100. 4/20/02 vs. Turning Mist

[stip]

[VinylGuy]

Intersting match. I haven listened to TM in a long time....still, there is a sadness and fierce in 4/20/02 that gets me every time.

[stip]

I don't really like either of these. 4/20/02 is a raw performance, but it's a bit too much of a sketch and I feel like Layne deserved a complete thought.

Turning Mist sounds like a bad Beatles/Oasis song. And those aren't bands whose good work I like, so this is a non-starter. What happened to Mike as a song writer. I'm trying to think of the last great thing he did.

[LetMeSleep]

Vote for Layne

[digster]

Well, not a fan of either of these. I guess I'm going with 4/20/02, but there's quite a few better songs that'll be biting the dust this round.

[PHATJ]

Dumb

[B]

Is that Mike singing on Turning Mist?

[stip]

yup

[B]

He's at least as talented as Jeff.

[E.H. Ruddock]

I've had the honor of hearing TM the very first time it was played live. Mike tried it out at a Flight to Mars show of which I was in attendance. Suck it, losers.

[B]

I've had the honor of hearing TM the very first time it was played live. Mike tried it out at a Flight to Mars show of which I was in attendance. Suck it, losers.

This statement leaves your vote in this match-up unclear.

[VinylGuy]

I don't really like either of these. 4/20/02 is a raw performance, but it's a bit too much of a sketch and I feel like Layne deserved a complete thought.

Turning Mist sounds like a bad Beatles/Oasis song. And those aren't bands whose good work I like, so this is a non-starter. What happened to Mike as a song writer. I'm trying to think of the last great thing he did.

i like thats a thing eddie did when he learnt the news..you can hear the sadness. Besides PJ doesnt seem to exploit their friend´s deaths by releasing a song, so im alright with this.

[epilogue]

I don't really like either of these. 4/20/02 is a raw performance, but it's a bit too much of a sketch and I feel like Layne deserved a complete thought.

Turning Mist sounds like a bad Beatles/Oasis song. And those aren't bands whose good work I like, so this is a non-starter. What happened to Mike as a song writer. I'm trying to think of the last great thing he did.

i like thats a thing eddie did when he learnt the news..you can hear the sadness. Besides PJ doesnt seem to exploit their friend´s deaths by releasing a song, so im alright with this.

I definitely lean toward TVG in this debate. But I also like the idea of the song more than the song.

Neither of these are especially interesting or meaningful to me.

[VinylGuy]

I remember being surprised that they included it on Lost Dogs. And i love the sentiment poured over it. You can feel Ed´s sadness and frustration.

I guess thats why Missing is a perfect choice for Chris´s tribute.

[stip]

I don't really like either of these. 4/20/02 is a raw performance, but it's a bit too much of a sketch and I feel like Layne deserved a complete thought.

Turning Mist sounds like a bad Beatles/Oasis song. And those aren't bands whose good work I like, so this is a non-starter. What happened to Mike as a song writer. I'm trying to think of the last great thing he did.

i like thats a thing eddie did when he learnt the news..you can hear the sadness. Besides PJ doesnt seem to exploit their friend´s deaths by releasing a song, so im alright with this.

fair enough, but then they did release it

[B]

I don't really like either of these. 4/20/02 is a raw performance, but it's a bit too much of a sketch and I feel like Layne deserved a complete thought.

Turning Mist sounds like a bad Beatles/Oasis song. And those aren't bands whose good work I like, so this is a non-starter. What happened to Mike as a song writer. I'm trying to think of the last great thing he did.

i like thats a thing eddie did when he learnt the news..you can hear the sadness. Besides PJ doesnt seem to exploit their friend´s deaths by releasing a song, so im alright with this.

fair enough, but then they did release it

It was a hidden track. It's not like they even used it as promotion.

[VinylGuy]

I don't really like either of these. 4/20/02 is a raw performance, but it's a bit too much of a sketch and I feel like Layne deserved a complete thought.

Turning Mist sounds like a bad Beatles/Oasis song. And those aren't bands whose good work I like, so this is a non-starter. What happened to Mike as a song writer. I'm trying to think of the last great thing he did.

i like thats a thing eddie did when he learnt the news..you can hear the sadness. Besides PJ doesnt seem to exploit their friend´s deaths by releasing a song, so im alright with this.

fair enough, but then they did release it

yeah, they released it as a hidden track so nobody is grabbing the album because of the song. I think Ed explains it in the pJ20 book

[stip]

All reasonable points. And it is a very raw performance. I just find myself a little unmoved by it -