Eddie Vedder - Earthling

[Birds in Hell]

man, i really wish i was feeling the same about this record as a whole lot of you are. i am truly surprised by the community reaction to this.

I hated it, but I figure there's not much point telling everyone again and again.

I listened to it again and it only confirmed my visceral initial reaction.

I like 80s Peter Gabriel and Split Enz a great deal, but this record does nothing for me.

Maybe I'm not invested enough in 'Eddie Vedder' to be carried away by his endearing personality, his renewed enthusiasm, etc.

I just think the songs are really weak.

[Jorge]

I don't hate it but I do think this is a one-and-doner for me. My favorite songs were "Try" (which sounds like Ed doing a Frank Turner folk-punk sort of thing) and "Mrs. Mills" which has some nice touches (although it feaures that strained Ed writing - "to none of them she ever will belong"). Even then, I found both of them charming, but wasn't bowled over by either. Aside from "The Haves," which remains one of the worst songs I have ever heard by anyone, I don't think any of it is bad; it's just an extremely OK album I will probably never listen to again

[B]

I listened on Friday. Can't really be bothered to search it on Spotify right now, but I'll probably spin the record if my Fresh Pressed version gets here before July.

[washing machine]

This feels like the page where we find out what happens when people stop being polite and start getting real.

[B]

The civil decorum of Red Mosquito is crumbling right before our eyes.

[Kevin Davis]

This feels like the page where we find out what happens when people stop being polite and start getting real.

Reid, it was most thoughtful of you to share this prediction. You're a fine RM'er!

[Ms Harmless]

The civil decorum of Red Mosquito is crumbling right before our eyes.

fully automated luxury gay space Jammunism

[Ms Harmless]

This feels like the page where we find out what happens when people stop being polite and start getting real.

I love you washing machine

[psychobain]

The new Spoon is gettin all of my time

This was ok

[Jorge]

"Power of Right" reminds me of this song by Mexican rock band Jumbo

[lecherouslittlestump]

This feels like the page where we find out what happens when people stop being polite and start getting real.

It's a fucking dreadful record.

You know how everyone loved The Force Awakens when it came out, but 6 years on everyone agrees it sucks an unbelievable amount of ass?

Same situation here.

[washing machine]

"Power of Right" reminds me of this song by Mexican rock band Jumbo

I actually love this album, but the intro to Power of Right does and likely will always give me very strong Cars (the Pixar film starring Lightning McQueen, not the band starring Ric Ocasek) vibes.



riff @0:34 for those of you who don't have a toddler.

[washing machine]

his renewed enthusiasm

I disagree with this take. Better or worse, it feels like EV is almost always enthusiastic. His verve simply needed a vehicle other than Pearl Jam to make sense for that rough stretch between S/T and Gigaton. At times he found it, mostly on solo efforts, but most times he did not. His enthusiasm is the weak link on those bad PJ albums. Ironically, the two albums he sounds the most exhausted on are two of the band's greatest and most beloved (Riot Act and No Code.)

[Release_Me]

Being invested in Eddie Vedder may have something to do with people's liking of this record but to be honest, even though I'm a huge Ed fan, I would not be gushing over this thing if I didn't think the songs were good. I wasn't posting about Ukulele songs because it was not something that made me go "wow". There were a few nice songs, none were offensive but I don't really seek that record out. ITW was better but again, I'd be OK if he never released it. This one seems an essential release to me, something I am actually glad he put out. It is the quality of the songs and how good he himself sounds. And this deserves repeating: he sounds mostly fantastic on this album.

[Birds in Hell]

I didn't like Ukulele Songs - I thought it was a disappointing rehash of the original recordings - but I really liked Into the Wild a lot.

I could absolutely get behind an EV solo career that used songs like Long Nights or The Wolf as a starting point.

[washing machine]

What I'm reading here is that you're all in on the upcoming On My Way/River Cross split 7", spenno.

[Birds in Hell]

It's not a fair comparison, but the other day I listened to this Van Morrison song right after some of the new EV material and I started thinking how it's exactly the kind of thing I think he'd be great at but doesn't remotely go near:



Slow tempos, moody rumination, sparse instrumentation, a sense of real place and atmosphere - and that sonorous, idiosyncratic voice acting effectively as the lead instrument in the ensemble, holding it all together.

I don't think he has it in him.

[Kevin Davis]

Oh man, I love that Morrison album!

Have you ever listened to Common One? No joke, the lead track, "Haunts of Ancient Peace," might be my favorite audio recording ever. Just sublime, beautiful music.

[Birds in Hell]

No, but I'll definitely check it out.

I haven't listened to much Van Morrison at all.

[Birds in Hell]

Have you ever listened to Common One? No joke, the lead track, "Haunts of Ancient Peace," might be my favorite audio recording ever. Just sublime, beautiful music.

Wow, I love this.