Building the "Ultimate" PJ Album: TRACK ELEVEN

[evenslow]

there goes theplatypus, tearing apart the RM community again.

[PHATJ]

I will support whatever strategy you pursue, phatj, if you help me get Get Right on to this thing

Lol, all all for Get Right. That song is badass.

[PHATJ]

I am voting for what I think is the best representative from each album if at all possible. Depending on the track, there are some caveats. But voting for some mediocre LB track as the lesser of 11 evils is pointless.

Especially when Track 11 has AWESOME songs.

[Farmer John]

To really raise the stakes, we should all agree that the resulting "Ultimate" PJ Album can be the only PJ album that any of us can listen to until then end of time.

[evenslow]

I will support whatever strategy you pursue, phatj, if you help me get Get Right on to this thing

Lol, all all for Get Right. That song is badass.

that's like the 10th best song on the album.

[PHATJ]

I will support whatever strategy you pursue, phatj, if you help me get Get Right on to this thing

Lol, all all for Get Right. That song is badass.

that's like the 10th best song on the album.

Hard disagree.

[96583UP]

I am voting for what I think is the best representative from each album if at all possible. Depending on the track, there are some caveats. But voting for some mediocre LB track as the lesser of 11 evils is pointless.

what do you suggest from LB?

we sip cocoa in a blanket and listen to Sirens while watching Sleepless in Seattle?

that sounds pretty good, actually, sign me up

[Kaius]

People are free to vote however they like, but I think it's more fun to weigh the options and what other songs you're knocking out of the competition, and potentially compromise to save them. Otherwise it's just another series of ranking threads.

You're right. But I want to participate but I also want to put minimal effort into it.

[Jorge]

People are free to vote however they like, but I think it's more fun to weigh the options and what other songs you're knocking out of the competition, and potentially compromise to save them. Otherwise it's just another series of ranking threads.

You're right. But I want to participate but I also want to put minimal effort into it.

Sounds like my ex girlfriend in bed, EYYYYYYYYYYYY

[Kaius]

I still think some of you aren't understanding how this works and are just voting for your favorite of the songs listed

So is the goal to have an album full of mid-tier songs so that we don’t get two absolute stink bombs from Backspacer and LB, or is it to vote for your favorite song every round, especially when they are winning, and just say “fuck it, who cares about the BS and LB songs, they’re gonna suck anyway, I’m gonna get as many awesome songs as possible.”

I think people understand just fine how this works, they just have different strategies.

Is this a strategy?

I can't possibly be fussed to consider how my choice is going to effect future choices. I'm just picking my favorite. 5 secs of contemplating and click.

That’s as much strategy as Kaius seems capable of, yes.

[Kaius]

People are free to vote however they like, but I think it's more fun to weigh the options and what other songs you're knocking out of the competition, and potentially compromise to save them. Otherwise it's just another series of ranking threads.

You're right. But I want to participate but I also want to put minimal effort into it.

Sounds like my ex girlfriend in bed, EYYYYYYYYYYYY

Well when you're pounding me with your giant ***k I feel paralyzed

[96583UP]

where the f*** is lenny it's getting HOTTT in here TRIANGLE OF LOVE CALLING ALL ANGLES CALLING ALL ANGLES

[evenslow]

I am voting for what I think is the best representative from each album if at all possible. Depending on the track, there are some caveats. But voting for some mediocre LB track as the lesser of 11 evils is pointless.

what do you suggest from LB?

we sip cocoa in a blanket and listen to Sirens while watching Sleepless in Seattle?

that sounds pretty good, actually, sign me up

Pick something approaching the best song on the album b/c the other really good albums can bear the weight of losing out on that specific track number.

[Jaeti]

I'm thinking The End. It's a fine enough song that fits near the end of an album, and would help avert a Backspacer catastrophe if we somehow got locked into The Fixer, Just Breathe, or Supersonic.

[Jaeti]

There will be a poll for this "Ultimate" album so we can all assign it 1-5 stars, correct?

[tragabigzanda]

I still think some of you aren't understanding how this works and are just voting for your favorite of the songs listed

Welp Welp

[96583UP]

I am voting for what I think is the best representative from each album if at all possible. Depending on the track, there are some caveats. But voting for some mediocre LB track as the lesser of 11 evils is pointless.

what do you suggest from LB?

we sip cocoa in a blanket and listen to Sirens while watching Sleepless in Seattle?

that sounds pretty good, actually, sign me up

Pick something approaching the best song on the album b/c the other really good albums can bear the weight of losing out on that specific track number.

WHAT IS THE BEST SONG ON THE ALBUM I AM NOT UP TO SPEED ON YOUR CURRENT LIST OF RANKINGS I NEED MORE DIRECT RECOMMENDATIONS IF I AM TO CONSIDER MODIFYING MY SELECTION

[tragabigzanda]

Picking SoH over NAIS or Of The Girl is respectable, even if I don’t agree with it

[reconstruction_ seeds]

I'm thinking The End. It's a fine enough song that fits near the end of an album, and would help avert a Backspacer catastrophe if we somehow got locked into The Fixer, Just Breathe, or Supersonic.

This song blows so hard. How is it not obvious?

[96583UP]

Picking SoH over NAIS or Of The Girl is respectable, even if I don’t agree with it

I can live with it

I am not a revisionist SoH hater like some

over time I have come to like OTG most from this album, methinks