Dark Matter: Official Album Thread

[Monkey_Driven]

my ears are still ringing from when i tried listened a couple weeks ago

I don't believe you

[daft twat]

Listened with headphones while doing yard work. It’s my favorite since Vitalogy. What a gift in 2024!

[Birds in Hell]

I will never listen to this record again.

[RockPusher]

I will never listen to this record again.

But I bet you will continue to post in its thread!

[tommy]

I will never listen to this record again.

We'll see about that

[Matters]

It’s harsh on the ears. No one can deny that.
Gigaton gave us new hope. Earthling gave us reason to believe in that hope. DM gave us the realization that they could still make an album that made us feel the way we did when we listened to the first 7.

[Aunt_Claire_Foy]

Earthling gave us reason to believe in that hope.

Man that record was *not* good.

[liebzz]

There’s some stuff on Earthling I really still enjoy a lot. The Dark is probably still my favorite song there just because it is such the amalgam of classic rock when it’s relieved of its weight. Fallout Today is perfect for a solo release. Rose of Jericho rocks, Mrs. Mills is still quite nice, On My Way is contextually heavy. Even for an album that as a whole seems the spritziest of all Pearl Jam related releases off the top of my head, the thing to me hits way more than it misses.

[stip]

You left out Try!

[Monkey_Driven]

I'd take 3-4 songs off Earthling over 3-4 songs on Dark Matter.

[epilogue]

I'd take 3-4 songs off Earthling over 3-4 songs on Dark Matter.

Easy

[stip]

I think Invincible, Try, and In The Dark would make it over a few. Maybe Mrs. Mills. But Earthlings is also great. No shade there.

[stip]

Obviously the haves

[Monkey_Driven]

Dark Matter really needs a song like Fallout Today.

[stip]

Dark Matter really needs a song like Fallout Today.

it has something special in that role. Which I like a lot, but it comes late.

[basically_infirmed]

Earthling gave us reason to believe in that hope.

Man that record was *not* good.

I thought this was the most inspired Eddie sounded in several years and that carried over to Dark Matter. The Haves was bad though.

[epilogue]

Dark Matter really needs a song like Fallout Today.

it has something special in that role. Which I like a lot, but it comes late.

I would need to listen to that song again. But my memory is that I really don't like it. Like, it's probably better than Something Special? But maybe not because I could sing you Something Special and I only remember Fallout Today because I have a visceral negative reaction to the title.

[Birds in Hell]

Both Earthling and DM were big misses for me.

Hopefully the end of the Wotman Jam era isn't far away.

[RockPusher]

Dark Matter really needs a song like Fallout Today.

it has something special in that role. Which I like a lot, but it comes late.

I would need to listen to that song again. But my memory is that I really don't like it. Like, it's probably better than Something Special? But maybe not because I could sing you Something Special and I only remember Fallout Today because I have a visceral negative reaction to the title.

Man I friggin' love Fallout Today!

[epilogue]

Dark Matter really needs a song like Fallout Today.

it has something special in that role. Which I like a lot, but it comes late.

I would need to listen to that song again. But my memory is that I really don't like it. Like, it's probably better than Something Special? But maybe not because I could sing you Something Special and I only remember Fallout Today because I have a visceral negative reaction to the title.

Man I friggin' love Fallout Today!

It's toward the bottom of my Earthling rankings.