Building the "Ultimate" PJ Album: TRACK FOUR

[digster]

I like it, it's just that other than Garden, all the remaining Ten choices I like better (Alive, Why Go, Black, Jeremy, Oceans). Marker has really grown on me over the years, although I still think Parachutes is a better song. I'd be fine with Ghost as well.

[DissidentRival4]

Jumped ahead and put mine together based on what all I've voted for. Ended up:

Spoiler: show

Getaway
God's Dice
Who You Are
Tremor Christ
Marker In the Sand
Seven O'clock
Evolution
Rearviewmirror
Get Right
Force Of Nature
Release
All Those Yesterdays

Looking forward to how the collective one turns out.

[stip]

I like it, it's just that other than Garden, all the remaining Ten choices I like better (Alive, Why Go, Black, Jeremy, Oceans). Marker has really grown on me over the years, although I still think Parachutes is a better song. I'd be fine with Ghost as well.

Ten is impossibly deep. I can't really take offense that you think there are better songs than Porch Agree about Garden, too

[Brett]

Voting "Tremor Christ," but I'd be okay with "Light Years" or "Given to Fly," too. They're all heavy-hitting favorites.

[epilogue]

I mean, picking the wrong song off of one of their shitty albums is one thing, but leaving off arguably one of their best songs and the best off of a good album is something else and completely asinine

Except that there are still several great options from Vitalogy. Leaving off Tremor Christ means you could still get Corduroy (for example). That's way less egregious than including probably the worst Pearl Jam song from the worst Pearl Jam album and calling it "Ultimate."

[epilogue]

This "Ultimate" list is now completely invalid. This all matters even less than it ever did. So... Who cares. Cropduster, I guess. But any of them are fine.

Didn't you vote for Force of Nature?

ABSOLUTELY NOT

How are we even friends????????????????

[epilogue]

Cropduster. You can still get Corduroy or Nothingman

Once again, stip proves he's an adult among children.

[Jaeti]

Switched my vote from Cropduster to Given To Fly.

Hoping to somehow encourage others to do the same and preserve the Vitalogy slot until we can put Corduroy on this thing.

[epilogue]

The problem is though... Tremor Christ is better than Corduroy.

[epilogue]

What about this? Providing Tremor Christ is the winner.

Spoiler: show

Go
Hail, Hail
Dance of the Clairvoyants
Tremor Christ
Marker in the Sand
I Am Mine
Do the Evolution
Porch
Grievance
Force of Nature
Yellow Moon
Immortality

The missed opportunity here is that I think most of the songs from Ten still available are better than Porch, but that's still a good song, and I think this would be a strong mix until the end.

I like this. You've made chicken salad out of chicken shit.

BUT... given that Get Right still has a chance, I'm going to switch my vote here from Cropduster to Tremor Christ and then lobby hard for Get Right later. Which could mean Nothing As It Seems or Insignificance instead of Grievance, and I fucking LOVE that idea.

[bodysnatcher]

who are the two people who voted for Light Years? i need to know who to foe.

[epilogue]

who are the two people who voted for Light Years? i need to know who to foe.

real talk: I'd vote for Light Years over Why Go, though

[digster]

What about this? Providing Tremor Christ is the winner.

Spoiler: show

Go
Hail, Hail
Dance of the Clairvoyants
Tremor Christ
Marker in the Sand
I Am Mine
Do the Evolution
Porch
Grievance
Force of Nature
Yellow Moon
Immortality

The missed opportunity here is that I think most of the songs from Ten still available are better than Porch, but that's still a good song, and I think this would be a strong mix until the end.

I like this. You've made chicken salad out of chicken shit.

BUT... given that Get Right still has a chance, I'm going to switch my vote here from Cropduster to Tremor Christ and then lobby hard for Get Right later. Which could mean Nothing As It Seems or Insignificance instead of Grievance, and I fucking LOVE that idea.

That'd be fine; I prefer both those songs anyway.

[epilogue]

What about this? Providing Tremor Christ is the winner.

Spoiler: show

Go
Hail, Hail
Dance of the Clairvoyants
Tremor Christ
Marker in the Sand
I Am Mine
Do the Evolution
Porch
Grievance
Force of Nature
Yellow Moon
Immortality

The missed opportunity here is that I think most of the songs from Ten still available are better than Porch, but that's still a good song, and I think this would be a strong mix until the end.

I like this. You've made chicken salad out of chicken shit.

BUT... given that Get Right still has a chance, I'm going to switch my vote here from Cropduster to Tremor Christ and then lobby hard for Get Right later. Which could mean Nothing As It Seems or Insignificance instead of Grievance, and I fucking LOVE that idea.

That'd be fine; I prefer both those songs anyway.

Alright! Let's get this shit back on track!

[bodysnatcher]

who are the two people who voted for Light Years? i need to know who to foe.

real talk: I'd vote for Light Years over Why Go, though

i'd have to think on that, might be a coin flip.

Light Years has to be the most overrated song in the catalogue though.

[epilogue]

who are the two people who voted for Light Years? i need to know who to foe.

real talk: I'd vote for Light Years over Why Go, though

i'd have to think on that, might be a coin flip.

Light Years has to be the most overrated song in the catalogue though.

Force of Nature says, "Hold my beer."

[bodysnatcher]

who are the two people who voted for Light Years? i need to know who to foe.

real talk: I'd vote for Light Years over Why Go, though

i'd have to think on that, might be a coin flip.

Light Years has to be the most overrated song in the catalogue though.

Force of Nature says, "Hold my beer."

shit i didn't even think about that. i have tried for years to block the memory of that song. seems to be working.

gotta keep at it though...

[wease]

Light Years is an excellent companion to Sad. Probably why I hold them both in such high regard.

[tragabigzanda]

who are the two people who voted for Light Years? i need to know who to foe.

real talk: I'd vote for Light Years over Why Go, though

i'd have to think on that, might be a coin flip.

Light Years has to be the most overrated song in the catalogue though.

[epilogue]

I like Light Years a lot. I guess I don't have any real gauge for how it's rated though (over or under) among fans.