220.Corduroy vs. Last Soldier

[epilogue]

According to the Alright thread:


5 Stars 27%
4 Stars 52%
3 Stars 17%
2 Stars 4%
1 Star 0%

And it beat 10 Billion Years, which is a song a sizable part of RM has a love affair with. I'm not sure where the RM doesn't like Alright idea comes from.

It comes from the discourse around the song.

My perception, which I guess is off?, is that people liked it more out of the gate but many (most?) have soured on it quite a bit. I'm not sure how many of those people bothered to revote in the thread poll.

[epilogue]

It's probably just that the few that really dislike it, call it an embarrassment and such, are super vocal about it.

Either way, Corduroy has still had an easy path (if not the literal easiest path) and I should have voted for Last Soldier.

[E.H. Ruddock]

It's probably just that the few that really dislike it, call it an embarrassment and such, are super vocal about it.

Either way, Corduroy has still had an easy path (if not the literal easiest path) and I should have voted for Last Soldier.

You can change your vote

[epilogue]

It's probably just that the few that really dislike it, call it an embarrassment and such, are super vocal about it.

Either way, Corduroy has still had an easy path (if not the literal easiest path) and I should have voted for Last Soldier.

You can change your vote

Yeah but if I did it would just be for all the wrong reasons. Corduroy is the better song, even if we're in a fight.

[stip]

I can't think of a better reason!

[stip]

It's probably just that the few that really dislike it, call it an embarrassment and such, are super vocal about it.

Either way, Corduroy has still had an easy path (if not the literal easiest path) and I should have voted for Last Soldier.

maybe - I've also barely been around the last 11 months, so I hardly have my finger on the pulse

[Higgs]

Last Soldier is written wrong.

No - stip was doing PJ puns after someone mentioned being a little constipated.

[Brett]

Last Soldier is better than Happy When I’m Crying or Leatherman.

No it's not.

[epilogue]

I can't think of a better reason!

I also tend to hold onto things and thus have slanted and unfair perceptions sometimes. I adore Alright. So if even a couple of posters who I like and respect bash on it, then to me it feels like the whole world is against me!

[Anders]

Last Soldier is better than Happy When I’m Crying or Leatherman.

No it's not.

By a good margin.

[VinylGuy]

Im one of those who liked Alright a lot when it came out and kinda felt meh about it now. Its the song from Gigaton i like the least.

[epilogue]

Last Soldier is better than Happy When I’m Crying or Leatherman.

No it's not.

By a good margin.

Anders, you and I agree on a lot of PJ takes. This isn't one of them.

[epilogue]

Im one of those who liked Alright a lot when it came out and kinda felt meh about it now. Its the song from Gigaton i like the least.

See Stip!!! Everyone hates it!!!

[stip]

VG counts for 10 alone!

[epilogue]

VG counts for 10 alone!

It's an outrage! Alright is a 5 star song!