MM F5: Immortality vs. Corduroy

[epilogue]

I don't think I've made my obligatory MM post yet this year:

Corduroy is a great song. Corduroy is also the band's most overrated song.

[dimejinky99]

I don't think I've made my obligatory MM post yet this year:

Corduroy is a great song. Corduroy is also the band's most overrated song.

I never thought it would end like this…

How could you??


*distraught*

[Jorge]

I don't think I've made my obligatory MM post yet this year:

Corduroy is a great song. Corduroy is also the band's most overrated song.

This, but about "Immortality," and removing the part about it being great, because it sucks

[epilogue]

I don't think I've made my obligatory MM post yet this year:

Corduroy is a great song. Corduroy is also the band's most overrated song.

I never thought it would end like this…

How could you??


*distraught*

I still love Corduroy! It's an incredible song. But it isn't even top 5 song on Vitalogy, let alone the best thing the band has recorded.

[epilogue]

I don't think I've made my obligatory MM post yet this year:

Corduroy is a great song. Corduroy is also the band's most overrated song.

This, but about "Immortality," and removing the part about it being great, because it sucks

Your undying hatred for Immortality is genuinely one of my favorite RM things.

[Jorge]

Mine too

[wease]

were there crowd sing alongs for Corduroy last tour?

Unfortunately

[liebzz]

I voted for Immortality but I do think in many ways Corduroy is probably the most representative song of theirs in the catalogue and the most uniquely them. Both songs have been with us 30 years and in the context of now, Immortality speaks to me more. Yet, when I go back to walking out of my very first Pearl Jam show in 1996 with my close friends glowing about one of the most amazing experiences of our lives, the song we were gushing about was Corduroy, and what it was like to experience that one live. There are many other songs that are uniquely Pearl Jam, but that one seems to somehow be an amalgam of their sound. I still voted for Immortality.

In my final desperate bid to save Immortality: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=StTu1I_IloE

[dimejinky99]

I don't think I've made my obligatory MM post yet this year:

Corduroy is a great song. Corduroy is also the band's most overrated song.

I never thought it would end like this…

How could you??


*distraught*

I still love Corduroy! It's an incredible song. But it isn't even top 5 song on Vitalogy, let alone the best thing the band has recorded.

Merciful hour…

Dig up!! You’re not helping here!!

I’m finished here can’t even believe you said this

[dimejinky99]

Mine too

We finally have a common cause. We’re best pals now.

Immortality is an overrated mess

[The Town]

I don't think I've made my obligatory MM post yet this year:

Corduroy is a great song. Corduroy is also the band's most overrated song.

This, but about "Immortality," and removing the part about it being great, because it sucks

Jorge, what's one of your favorite songs you view as quintessential PJ?

[The Town]

were there crowd sing alongs for Corduroy last tour?

Unfortunately

[liebzz]

were there crowd sing alongs for Corduroy last tour?

Unfortunately

If Corduroy wins, the call and response wins with. Yeah yeah yeah! Yeaaaaah!

[Farmer John]

As a fabric, corduroy is the essence of comfort and style.

[Jorge]

I don't think I've made my obligatory MM post yet this year:

Corduroy is a great song. Corduroy is also the band's most overrated song.

This, but about "Immortality," and removing the part about it being great, because it sucks

Jorge, what's one of your favorite songs you view as quintessential PJ?

I don't really know how to answer "quintessential" but here's a playlist with my favorite PJ songs: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2aqn1 ... 943385406c

[Gigalogy84]

Corduroy is the ultimate Pearl Jam song in my opinion.

[Farmer John]

If you really think about it, this matchup is the ultimate Pearl Jam song vs. the penultimate Vitalogy song.

[stip]

I don't think I've made my obligatory MM post yet this year:

Corduroy is a great song. Corduroy is also the band's most overrated song.

This, but about "Immortality," and removing the part about it being great, because it sucks

Jorge, what's one of your favorite songs you view as quintessential PJ?

I don't really know how to answer "quintessential" but here's a playlist with my favorite PJ songs: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2aqn1 ... 943385406c

god, it’s like you took my bottom twenty pearl jam songs and added last exit

[stip]

Corduroy advances to its traditional place in the finals