Apple Atmos

[dimejinky99]

Come back to me when lost dogs and all the Christmas singles are on there

We need to hear Olympic platinum and happy when I’m crying and strangest tribe with this new voodoo sound



Strangers tribe could be amazing with this

[darth_vedder]

I have Apple Music, but turned Atmos off. I'm usually listening to music via my external JBL speakers. They're really old and still plug in via USB, so I don't think Atmos is for me yet. I have been thinking of getting a HomePod for the kitchen and those support Atmos (currently have an old HK Onyx there).

[Ms Harmless]

I've also turned Atmos off in Amazon Music; where Dark Matter is concerned, it was making the melodic tracks lovely and nuanced, but the rhythmic ones, especially the drums, very distant and buried under guitars; Pearl Jam has always been a drum-forward band for me, so for better and worse, I have to admit I'll take "pop" drum sounds over distant drums

[darth_vedder]

I've also turned Atmos off in Amazon Music; where Dark Matter is concerned, it was making the melodic tracks lovely and nuanced, but the rhythmic ones, especially the drums, very distant and buried under guitars; Pearl Jam has always been a drum-forward band for me, so for better and worse, I have to admit I'll take "pop" drum sounds over distant drums

I'm generally with you, and want to hear Matt in all of his glory.

Off topic somewhat, but I suppose that's probably why I prefer the Ten Redux... I hear way more of Dave K. and like hearing the drums "pop" more on Ten.

[Ms Harmless]

I've also turned Atmos off in Amazon Music; where Dark Matter is concerned, it was making the melodic tracks lovely and nuanced, but the rhythmic ones, especially the drums, very distant and buried under guitars; Pearl Jam has always been a drum-forward band for me, so for better and worse, I have to admit I'll take "pop" drum sounds over distant drums

I'm generally with you, and want to hear Matt in all of his glory.

Off topic somewhat, but I suppose that's probably why I prefer the Ten Redux... I hear way more of Dave K. and like hearing the drums "pop" more on Ten.

I need to listen to that again, I'm still very attached to the original Ten for nostalgia reasons, even in all of its retro 80s/90s cusp glory

[darth_vedder]

I've also turned Atmos off in Amazon Music; where Dark Matter is concerned, it was making the melodic tracks lovely and nuanced, but the rhythmic ones, especially the drums, very distant and buried under guitars; Pearl Jam has always been a drum-forward band for me, so for better and worse, I have to admit I'll take "pop" drum sounds over distant drums

I'm generally with you, and want to hear Matt in all of his glory.

Off topic somewhat, but I suppose that's probably why I prefer the Ten Redux... I hear way more of Dave K. and like hearing the drums "pop" more on Ten.

I need to listen to that again, I'm still very attached to the original Ten for nostalgia reasons, even in all of its retro 80s/90s cusp glory

Most seem for prefer the original for that fluid and ambient sound it has. The Redux is a little more like Vs. and just hits harder. I can see why people don't like that, especially those that have Ten as their favorite.

[stip]

i think the remixes serve the harder songs well but flatten out the expansiveness that is part of the character of songs like release and oceans. the reverb is a feature, not a bug

[digster]

Yeah, on my most recent listen I tried the remix but switched back pretty quickly. It may just be nostalgia talking, but I do feel like Ten benefits from the murk, even if it also dates it in a way their other records aren't.

[darth_vedder]

i think the remixes serve the harder songs well but flatten out the expansiveness that is part of the character of songs like release and oceans. the reverb is a feature, not a bug

I think this is it right here. You gave me an for a new playlist, Ten Redux with Reverb;
- Once (Redux)
- Even Flow (single version with Dave A.)
- Alive (RVM version)
- Why Go (Redux)
- Black (Original)
- Jeremy (Original)
- Oceans (Original)
- Porch (Redux)
- Garden (Original)
- Deep (Redux)
- Release (Original)

edited to include Black and fix Jeremy

[stip]

you made the right choice on Alive.

No Black?

[darth_vedder]

how could I forget Black? That would be the original mix of course. Not sure why I put No Jeremey, but why not? When I'm in the mood to listen to Jeremy, that's the version I go for anyway.

[BootsToAsses]

The piano during the chorus of Black is slightly clearer on the redux and I much prefer it.

Are the RVM mixes different from the Redux versions?? How did I miss that.

[stip]

all 3 are different and i think superior to remix (since he already did his best work on rvm)

[bodysnatcher]

I can’t tell the difference in any of this shit

[Farmer John]

My appreciation of the “Spatial Audio” experience varies quite widely. Sometimes song to song. Sometimes within a single song.

At its worst it can be a distraction and just a plain old inferior mix than the version you’re used to. When done well (which usually means not too extreme) it can be wonderful (Listen to whichever song you want from the Deluxe Edition of Stop Making Sense and tell me that’s not the greatest thing you’ve ever heard)

Even when it’s a distraction, like Stip said, it can be an interesting tool to pull apart all the elements of a song you’ve heard a million times and look around at all the components you didn’t necessarily notice were there.

That being said, most of the time I have it turned off

[stip]

Wow, the Gigaton Atmos mix is not good. It's basically Eddie and everything else is disconnected and far behind him (Eddie sounds great, though). This is brutal on the guitars.

[stip]

I'm almost through. This is really a showcase for how good Eddie sounded on Gigaton. And it's weird, since one of the things we all liked about Gigaton after Lightning Bolt was that he seemed a little further back/seemed like more of a band affair at least in terms of the mixing if not the writing (am I remembering that correctly)?

[stip]

Ohhh, I should note that Comes then Goes actually sounds BETTER than Gigaton. A little more intimate, and the distant guitar makes the whole piece feel a little more thoughtful and pensive.

[stip]

Final addendum. River Cross is also greatly improved. It comes across as much less busy and centers the weary beauty in Eddie's voice

[oneway23]

Interesting thoughts about Gigaton, stip...Believe we've spoken about this, but, it was the first record Josh Evans had ever done in the format, prior to learning and working under Nick Rivas.
He didn't even know what the format was until the band personally requested it.

Definitely far from a demo disc, but, he's grown leaps and bounds since then. Everyone is still learning.