Yield: Official Album Thread

[bodysnatcher]

what's the overall consensus on "Hummus"?

Love it, and I wish they'd try it live one of these days.

Yeah I've always loved it. I like it when we get those peaks into them goofing around

[epilogue]

what's the overall consensus on "Hummus"?

Love it, and I wish they'd try it live one of these days.

Yeah I've always loved it. I like it when we get those peaks into them goofing around

I think it's the epitome of what a "hidden track" should be. It's perfect. They really nailed it with that one and with Writer's Block on Binuaral. Both of those hidden codas are perfect for their respective albums.

[stip]

i think pj should cover Disgusitpated for their next hidden track.

[Dr. Van Nostrand]

i think pj should cover Disgusitpated for their next hidden track.

What is that?

[stip]

the hidden track (track 69, actually. Get it?!) on Tool's album, undertow. One of my favorite hidden tracks of all time.

[LetMeSleep]

I think the transition between Wishlist and Pilate is really weak.

I agree but I would transition into Pilate 3:26 earlier. I enjoy Yield infinitely more without Wishlist.

I'd have preferred something a bit louder to separate them (Happy When I'm Crying?) or, perhaps even more suitably, a non faded-out ending to Wishlist.

Maybe Happy would work but I don't think it's strong enough. I always want a little something extra after Push Me Pull Me but there was nothing from those sessions that would work. A burst of energy ala Leash or Lukin.

[Birds in Hell]

I'm always heartened to find others who think Wishlist is terrible.

[William Bloke]

Wishlist is one of the few PJ songs I actively dislike.

[WtOB?]

I sometimes, out of nowhere, get a strange affection for it and ill listen to it and enjoy it. The rest of the time I skip it. It's pretty awful with Matt Cam.

[Sigerson]

I adore the album version of Wishlist. Don't care for it much live. Sure, it's a simple track but doesn't keep me from enjoying it. It's beautiful and understated, unlike Unthought Known (a track which I do actively dislike).

[Birds in Hell]

As bad as Wishlist is, Unthought Known is certainly a lot worse.

[Hatfield]

I adore the album version of Wishlist. Don't care for it much live. Sure, it's a simple track but doesn't keep me from enjoying it. It's beautiful and understated, unlike Unthought Known (a track which I do actively dislike).

Wishlist>Why Can't I Touch It at 7/11/03 was one of the highlights.

[Dr. Van Nostrand]

I adore the album version of Wishlist. Don't care for it much live. Sure, it's a simple track but doesn't keep me from enjoying it. It's beautiful and understated, unlike Unthought Known (a track which I do actively dislike).

the good part about it live is the mirror ball, as simple as it is i always like the lights with the mirror ball and i cant remember any other songs they might use it for.

[EJ]

There's absolutely nothing wrong with Wishlist.

[Angus]

I absolutely adore studio version Wishlist.

[worldwithyourheart]

I adore the album version of Wishlist. Don't care for it much live. Sure, it's a simple track but doesn't keep me from enjoying it. It's beautiful and understated, unlike Unthought Known (a track which I do actively dislike).

Wishlist>Why Can't I Touch It at 7/11/03 was one of the highlights.

Eddie hacks that version, but the tag/ crowd are great.

[worldwithyourheart]

As bad as Wishlist is, Unthought Known is certainly a lot worse.

I love them both.

[harmless]

There's absolutely nothing wrong with Wishlist.

Wishlist is an excellent song.

Unthought Known is not.

[Jorge]

I can't hate "Wishlist" too much. It's a sweet song (where 'sweet' means tender, pleasant and heartfelt, not 'sweet' as in the modern parlance of 'awesome').

[stip]

i love wishlist. I always have.