Ultimate Pearl Jam Album Redux Track 12 (finals)

[Thurman Murman]

Playlist be damned, i'm going with the better song. Indifference it is.

[Tj]

River Cross is the worst song in 18 years. Indifference is top 20. I can't believe this nonsense. River Cross sounds like a grown up Charlie Brown found a pump organ at a thift store and wrote a song that was influenced by the last days of Mr. Supertramp after reading Into The Wild.

[Jorge]

An okay-but-kinda-ordinary instrumental bed atop which lies a great performance of some hilariously overwrought lyrics

vs.

some kumbaya bullshit I can barely remember

Going with "Indifference" I guess

[Anders]

Indifference

[Monkey_Driven]

River Cross is the worst song in 18 years. Indifference is top 20. I can't believe this nonsense. River Cross sounds like a grown up Charlie Brown found a pump organ at a thift store and wrote a song that was influenced by the last days of Mr. Supertramp after reading Into The Wild.

LOL at River Cross being worse than Supersonic.

[PHATJ]

River Cross is the worst song in 18 years. Indifference is top 20. I can't believe this nonsense. River Cross sounds like a grown up Charlie Brown found a pump organ at a thift store and wrote a song that was influenced by the last days of Mr. Supertramp after reading Into The Wild.

You’re on crack

[Toots McSharty]

River Cross is the worst song in 18 years. Indifference is top 20. I can't believe this nonsense. River Cross sounds like a grown up Charlie Brown found a pump organ at a thift store and wrote a song that was influenced by the last days of Mr. Supertramp after reading Into The Wild.

LOL at River Cross being worse than Supersonic.

It's nowhere near the worst. I'm not a huge fan of it, but it's not bad and definitely better than a good chunk from BS and LB.

Voting Indifference

[PHATJ]

Indifference is my least favorite song on Vs. by a wide margin.

[LetMeSleep]

Indifference by the largest possible margin.

[Tj]

River Cross is the worst song in 18 years. Indifference is top 20. I can't believe this nonsense. River Cross sounds like a grown up Charlie Brown found a pump organ at a thift store and wrote a song that was influenced by the last days of Mr. Supertramp after reading Into The Wild.

LOL at River Cross being worse than Supersonic.

It's nowhere near the worst. I'm not a huge fan of it, but it's not bad and definitely better than a good chunk from BS and LB.

Voting Indifference

It would be my least favorite on both these albums.

[Farmer John]

Playlist be damned, i'm going with the better song. Indifference it is.

[DissidentRival4]

Indifference all day over River Cross. All. Damn. Day.

[stip]

River cross is really good - no shame in not being as good as indifference

[VinylGuy]

River Cross for me.

this song is reaching me in a way Indifference doesnt. Yeah, Indifference is a classic but i prefer River Cross.
I hope the band gives the spot this song deserves live.

[Rob]

So, not a single Gigaton song will be on this. And that doesn't surprise me. It's a great album, but I do think the songs sound too different to be mixed in with earlier stuff. That's not a bad thing. I have a hard time comparing it to other albums because it just seems so different/unique from the rest.

[liebzz]

River Cross for me.

this song is reaching me in a way Indifference doesnt. Yeah, Indifference is a classic but i prefer River Cross.
I hope the band gives the spot this song deserves live.

I agree with that.

[stip]

Closing this out a little early - Indifference takes it 61-39%

[96583UP]

ehhhh Indifference life is so bleak meeehhhh ehhhh ehhhhhhh

[PHATJ]

Yeah, I just don’t relate to indifference anymore. And it doesn’t excite me musically. So... meh. *shrug*