Gigaton: Official album thread

[Brett]

There are plenty of bands who have made albums better than this 30 years into their career...this album isn't THAT good

My knowledge is neither deep nor broad enough to agree with or refute this statement. Do you have any examples to share?

[jgardz]

So far I’m not overly impressed with this album...the first 3 tracks are really good, after that I kinda started losing interest. Gonna have to give it some more time, but initial reaction is meh for the most part...nothing I really hated necessarily just haven’t really connected with much.

[stip]

Something I just noticed that I like. Retrograde ends with a call to feel the sound, and River Cross ends with a call to share the light. Given the double album closer role that these songs play that's an interesting juxtaposition

[Farmer John]

Something I just noticed that I like. Retrograde ends with a call to feel the sound, and River Cross ends with a call to share the light. Given the double album closer role that these songs play that's an interesting juxtaposition

The band is giving us quite the to-do list:

- Share the light
- Feel the sound
- Put your seatbelt on
- Stand back when the spirit comes

sounds like a lot of work

[corduroyg]

can someone give a cliff notes version of that review. there are WAY too many words there.

“this album is the bomb yo!”

[LoathedVermin72]

There are plenty of bands who have made albums better than this 30 years into their career...this album isn't THAT good

My knowledge is neither deep nor broad enough to agree with or refute this statement. Do you have any examples to share?

Off the top of my head:

Tool
Melvins
Bruce Springsteen
Steely Dan
Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds
Helmet
David Bowie
Tom Waits

[McParadigm]

Something I just noticed that I like. Retrograde ends with a call to feel the sound, and River Cross ends with a call to share the light. Given the double album closer role that these songs play that's an interesting juxtaposition

The band is giving us quite the to-do list:

- Share the light
- Feel the sound
- Put your seatbelt on
- Stand back when the spirit comes

sounds like a lot of work

It’s alright to say no, John.

[Strat]

Lol steely dan

[vedder316]

Trying to limit my listens to once per day, Christ even Never Destination is getting better for me.

Only Retrograde is failing to really connect for me. They really did a great job for 30 years in

[Jaeti]

Something I just noticed that I like. Retrograde ends with a call to feel the sound, and River Cross ends with a call to share the light. Given the double album closer role that these songs play that's an interesting juxtaposition

The band is giving us quite the to-do list:

- Share the light
- Feel the sound
- Put your seatbelt on
- Stand back when the spirit comes

sounds like a lot of work

It’s alright to say no, John.

This would disappoint me, but hey, it's just you there in your own home.

[stip]

Something I just noticed that I like. Retrograde ends with a call to feel the sound, and River Cross ends with a call to share the light. Given the double album closer role that these songs play that's an interesting juxtaposition

The band is giving us quite the to-do list:

- Share the light
- Feel the sound
- Put your seatbelt on
- Stand back when the spirit comes

sounds like a lot of work

It’s alright to say no, John.

bunch of rich liberals thinking the rest of us dont have real jobs

[stip]

There are plenty of bands who have made albums better than this 30 years into their career...this album isn't THAT good

My knowledge is neither deep nor broad enough to agree with or refute this statement. Do you have any examples to share?

Off the top of my head:

Tool
Melvins
Bruce Springsteen
Steely Dan
Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds
Helmet
David Bowie
Tom Waits

i think solo artists reflect a different dynamic, for what its worth.


That Tool album was incredibly disappointing

[LoathedVermin72]

There are plenty of bands who have made albums better than this 30 years into their career...this album isn't THAT good

My knowledge is neither deep nor broad enough to agree with or refute this statement. Do you have any examples to share?

Off the top of my head:

Tool
Melvins
Bruce Springsteen
Steely Dan
Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds
Helmet
David Bowie
Tom Waits

i think solo artists reflect a different dynamic, for what its worth.


That Tool album was incredibly disappointing

Okay then remove three of those, point stands

Fear Inoculum is already my second favorite Tool album and waaaaaaaaay better than Gigaton

[LoathedVermin72]

Lol steely dan

Is a much better band than Pearl Jam

[brisk]

1st 4 songs are good. Got me too excited.
Alright was appropriately named, just tolerable
7 o Clock - too cheesey with the synth, probably better live when they hopefully drop some of that production
Never Destination - boring song until the last 30 seconds which has a killer ending bridge phase
Take the Long Way - boring song until the last 30 which has a killer ending bridge phase
Buckle Up - Perhaps worst PJ song ever
Comes Then Goes - It's ok but goes on too long
Retrograde - Really grown on me, think it's a good'n
River Cross - It's okay, goes on bit too long.

Overall better than Backspacer I'd say but not as good as LB or Avocado that's for sure.

I'm wondering how a lot of this album will come across live, there's a lot of synth / keys and backin vocals.

[dad]

Has Gigaton been sent to any Zunes yet? Need to know how that community is feeling the sound.

[dad]

Lol steely dan

Is a much better band than Pearl Jam

Are...are you John Mulaney?

[LoathedVermin72]

Lol steely dan

Is a much better band than Pearl Jam

Are...are you John Mulaney?

JOHN MULANEY DOESNT OWN DANDOM

[Ms Harmless]

Something I just noticed that I like. Retrograde ends with a call to feel the sound, and River Cross ends with a call to share the light. Given the double album closer role that these songs play that's an interesting juxtaposition

The band is giving us quite the to-do list:

- Share the light
- Feel the sound
- Put your seatbelt on
- Stand back when the spirit comes

sounds like a lot of work

It’s alright to say no, John.

bunch of rich liberals thinking the rest of us dont have real jobs

this exchange was great

[stip]

There are plenty of bands who have made albums better than this 30 years into their career...this album isn't THAT good

My knowledge is neither deep nor broad enough to agree with or refute this statement. Do you have any examples to share?

Off the top of my head:

Tool
Melvins
Bruce Springsteen
Steely Dan
Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds
Helmet
David Bowie
Tom Waits

i think solo artists reflect a different dynamic, for what its worth.


That Tool album was incredibly disappointing

Okay then remove three of those, point stands

Fear Inoculum is already my second favorite Tool album and waaaaaaaaay better than Gigaton

i gave it about 5 listens and nothing stood out. I wasnt a big fan of 10000 Days either though