Ultimate Pearl Jam Album Redux Track 5 (finals)

[bada]

Black and Nothingman

[LetMeSleep]

Nothing As It Seems
Ghost

[tragabigzanda]

Odd that four of these are Jeff songs

[Birds in Hell]

I don't much care for Nothingman.

What the hell bro

Not a fan of that whole lilting acoustic vein of Jeff's songwriting: Nothingman, Low Light, Yellow Moon, etc.

Total snoozers.

You've listed one snoozer here

Yeah, but people seem to like Low Light in spite of that

Low Light sucks

Oh heavens no

Going to have to agree with wease on this one.

I like virtually everything the band did (to a greater or lesser degree) between 1990-1998, but Low Light is one of the worst songs from that period. Maybe even the worst! Who knows.

[Jorge]

"Low Light" is obviously gorgeous and one of the best things they've ever done. I understand it's a little high-brow for the likes of SPENNO and WEASE

[Monkey_Driven]

Lowlight was a real pleasure to hear live at Wrigley in 2018. A fine song.

[epilogue]

It's legit one of my favorites. Like Jorge said, it's a gorgeous song. Still haven't ever gotten it live. But that's alright. The studio version is perfection and I can listen to it whenever I want.

[Jorge]

I think it kind of sucks live

[digster]

I think it's okay live, but there is an emptiness compared to the studio version; it's one of PJ's few tracks for me where there's a wide gulf between the studio take and a live version from any era.

[epilogue]

I think it's okay live, but there is an emptiness compared to the studio version; it's one of PJ's few tracks for me where there's a wide gulf between the studio take and a live version from any era.

I feel that way about every Pearl Jam song.

[chewm]

i have no idea how most pearl jam songs sound live

[wease]

"Low Light" is obviously gorgeous and one of the best things they've ever done. I understand it's a little high-brow for the likes of SPENNO and WEASE

Keep telling yourself that. It won’t be true, but you’ll feel better.

[Norah]

but it is true

[knee tunes]

i have no idea how most pearl jam songs sound live

why do you always want to make people cry?

[Toots McSharty]

NAIS and Smile. Both are personal faves and I've never seen either live. Smile's always had a spot in my top 5 PJ songs.

[DissidentRival4]

Unexpectedly got Low Light in Memphis 2014 - still one of my favorite versions (albeit that's a biased 'I was there' opinion ), but really liked the way he held/holds the last "see" until the song ends.

[VinylGuy]

Team Anything But Ghost

Ghost is out of its league here.

[VinylGuy]

Also, Nothingman is winning.

Shocker.

[stip]

Sorry - was helping kids with school

Round is closed.

Nothingman: 28%
Nothing as it Seems: 26%
Smile: 21%
Black: 15% (welcome to planet RM)
Ghost: 9%


Nothingman and NAIS move to the finals

[stip]

Voting for Nothingman, but both worthy songs