1-11: Alive vs. W.M.A.

[stip]

Voting open until 8ish EST 3/6/24

[Farmer John]

W.M.A.

[liebzz]

WMA is a great song, but it’s Alive, man.

[stip]

yeah, wtf Farmer John?

[Farmer John]

Oh, I'm sorry, I thought this was America!

[dad]

Alive is aight, but there’s something about the way guitar tech-shaming Eddie Vedder sings the outro chorus on W.M.A. that makes it a better song.

[Kevin Davis]

"Alive" hasn't been one of my favorite PJ songs for probably 25 years, and it always falters fairly early in the competition for me because so many other songs just seem so much better-written. "WMA" is a similarly impassioned performance, but in my opinion it's a better-crafted, more unique piece of music. Jumping on the contrarian train!

[liebzz]

If Pearl Jam were Donald Trump: “Yeezus greets me, looks just like me”

[wease]

Took his mother’s white breast to his tongue.

[WaitingForBluey]

WMA... and not just to piss off stip either

[Farmer John]

Stip getting nervous

[stip]

every time I think RM can’t hurt me again…

[VinylGuy]

Alive

[epilogue]

WMA

[Monkey_Driven]

Why is this so close? Clearly Alive.

[Anders]

Alive

[Got Some]

Alive is a classic

WMA is a slow burn. I remember hearing Vs for the first time and WMA was one of the tracks I didn’t click with immediately.

[elliseamos]

Alive.

[Anders]

Alive is really good, but it's nearly impossible not to get a bit tired of it. Also even back in the early 90s, it was never my favorite. Still the better of these two songs.

[stip]

Alive wins in a would be shockingly close anywhere else matchup 25-21