Is culture dead?

[Bi_3]

Seems to be a hot topic in the chattering classes recently. Kinda feels that way.

[darth_vedder]

Maybe? I was wondering the other day about the last major scene that originated in a city (because I watched Hype! on Prime). For example, Seattle. Was that the last kind of organic scene that was (mostly) city specific? Many of us were around during that time and it didn't matter where you were, what country you were in, anywhere on a global level (largely pre-internet), and it was "Seattle this" and "Seattle that". For like 4 straight years. Has that happened since? I know I'm old and shit, and I know nothing tops Tay right now, but she doesn't have a whole city scene with tons of artist like Seattle had/still has.

[tragabigzanda]

FUCK ICE

[darth_vedder]

Maybe? I was wondering the other day about the last major scene that originated in a city (because I watched Hype! on Prime). For example, Seattle. Was that the last kind of organic scene that was (mostly) city specific? Many of us were around during that time and it didn't matter where you were, what country you were in, anywhere on a global level (largely pre-internet), and it was "Seattle this" and "Seattle that". For like 4 straight years. Has that happened since? I know I'm old and shit, and I know nothing tops Tay right now, but she doesn't have a whole city scene with tons of artist like Seattle had/still has.

Have you forgotten about the Brooklyn marketing deluge of the early aughts? It's why all our cocktails are served by Rollie Fingers now.

Oh yeah, NYC in the late 90's / early 2000s with the Strokes leading the way. To clarify above too, I was only talking music and scenes specific to a city. NYC has had lots of them, London too. LA and San Fransisco and many other cities all have seen their share. They used to be pretty norm and what would drive trends, like rap in the 1980s and everyone wearing Adidas. I was not talking about anything outside of music scenes in specific cities.

[BurtReynolds]

Woah woah ease up on the culture talk, culture warriors!

[tragabigzanda]

FUCK ICE

[Jorge]

Culture is obviously not dead. Culture can't die. You're asking something different, though I'm not sure what

[B]

[96583UP]

christ what 7th grade english lit desk circle did i accidentally just step into

[Simple Torture]

Yo what do we think the green light means

[Bi_3]

Maybe? I was wondering the other day about the last major scene that originated in a city (because I watched Hype! on Prime). For example, Seattle. Was that the last kind of organic scene that was (mostly) city specific? Many of us were around during that time and it didn't matter where you were, what country you were in, anywhere on a global level (largely pre-internet), and it was "Seattle this" and "Seattle that". For like 4 straight years. Has that happened since? I know I'm old and shit, and I know nothing tops Tay right now, but she doesn't have a whole city scene with tons of artist like Seattle had/still has.

Have you forgotten about the Brooklyn marketing deluge of the early aughts? It's why all our cocktails are served by Rollie Fingers now.

Oh yeah, NYC in the late 90's / early 2000s with the Strokes leading the way. To clarify above too, I was only talking music and scenes specific to a city. NYC has had lots of them, London too. LA and San Fransisco and many other cities all have seen their share. They used to be pretty norm and what would drive trends, like rap in the 1980s and everyone wearing Adidas. I was not talking about anything outside of music scenes in specific cities.

I suspect hip-hop culture is the most recent easily identifiable cultural shift. Since then has there been significant new styles of art? Fashion? Architecture? Food? Anything really.... it feels like we are stuck in the whole "middle children of history" moment and all the great minds are stuck doing HFT work.

[tragabigzanda]

FUCK ICE

[BurtReynolds]

It's gonna get very French in here and I'm not ready for it.

[Bi_3]

I think you’re asking about broadly shared pop-cultural experiences? To which I’d say we (westerners and modernized European countries) mostly exist in siloed pop-cultural feedback loops now, thanks to the algorithm. Broad experiences are engineered by people like Kevin Feige.

But of course micro cultures still exist. This very website is one such example.

If you’re talking specifically about music, I’d just say stop listening to rock, rap, and country music. Reject them with all your might and you’ll find a world of rich musical cultures full of innovation.

Spoiler: show

Pearl Jam sucks now

This is probably closer to the truth. It all feels largely static at this point.

[BurtReynolds]

If you delve too deep on this subject you'll start to wonder why everything is so goddamned beige.

[tragabigzanda]

FUCK ICE

[spike]

haha dammit didn’t get in before beige burt

[Bi_3]

What was the last "culture" or element of culture you latched on to?

[E.H. Ruddock]

Just a bunch of middle-aged, mostly well off white men working out whether or not culture is dead.

[spike]

Just a bunch of middle-aged, mostly well off white men working out whether or not culture is dead.

Is supportive footwear a culture?