Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Lament · Post by **Lament** » Wed October 30, 2013 11:11 am

Yeah, he's got a touch of Freddie Mercury in his vocals. He's got some really great aggressive vocals on each record, but even then he might not be growly enough for your tastes...

Post by **stip** » Wed October 30, 2013 11:13 am

I like Tim booth from James an awful lot, but I guess he also has that cracked low end.

The girls just woke up. I'll listen later though

Post by **stip** » Wed October 30, 2013 1:23 pm

Lament wrote:Yeah, he's got a touch of Freddie Mercury in his vocals. He's got some really great aggressive vocals on each record, but even then he might not be growly enough for your tastes...

yeah, you can really hear the freddy mercury in that one. I think they're just not gonna be my thing.

William Bloke · Post by **William Bloke** » Wed October 30, 2013 2:32 pm

stip wrote:no christmas song will get my vote on general principle

How to Make Gravy is much more than just a christmas song. It's a perfect slice of normal life, longing and want, happiness and regret, all tied up in 5 minutes of exceptional story telling. It's a song that I've heard at least 200 times and yet will still evoke real physical emotion from me if I happen to be alone when I hear it.

John Butler described it thus, and I can't do better:

I just reacquainted myself with the lyrics online and I have to say it brought tears to my eyes again. What a wordsmith! This song is the perfect example of what we as artists try to do – to explain and convey the very emotion and feeling of a situation and setting in just a few words. It is an art and there is something divine about the process, and Paul has that gift. This song is steeped in modern Australian culture. How is it that I feel like I know Dan, Rita, Frank, Dolly and the kids? I can smell the roast and see the cars parked in the front yard. The stubby holders, piles of wrapping paper, the heat rippling up from the road and the camaraderie in the busy kitchen. I’ve been at that Christmas … or have I? Either way, after hearing, feeling, experiencing that song, I have now.

I actually doubt that you'd like it regardless stip, just guaging the general feel I get for your tastes. I'm pretty sure you won't like Paul Kelly's voice and I suspect that the intrinsic and basic "straylianism" of it might not resonate with you, but you never know. If you do give it a bash the album version is what you want to listen to.

Post by **stip** » Wed October 30, 2013 2:36 pm

I'll listen later. I don't know the song. If it is not traditioanl schmaltzy christmas crap maybe i'll like it

Heathen · Post by **Heathen** » Wed October 30, 2013 2:40 pm

stip, I BEG YOU, do a LAL in the Mogwai thread

corduroy2121 · Post by **corduroy2121** » Wed October 30, 2013 3:21 pm

stip wrote:no christmas song will get my vote on general principle

How to Make Gravy is not a traditional Christmas song. It is a great nomination and while it may not match Pearl Jam's best in many ways it is a truly incredible song

William Bloke · Post by **William Bloke** » Wed October 30, 2013 3:27 pm

corduroy2121 wrote:
stip wrote:no christmas song will get my vote on general principle
How to Make Gravy is not a traditional Christmas song. It is a great nomination and while it may not match Pearl Jam's best in many ways it is a truly incredible song

I would like to buy you a beer, Sir.

(Please excuse my gendarial assumption)

Post by **stip** » Wed October 30, 2013 4:03 pm

Heathen wrote:stip, I BEG YOU, do a LAL in the Mogwai thread

who would I be pissing off? BurtReynolds and I dislike a lot of the same stuff. I can't alienate an ally like that.

harmless · Post by **harmless** » Wed October 30, 2013 4:07 pm

I've never heard a better song than my favourite songs by Pearl Jam (of which Corduroy is my favourite).

Heathen · Post by **Heathen** » Wed October 30, 2013 4:13 pm

stip wrote:
Heathen wrote:stip, I BEG YOU, do a LAL in the Mogwai thread
who would I be pissing off? BurtReynolds and I dislike a lot of the same stuff. I can't alienate an ally like that.

probably Soma but then again what doesn't piss him off?

nyquillyn · Post by **nyquillyn** » Wed October 30, 2013 4:21 pm

stip wrote:maybe mogwai is a really good band with some great stuff but that song was an idiotic nomination

This means I won this thread, right? What's my prize?

Post by **stip** » Wed October 30, 2013 4:38 pm

Varis wrote:
stip wrote:no christmas song will get my vote on general principle
How to Make Gravy is much more than just a christmas song. It's a perfect slice of normal life, longing and want, happiness and regret, all tied up in 5 minutes of exceptional story telling. It's a song that I've heard at least 200 times and yet will still evoke real physical emotion from me if I happen to be alone when I hear it.

John Butler described it thus, and I can't do better:

I just reacquainted myself with the lyrics online and I have to say it brought tears to my eyes again. What a wordsmith! This song is the perfect example of what we as artists try to do – to explain and convey the very emotion and feeling of a situation and setting in just a few words. It is an art and there is something divine about the process, and Paul has that gift. This song is steeped in modern Australian culture. How is it that I feel like I know Dan, Rita, Frank, Dolly and the kids? I can smell the roast and see the cars parked in the front yard. The stubby holders, piles of wrapping paper, the heat rippling up from the road and the camaraderie in the busy kitchen. I’ve been at that Christmas … or have I? Either way, after hearing, feeling, experiencing that song, I have now.

I actually doubt that you'd like it regardless stip, just guaging the general feel I get for your tastes. I'm pretty sure you won't like Paul Kelly's voice and I suspect that the intrinsic and basic "straylianism" of it might not resonate with you, but you never know. If you do give it a bash the album version is what you want to listen to.

that's a pretty touching song. I owe it an apology

William Bloke · Post by **William Bloke** » Wed October 30, 2013 4:41 pm

I'm a fan of a lot of Mogwai's stuff but they don't have a horse in this race. Having said that Auto Rock is a cracker and is more representative of the side of the band that I most appreciate (as compared to Batcat).

<edit> and cheers for giving How to Make Gravy a listen stip. It is good, isn't it?

Post by **stip** » Wed October 30, 2013 4:50 pm

you're right that the singer is my thing (I don't have a problem with meandering songs like that, though), but the story is pretty touching.

Post by **Jorge** » Wed October 30, 2013 5:04 pm

Heathen wrote:stip, I BEG YOU, do a LAL in the Mogwai thread

"Does anything happen? Where's the singer? WHERE ARE WORDS?"

Post by **Jorge** » Wed October 30, 2013 5:05 pm

"THEY HAVE BEEN PLAYING MUSIC FOR 8 MINUTES THIS IS A VERY LONG INTRO"

Post by **Jorge** » Wed October 30, 2013 5:23 pm

"ok. one with words. I like this one more. The lyrics are stupid tho."

bada · Post by **bada** » Wed October 30, 2013 5:26 pm

Christmas With The Rat Pack will change your life Stip.

Post by **stip** » Wed October 30, 2013 8:24 pm

theplatypus wrote:
Heathen wrote:stip, I BEG YOU, do a LAL in the Mogwai thread
"Does anything happen? Where's the singer? WHERE ARE WORDS?"

man, that was just a boring song even for an instrumental

Red Mosquito

Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog

Re: Songs that are better than Pearl Jam's entire discog