gems and rhinestones wrote:I really liked this performance. I also really liked watching the blonde girl in the back dance, she was cute as hell. (front row, second from left)
Yeah I spent some time watching that too
I didn't really care for it. The ending was kind of cool and unique though.
Tonight is Dierks Bentley, country superstar and general curly-locked studmuffin. My wife is a fan of his--he does typical assembly line Nashville shit, but he also has an affinity for traditional bluegrass/gospel-type stuff that I find refreshing among musicians of his kind. He did a covers album a few years back that featured bluegrass arrangements of Bob Dylan's "Senor" and U2's "Pride," so he's at least somewhat adherent to his own whims.
Kevin Davis wrote:Pecknold is one of my favorite singers in the business but I think his voice kind of shrinks under the weight of a song like this--or maybe it was just the arrangement, I don't know, but something about it just felt rote. I liked Cornell's performance better but would ultimately say that he similarly failed to get to the heart of the song in the way that I know both of these singers are capable. ."
Anything from the ten through Vitalogy era is going to be difficult for any singer to pull off.
I think what these two performance display is the power and emotion of pre 96 Ed vocals. There have been many singers with better technical skills. But only a few singers can combine that emotional edge with great talent And when its not "your song" - I would imagine its tough to get that level. Aaron Lewis did a great job with "Black" in terms of the emotional aspect of the song (though the performance ultimatley lacked).
I didn't see or hear anything wrong with that Corduroy performance, and it's my favourite PJ song. The only issue with the Chris Cornell one was that it was Cornell, and I'm kind of bored of grunge musicians doing each others' grunge songs.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
Kevin Davis wrote:Tonight is Dierks Bentley, country superstar and general curly-locked studmuffin. My wife is a fan of his--he does typical assembly line Nashville shit, but he also has an affinity for traditional bluegrass/gospel-type stuff that I find refreshing among musicians of his kind. He did a covers album a few years back that featured bluegrass arrangements of Bob Dylan's "Senor" and U2's "Pride," so he's at least somewhat adherent to his own whims.
Here's one of his tunes I've always kind of dug:
He's also a frequent coverer of Just Breathe, so fingers crossed that it's not that.
it really didn't seem to have any emotional core to it that I was able to pick up. If someone played me that song and said he was covering one of pearl jam's greatest songs I'd wonder why anyone would care about it.
Kevin Davis wrote:Tonight is Dierks Bentley, country superstar and general curly-locked studmuffin. My wife is a fan of his--he does typical assembly line Nashville shit, but he also has an affinity for traditional bluegrass/gospel-type stuff that I find refreshing among musicians of his kind. He did a covers album a few years back that featured bluegrass arrangements of Bob Dylan's "Senor" and U2's "Pride," so he's at least somewhat adherent to his own whims.
Here's one of his tunes I've always kind of dug:
He's also a frequent coverer of Just Breathe, so fingers crossed that it's not that.
am I making up that he's covering off he goes? that sounds familiar to me.
harmless wrote:I didn't see or hear anything wrong with that Corduroy performance,.
The vocals were too light...too flat... Its already been mentioned before but its worth repeating. The song needed to be arranged differently for the vocal performance to work.
Kevin Davis wrote:Tonight is Dierks Bentley, country superstar and general curly-locked studmuffin. My wife is a fan of his--he does typical assembly line Nashville shit, but he also has an affinity for traditional bluegrass/gospel-type stuff that I find refreshing among musicians of his kind. He did a covers album a few years back that featured bluegrass arrangements of Bob Dylan's "Senor" and U2's "Pride," so he's at least somewhat adherent to his own whims.
Here's one of his tunes I've always kind of dug:
He's also a frequent coverer of Just Breathe, so fingers crossed that it's not that.
Oh Fuck! It may be "Just Breathe"! That actually makes sense... but the mcCready aspect makes me think it may not be... What other options make sense?
E.H. Ruddock wrote:The audience behind him last night really annoyed me for some reason.
I dunno know why since they were obviously huge fans of the band and were not just there to sway awkwardly. I think I reckognized a few from "The Fixer" video.
harmless wrote:I didn't see or hear anything wrong with that Corduroy performance,.
The vocals were too light...too flat... Its already been mentioned before but its worth repeating. The song needed to be arranged differently for the vocal performance to work.
I disagree. Light? Flat? Is this just a version of "It didn't sound good without Eddie Vedder?" I don't get it, the guy had a great voice and this was a really good version. Oh well, what do I know?
But yeah, the audience was really funny.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
harmless wrote:I didn't see or hear anything wrong with that Corduroy performance,.
The vocals were too light...too flat... Its already been mentioned before but its worth repeating. The song needed to be arranged differently for the vocal performance to work.
I disagree. Light? Flat? Is this just a version of "It didn't sound good without Eddie Vedder?" I don't get it, the guy had a great voice and this was a really good version. Oh well, what do I know?
But yeah, the audience was really funny.
I dug it. It was kinda nice to experience the music, and about 60% of the lyrics, separated from either the "weight of the world" quality of the studio version or the "we're older now but let's celebrate" surrealism of the live performances. Just a different color to look at, was all.
A few of the mopier lines played out a little awkward, though.
What are you hoping pj play? I'm assuming getaway is a given. They should play pendulum or yellow moon. Please let them not play FD, LTRP or sirens or infallibleh.
