Eddie Vedder - Earthling

[Bammer]

is watt playing the guitar solos?

Yes and he is very fucking good.

[Hatfield]

is watt playing the guitar solos?

This is the direction I'm hoping the conversation veers. I really want to know things like who is playing what. Andrew's style of soloing (live) is right up my alley.

Another aspect to this record that has really stood out the last few listens is having different vocals harmonize instead of it just being Ed. Ed's harmonies are really under-praised, but the lack of them on this record isn't a negative.

[RockPusher]

like there's an uphill battle to convince myself I haven't made an embarrassing error.

I don't understand this at all. An embarrassing error? Like, there are things you *should* like and things you *shouldn't* and guilty pleasures are things to be ashamed of? Screw that. I deeply enjoy Dave Matthews Band. Ban me if you want.

my new favorite poster

Thanks

Is that why you're called "warehouse"?

[warehouse]

like there's an uphill battle to convince myself I haven't made an embarrassing error.

I don't understand this at all. An embarrassing error? Like, there are things you *should* like and things you *shouldn't* and guilty pleasures are things to be ashamed of? Screw that. I deeply enjoy Dave Matthews Band. Ban me if you want.

my new favorite poster

Thanks

Is that why you're called "warehouse"?

yes, it's been my favorite song for like 20 years. i think i've written essays on this board about how great it is lol

[guitar_davey]

it doesn't, it's just really joyless and annoying

Yeah, this.

[guitar_davey]

In My Tree is dumb and people who like it are dumb for liking it

You mean the best Pearl Jam song of all time?

[RockPusher]

like there's an uphill battle to convince myself I haven't made an embarrassing error.

I don't understand this at all. An embarrassing error? Like, there are things you *should* like and things you *shouldn't* and guilty pleasures are things to be ashamed of? Screw that. I deeply enjoy Dave Matthews Band. Ban me if you want.

my new favorite poster

Thanks

Is that why you're called "warehouse"?

yes, it's been my favorite song for like 20 years. i think i've written essays on this board about how great it is lol

Sweet. It's a set closer in my dream setlist.

[warehouse]

like there's an uphill battle to convince myself I haven't made an embarrassing error.

I don't understand this at all. An embarrassing error? Like, there are things you *should* like and things you *shouldn't* and guilty pleasures are things to be ashamed of? Screw that. I deeply enjoy Dave Matthews Band. Ban me if you want.

my new favorite poster

Thanks

Is that why you're called "warehouse"?

yes, it's been my favorite song for like 20 years. i think i've written essays on this board about how great it is lol

Sweet. It's a set closer in my dream setlist.

[warehouse]

did ed mention any of his punk influences in interviews about this album? petty and bruce are pretty clear influences on here, but i'm wondering where some of the punk stuff comes from. its sounds like california type punk. the one song reminded me of the dead kennedys. i dont know X very well but i've heard EV mention them a number of times.

where the fuck did elton john come from? i think he's amazing, but he's not the first person i had teaming up with eddie vedder. i assume he wrote most of the song he's on, it sounds like an elton john song.

i also really like the last song. i know its kinda cheesy to have ed's dad on the album, but knowing the backstory it would almost be a shame if he had his dad's music and never did anything with it. you know the whole story, but it's crazy to think Alive came out over 30 years ago and he just released a song with his dad singing. the song is weird enough to work, i like way it wraps up the whole album.

[tragabigzanda]

did ed mention any of his punk influences in interviews about this album? petty and bruce are pretty clear influences on here, but i'm wondering where some of the punk stuff comes from. its sounds like california type punk. the one song reminded me of the dead kennedys. i dont know X very well but i've heard EV mention them a number of times.

Good & Evil has shades of Public Image Ltd, Fugazi, Dead Kennedys, Buzzcocks…More snappy and spindly, particularly with those single guitar notes on the chorus

Jericho reminds me of X, Husker Du, Black Flag, more of a “three chords and the truth” kind of vibe

[lowlight79]

did ed mention any of his punk influences in interviews about this album? petty and bruce are pretty clear influences on here, but i'm wondering where some of the punk stuff comes from. its sounds like california type punk. the one song reminded me of the dead kennedys. i dont know X very well but i've heard EV mention them a number of times.

Good & Evil has shades of Public Image Ltd, Fugazi, Dead Kennedys, Buzzcocks…More snappy and spindly, particularly with those single guitar notes on the chorus

Jericho reminds me of X, Husker Du, Black Flag, more of a “three chords and the truth” kind of vibe

I may be the only one here who literally thinks Good and Evil is a top song on the record. I'm ok with that.

[tragabigzanda]

You and me both

[Ms Harmless]

did ed mention any of his punk influences in interviews about this album? petty and bruce are pretty clear influences on here, but i'm wondering where some of the punk stuff comes from. its sounds like california type punk. the one song reminded me of the dead kennedys. i dont know X very well but i've heard EV mention them a number of times.

Good & Evil has shades of Public Image Ltd, Fugazi, Dead Kennedys, Buzzcocks…More snappy and spindly, particularly with those single guitar notes on the chorus

Jericho reminds me of X, Husker Du, Black Flag, more of a “three chords and the truth” kind of vibe

I may be the only one here who literally thinks Good and Evil is a top song on the record. I'm ok with that.

I put it at #2

[PHATJ]

like there's an uphill battle to convince myself I haven't made an embarrassing error.

I don't understand this at all. An embarrassing error? Like, there are things you *should* like and things you *shouldn't* and guilty pleasures are things to be ashamed of? Screw that. I deeply enjoy Dave Matthews Band. Ban me if you want.

my new favorite poster

Thanks

Is that why you're called "warehouse"?

yes, it's been my favorite song for like 20 years. i think i've written essays on this board about how great it is lol

Sweet. It's a set closer in my dream setlist.

FYI, I too am a Dave Matthews fan.

[stip]

did ed mention any of his punk influences in interviews about this album? petty and bruce are pretty clear influences on here, but i'm wondering where some of the punk stuff comes from. its sounds like california type punk. the one song reminded me of the dead kennedys. i dont know X very well but i've heard EV mention them a number of times.

Good & Evil has shades of Public Image Ltd, Fugazi, Dead Kennedys, Buzzcocks…More snappy and spindly, particularly with those single guitar notes on the chorus

Jericho reminds me of X, Husker Du, Black Flag, more of a “three chords and the truth” kind of vibe

I may be the only one here who literally thinks Good and Evil is a top song on the record. I'm ok with that.

It's gone up a fair bit for me. I think I have it 5th maybe. Top of my second tier

[Jorge]

did ed mention any of his punk influences in interviews about this album? petty and bruce are pretty clear influences on here, but i'm wondering where some of the punk stuff comes from. its sounds like california type punk. the one song reminded me of the dead kennedys. i dont know X very well but i've heard EV mention them a number of times.

Good & Evil has shades of Public Image Ltd, Fugazi, Dead Kennedys, Buzzcocks…More snappy and spindly, particularly with those single guitar notes on the chorus

Jericho reminds me of X, Husker Du, Black Flag, more of a “three chords and the truth” kind of vibe

"Try" is basically a folk-punk song

[tragabigzanda]

did ed mention any of his punk influences in interviews about this album? petty and bruce are pretty clear influences on here, but i'm wondering where some of the punk stuff comes from. its sounds like california type punk. the one song reminded me of the dead kennedys. i dont know X very well but i've heard EV mention them a number of times.

Good & Evil has shades of Public Image Ltd, Fugazi, Dead Kennedys, Buzzcocks…More snappy and spindly, particularly with those single guitar notes on the chorus

Jericho reminds me of X, Husker Du, Black Flag, more of a “three chords and the truth” kind of vibe

"Try" is basically a folk-punk song

I get that, and I can easily hear The Pogues, Billy Bragg, Ani DiFranco...But the production puts it squarely in "Warped Tour opening act w/a harmonica" territory for me.

[Jorge]

Frank Turner has played Warped Tour so that's fitting

[Strat]

I, too, have played the warped tour. So that’s something

[Ms Harmless]

me too