Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 11

[Farmer John]

although if Retrograde gets in I would be delighted by The Fixer/Sleeping By Myself

Aye Yai Yai!

[Chris_H_2]

Guys, it's got to be Yellow Moon here. Just swallow the bitter pill.

to compensate for the previous idiotic choices? not a chance.

A LB song does need to be included, you know

i do!

[liebzz]

If track 12 is Come Back, I think Retrograde kind of works best before it rather than Yellow Moon. But this is the corner we’ve painted ourselves into.

[Kevin Davis]

“Yellow Moon” is one of those songs that I’d love to hear dirtied up a little bit — something a bit less pristine-sounding, perhaps something similar to that version of “Let Me Sleep” from PJ20. The composition feels rootsy/bluesy in a way not a lot of PJ songs do, a style which is served especially poorly by LB’s production choices.

[tommy]

When I think about Yellow Moon I hear Pearl Jam covering Harvest Moon, which is absolutely something I could see myself voting for.

[epilogue]

Yellow Moon is great. Always has been.

[Jorge]

“Yellow Moon” is one of those songs that I’d love to hear dirtied up a little bit — something a bit less pristine-sounding, perhaps something similar to that version of “Let Me Sleep” from PJ20. The composition feels rootsy/bluesy in a way not a lot of PJ songs do, a style which is served especially poorly by LB’s production choices.

Instead it ends up sounding New Agey by way of Massage Envy spas, with a melody like molasses. Yuck

[Anders]

Yellow Moon is great. Always has been.

Best LB song.

[VinylGuy]

It’s yellow moon and dance from gigaton

[LoathedVermin72]

lmao I'm not voting for any of these, get real

[Birds in Hell]

Retrograde is a good song.

Yellow Moon not so much.

Some regrettable choices have been made along the way unfortunately.

[Anders]

Retrograde is the weakest song on Gigaton.

[wease]

No matter what’s picked here, we all lose

[tommy]

What backspacer song are we going to end up with?

[Chris_H_2]

whatever it is, it's what's deserved.

[knee tunes]

All 3 of these songs are beautiful

[Farmer John]

What backspacer song are we going to end up with?

Force of Nature probably

[E.H. Ruddock]

It’s weird that the two songs everyone got bonered up about being on this were DotC and DtE. Two great songs but i feel like there could have been some concessions to have more quantity of good songs on this. You should all smash your boners with a dictionary

[Monkey_Driven]

It’s weird that the two songs everyone got bonered up about being on this were DotC and DtE. Two great songs but i feel like there could have been some concessions to have more quantity of good songs on this. You should all smash your boners with a dictionary

Dang

[Anders]

Need a LB song on the album, so better get the best one, and even if you think it’s tight between the remaining LB songs, surely Dance is far better than Retrograde.