Who Ever Said

[stip]

getaway just came on, actually (i was listening to a few lightning bolt tracks). It’s got some movement to it. it just gets a little
samey

[dimejinky99]

getaway just came on, actually (i was listening to a few lightning bolt tracks). It’s got some movement to it. it just gets a little
samey

I think getaway would fit on here better than a couple of songs on here

Sue me

[Ms Harmless]

I like the chorus of Getaway and where it goes towards the end, but I've kind of tired of the rest

[Jaeti]

The part from 2:30 onwards is my favourite thing on the album.

I think this might be true for me, too.

[EJ]

The part from 2:30 onwards is my favourite thing on the album.

I think this might be true for me, too.

It could be for me too. At the very least, somewhere in the top 5. Another contender for me is the explosive last minute of Quick Escape.

[OmegaprimeVKM]

Perfectly listenable and serviceable as a high paced stomper. There's some feeling to try to differentiate it from the back catalogue with that ominous intro and the vocal middle 8.

However, it's just far too similar to Gonna Be My Friend, Getaway, Swallowed Whole...it comes across as latter era PJ's stock modus operandi. I do think the production conceals a lot on tracks like this - it will sound thin and lame live.

[Ms Harmless]

I think when performed live, this one will live or die based on how much energy Ed can pour into the middle section; if he knows what's good for it, he'll milk that for all it's worth, so that the return to the chorus at the end has impact

I almost want them to do everything they do in live RVM (that I hate in that song) in this one; take the best part and jam it the fuck out, letting it become even more distorted in the back half

[Ms Harmless]

the snare sound on this song is so sexy (and I don't like every snare on this album)

[Ms Harmless]

it took a while but I'm coming around to the first section of this song now; I was just surprised it didn't have the unhinged distorted noise and energy I expected; it loosens up and builds in intensity later, but is not interested in the big intro punch, and now that I've come to terms with that, I can concentrate on what it *is* doing; I don't know how to speak about guitar chords, really, but that first section (and the whole song, really) throws some nicely unexpected "grunge" chord changes and vocal melody choices that kind of compete with the song's more classic rock backbone, and I'm beginning to really enjoy that fight between both of those equally Pearl Jam inclinations; it's in the slightly awkward and jarring tussle between the soaring "who ever said it's all been said?" and the Stones-esque "gave up on satisfaction!" (during which I can hear "can't get no... satisfaction!", and it makes me cringe a little)

anyway, all of that is to say, my journey with all of this song's oddities and ironies is its strength, not a weakness

[adamhewett]

Perfectly listenable and serviceable as a high paced stomper. There's some feeling to try to differentiate it from the back catalogue with that ominous intro and the vocal middle 8.

However, it's just far too similar to Gonna Be My Friend, Getaway, Swallowed Whole...it comes across as latter era PJ's stock modus operandi. I do think the production conceals a lot on tracks like this - it will sound thin and lame live.

"it will sound thin and lame live."

this is so fucking true. aim that directly at mike/stone. crazy weak live tones post "yield" era pearl jam. it's so painful listening to their modern setup playing the older material. people complain about vedder, but stone/mike are the overall let downs for me live these days. i remember blowing cash i didn't actually have in 2003 on those japan boots and learned my lesson, will never buy another pj boot again. paper thin sounding guitars. ugh.

"what happened, did your uh...balls drop off?"

[evenslow]

somehow, this song has taken the longest for me to connect. i do really like it and how it's arranged - keeps me coming back.

i would absolutely agree that it would be a great live opener. the whole middle section galloping into the big finish is just tailor made for that experience.

[gardenparty]

I like this song but a few things hold it back from being great

The "cradle to the grave" and "ventricles pumping" lines are two of them

[Ms Harmless]

I like this song but a few things hold it back from being great

The "cradle to the grave" and "ventricles pumping" lines are two of them

what's wrong with them?

[Hatfield]

somehow, this song has taken the longest for me to connect. i do really like it and how it's arranged - keeps me coming back.

i would absolutely agree that it would be a great live opener. the whole middle section galloping into the big finish is just tailor made for that experience.

you got the volume turned up enough?!

I don't think I've heard another album benefit from volume as much as Gigaton.

[evenslow]

somehow, this song has taken the longest for me to connect. i do really like it and how it's arranged - keeps me coming back.

i would absolutely agree that it would be a great live opener. the whole middle section galloping into the big finish is just tailor made for that experience.

you got the volume turned up enough?!

I don't think I've heard another album benefit from volume as much as Gigaton.

this is what ultimately did it for me with SBWM.

[Kevin Davis]

I like this song a lot but I do feel like I'm only hearing Eddie's guitar on it, except for maybe some subtle flourishes in the second half. His rhythm playing always sounds so rudimentary and thin compared to Stone's.

I don't think this band has utilized the three-guitar approach very effectively very often. I wish Eddie would relinquish guitar duties to Mike and Stone even on song's he's written, I feel like it would bolster the overall impact of many of his songs.

[EJ]

somehow, this song has taken the longest for me to connect. i do really like it and how it's arranged - keeps me coming back.

i would absolutely agree that it would be a great live opener. the whole middle section galloping into the big finish is just tailor made for that experience.

you got the volume turned up enough?!

I don't think I've heard another album benefit from volume as much as Gigaton.

Probably just needs to upgrade his sound system.

Spoiler: show

[scrub12]

I like this song but a few things hold it back from being great

The "cradle to the grave" and "ventricles pumping" lines are two of them

What the heck? I love those lines, particularly how they are delivered.

[epilogue]

I like this song but a few things hold it back from being great

The "cradle to the grave" and "ventricles pumping" lines are two of them

what's wrong with them?

I know you aren't asking me but I will say that I don't dislike either line other than he says "room to tomb" instead of "womb to tomb." That bugs the shit out of me.

[Ms Harmless]

I like this song but a few things hold it back from being great

The "cradle to the grave" and "ventricles pumping" lines are two of them

what's wrong with them?

I know you aren't asking me but I will say that I don't dislike either line other than he says "room to tomb" instead of "womb to tomb." That bugs the shit out of me.

I always heard "womb" but I could be wrong lol