MM 4-6: Scared of Fear vs. Setting Sun

[stip]

Scared of Fear vs. Setting Sun

Round is closed 8 PM EST 4/25

[stip]

I think Scared of Fear. This is incredibly close.

[Gigalogy84]

This is tough but gotta go with Scared of Fear.

[Jaeti]

Setting Sun for now, as it was an immediate classic for me. Scared of Fear gets better every time I hear it, though.

[Fattie_Vedder]

It’s always a great sign of the quality of the album when it’s so hard to choose. Team Setting Sun for the beauty and devastation.

[Farmer John]

These might be my top 2 on the album at the moment, but still an easy vote for Setting Sun

[Stardog Champion]

Setting Sun is my early favorite on Dark Matter.

[Anders]

Scared of Fear

[EJ]

Scared Of Fear is a great song, and my interest in it is still climbing. However, Setting Sun is already an all-time PJ favorite of mine. And, I can't believe I'm saying that at this stage of their game. It really is that great though.

[Bammer]

Honestly I think the “setting sun” lyric in Scared Of Fear stands out more than in Setting Sun itself

[Buby]

Setting Sun isn't better than Upper Hand

[digster]

Both of these songs didn't land hard for me on the first few listens, but Scared of Fear has definitely improved over time to get into my top 5 on the record. I like the first part of Setting Sun, but it loses me after that, so this is a pretty easy choice.

[stip]

Setting Sun advances