
7. Unthought Known - 2
8. Supersonic - 3
9. Speed of Sound - 3
10. Force of Nature - 5
11. The End - 1

Lightning Bolt (36 - 3)
1. Getaway - 3
2. Mind Your Manners - 3
3. My Father's Son - 5
4. Sirens - 3
5. Lightning Bolt - 2
6. Infallible - 5
7. Pendulum - 5
8. Swallowed Whole - 2
9. Let the Records Play - 2
10. Sleeping By Myself - 3
11. Yellow Moon - 2
12. Future Days - 1

[liebzz]

Gotta try this and see where it takes me:

Ten (AVG 4.18)
1. Once - 4
2. Even Flow - 4
3. Alive - 5
4. Why Go - 4
5. Black - 3
6. Jeremy - 5
7. Oceans - 5
8. Porch - 5
9. Garden - 3
10. Deep - 3
11. Release - 5

Vs. (AVG 4.33)
1. Go - 5
2. Animal - 5
3. Daughter - 4
4. Glorified G - 4
5. Dissident - 3
6. WMA - 5
7. Blood - 4
8. Rearviewmirror - 5
9. Rats - 5
10. Elderly Woman - 4
11. Leash - 3
12. Indifference - 5

Vitalogy (AVG 4.0)
1. Last Exit - 5
2. Spin the Black Circle - 4
3. Not For You - 5
4. Tremor Christ - 5
5. Nothingman - 4
6. Whipping - 4
7. Pry, To - 3
8. Corduroy - 5
9. Bugs - 4
10. Satan's Bed - 4
11. Better Man - 4
12. Aye Davanita - 2
13. Immortality - 5
14. Stupid Mop - 2

No Code (AVG 4.31)
1. Sometimes - 5
2. Hail, Hail, - 5
3. Who You Are - 4
4. In My Tree - 5
5. Smile - 5
6. Off He Goes - 4
7. Habit - 4
8. Red Mosquito - 5
9. Lukin - 4
10. Present Tense - 4
11. Mankind - 4
12. I'm Open - 3
13. Around the Bend - 4

Yield (AVG 4.5)
1. Brain of J - 5
2. Faithfull - 5
3. No Way - 4
4. Given to Fly - 4
5. Wishlist - 3
6. Pilate - 3
7. Do the Evolution - 5
8. Red Dot - 3
9. MFC - 5
10. Lowlight - 4
11. In Hiding - 4
12. Push Me, Pull Me - 5
13. All Those Yesterdays - 4

Binaural (AVG 4.46)
1. Breakerfall - 5
2. God's Dice - 5
3. Evacuation - 4
4. Light Years - 4
5. Nothing As It Seems - 5
6. Thin Air - 3
7. Insignificance - 5
8. Of the Girl - 5
9. Grievance - 4
10. Rival - 4
11. Sleight of Hand - 5
12. Soon Forget - 4
13. Parting Ways - 5

Riot Act (AVG 4.13)
1. Can't Keep - 5
2. Save You - 4
3. Love Boat Captain - 3
4. Cropduster - 3
5. Ghost - 5
6. I Am Mine - 3
7. Thumbing My Way - 3
8. You Are - 5
9. Get Right - 5
10. Green Disease - 4
11. Help, Help - 5
12. Bushleaguer - 4
13. Half Full - 5
14. Arc - 4
15. All or None - 4

S/T (AVG 4.3)
1. Life Wasted - 4
2. World Wide Suicide - 4
3. Comatose - 4
4. Severed Hand - 5
5. Marker in the Sand - 4
6. Parachutes - 4
7. Unemployable - 4
8. Big Wave - 4
9. Gone - 5
10. Wasted Reprise - 3
11. Army Reserve - 3
12. Come Back - 3
13. Inside Job - 5

Backspacer (AVG 3.45)
1. Gonna See My Friend - 3
2. Got Some - 4
3. The Fixer - 3
4. Johnny Guitar - 3
5. Just Breathe - 2
6. Amongst the Waves - 4
7. Unthought Known - 4
8. Supersonic - 4
9. Speed of Sound - 3
10. Force of Nature - 4
11. The End - 4

Lightning Bolt (AVG 3.75)
1. Getaway - 4
2. Mind Your Manners - 4
3. My Father's Son - 4
4. Sirens - 3
5. Lightning Bolt - 4
6. Infallible - 4
7. Pendulum - 5
8. Swallowed Whole - 4
9. Let the Records Play - 4
10. Sleeping By Myself - 4
11. Yellow Moon - 4
12. Future Days - 1

Which makes my album ranking on individual song rankings alone:

Yield (AVG 4.5)
Binaural (AVG 4.46)
Vs. (AVG 4.33)
No Code (AVG 4.31)
S/T (AVG 4.3)
Ten (AVG 4.18)
Riot Act (AVG 4.13)
Vitalogy (AVG 4.0)
Lightning Bolt (AVG 3.75)
Backspacer (AVG 3.45)

Not how I would rank them. On a more general ranking it would look very different at the moment:

Vitalogy (8 in song rankings)
Binaural (2)
No Code (4)
Yield (1)
Ten (6)
Vs. (3)
S/T (5)
Riot Act (7)
Backspacer (10)
Lightning Bolt (9)

[Brett]

I usually hate the idea of these numerical tally-ups because they never represent my overall feelings towards a particular album. The whole being greater than the sum of its parts and all that. But I figured what the hell and decided to give it a shot.

Ten (4.00)
1. Once - 3
2. Even Flow - 4
3. Alive - 4
4. Why Go - 3.5
5. Black - 4
6. Jeremy - 5
7. Oceans - 4.5
8. Porch - 3.5
9. Garden - 4
10. Deep - 4
11. Release - 4.5

Vs. (4.00)
1. Go - 4
2. Animal - 4
3. Daughter - 5
4. Glorified G - 4.5
5. Dissident - 4
6. WMA - 3.5
7. Blood - 3
8. Rearviewmirror - 5
9. Rats - 4
10. Elderly Woman - 4
11. Leash - 3
12. Indifference - 4

Vitalogy (3.54)
1. Last Exit - 4.5
2. Spin the Black Circle - 3.5
3. Not For You - 5
4. Tremor Christ - 5
5. Nothingman - 4
6. Whipping - 3.5
7. Pry, To - 1
8. Corduroy - 4.5
9. Bugs - 1.5
10. Satan's Bed - 4
11. Betterman - 4
12. Aye Davanita - 3
13. Immortality - 4
14. Stupid Mop - 2

No Code (3.81)
1. Sometimes - 4
2. Hail, Hail, - 5
3. Who You Are - 3.5
4. In My Tree - 5
5. Smile - 3.5
6. Off He Goes - 3.5
7. Habit - 4
8. Red Mosquito - 4
9. Lukin - 2
10. Present Tense - 3.5
11. Mankind - 3
12. I'm Open - 4
13. Around the Bend - 4.5

Yield (3.96)
1. Brain of J - 4
2. Faithfull - 4.5
3. No Way - 4.5
4. Given to Fly - 4.5
5. Wishlist - 4
6. Pilate - 4
7. Do the Evolution - 5
8. Red Dot - 1.5
9. MFC - 3.5
10. Lowlight - 4
11. In Hiding - 4
12. Push Me, Pull Me - 4
13. All Those Yesterdays - 4

Binaural (4.12)
1. Breakerfall - 3.5
2. God's Dice - 3.5
3. Evacuation - 4
4. Light Years - 5
5. Nothing As It Seems - 5
6. Thin Air - 3
7. Insignificance - 5
8. Of the Girl - 5
9. Grievance - 5
10. Rival - 4
11. Sleight of Hand - 5
12. Soon Forget - 1.5
13. Parting Ways - 4

Riot Act (3.37)
1. Can't Keep - 4.5
2. Save You - 3.5
3. Love Boat Captain - 4
4. Cropduster - 5
5. Ghost - 3.5
6. I Am Mine - 3
7. Thumbing My Way - 3
8. You Are - 4.5
9. Get Right - 3
10. Green Disease - 3
11. Help, Help - 3.5
12. Bushleaguer - 3
13. Half Full - 3.5
14. Arc - 3
15. All or None - 4

S/T (3.27)
1. Life Wasted - 3
2. World Wide Suicide - 3.5
3. Comatose - 2
4. Severed Hand - 3.5
5. Marker in the Sand - 4
6. Parachutes - 4.5
7. Unemployable - 4.5
8. Big Wave - 3
9. Gone - 2.5
10. Wasted Reprise - 2
11. Army Reserve - 3
12. Come Back - 4
13. Inside Job - 3

Backspacer (2.82)
1. Gonna See My Friend - 2
2. Got Some - 3.5
3. The Fixer - 3.5
4. Johnny Guitar - 3
5. Just Breathe - 3
6. Amongst the Waves - 2.5
7. Unthought Known - 3
8. Supersonic - 2
9. Speed of Sound - 4
10. Force of Nature - 2.5
11. The End - 2

Lightning Bolt (3.08)
1. Getaway - 3
2. Mind Your Manners - 3
3. My Father's Son - 3
4. Sirens - 3.5
5. Lightning Bolt - 3.5
6. Infallible - 4
7. Pendulum - 3.5
8. Swallowed Whole - 3.5
9. Let the Records Play - 2
10. Sleeping By Myself - 3
11. Yellow Moon - 3.5
12. Future Days - 1.5

All together that comes out as:
Binaural
Vs./Ten
Yield
No Code
Vitalogy
Riot Act
Avocado
Lightning Bolt
Backspacer

I did a ranking a couple weeks ago that I put as:
Binaural
Yield
No Code
Vitalogy
Vs.
Riot Act
Ten
Avocado
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

This isn't greatly different, though Ten and Vs. get pushed way up. The overall album experiences tend to drop those albums a bit, as does the lack of 'artsier' tracks that pull down some of the other albums.

[7 Years and Maybe Longer]

We have a lot of good data now. Who's going to tally up all the answers so we can have the definitive rankings?

[ABNorman]

I've had some free time over the last week, so I've updated the song ranker.

http://return-to-form.surge.sh/

It now has:

* A better filter - you can also copy the URL on the ranking page so you can give other people the same filter
* Multiple rating systems - standard ranking, a "every song vs every other song" for the insane, a Ruddo-friendly 1, 0, -1 system, and star rating.
* Some basic album stats after you've ranked

Lemme know if there's any bugs

[Jorge]

I commend Abby for his tireless dedication to the art of ranking

[Anders]

I've had some free time over the last week, so I've updated the song ranker.

http://return-to-form.surge.sh/

It now has:

* A better filter - you can also copy the URL on the ranking page so you can give other people the same filter
* Multiple rating systems - standard ranking, a "every song vs every other song" for the insane, a Ruddo-friendly 1, 0, -1 system, and star rating.
* Some basic album stats after you've ranked

Lemme know if there's any bugs

Great. Can you add:
Untitled (LO2L)
Out Of My Mind
F*Ckin’ Up
Rockin In The Free World
Turn The Corner

[Anders]

Lost Dogs part two

1. Last Soldier
2. Cold Confession
3. Let It Ride
4. Anything In Between
5. I Got Shit
6. Of The Earth
7. Untitled (the LO2L song in studio)
8. State Of Love And Trust
9. Angel
10. Falling Down
11. Sunburn
12. Happy When I'm Crying
13. Out Of My Mind
14. Fuckin Up
15. Rockin' In The Free World

Side 2:
16. Acoustic #1
17. Chinese
18. Brother (with lyrics)
19. Olé
20. Leatherman
21. Just A Girl
22. Breath
23. Sonic Reducer
24. Better Things
25. Love Reign O'er Me
26. Man Of The Hour
27. 10 Billion Years
28. Santa Cruz
29. Turn The Corner
30. Crazy Mary
31. Long Road
32. Pendulumorphisis

I like listening to this collection of songs not on any of the studio albums or Lost Dogs. Flows nicely.

[Anders]

[Anders]

1. Last Soldier (Rarities)
2. Untitled [Live on Two Legs] (Rarities)
3. Let It Ride (Rarities)
4. I Got Id (Rarities)
5. Acoustic #1 (Rarities)
6. Man of the Hour (Rarities)
7. Cold Confession (Rarities)
8. Breath (Rarities)
9. Rockin' in the Free World (Rarities)
10. Falling Down (Rarities)
11. Brother w/lyrics (Rarities)
12. Anything In Between (Rarities)
13. Of The Earth (Rarities)
14. Long Road (Rarities)
15. Love Reign O'er Me (Rarities)
16. Better Things (Rarities)
17. Sunburn (Rarities)
18. Crazy Mary (Rarities)
19. 10 Billion Years (Rarities)
20. Out of My Mind (Rarities)
21. State Of Love And Trust (Rarities)
22. Turn The Corner (Rarities)
23. Fuckin' Up (Rarities)
24. Santa Cruz (Rarities)
25. Just a Girl (Rarities)
26. Chinese (Rarities)
27. Sonic Reducer (Rarities)
28. Angel (Rarities)
29. Pendulumorphisis (Rarities)
30. Ole (Rarities)
31. Leatherman (Rarities)
32. Happy When I'm Crying (Rarities)