Jorge wrote:epilogue wrote:Of all the awards shows they are the most "rigged."
Interesting, care to elaborate? (I don't know anything about how they work)
Sure! There's no objectivity. It's literally all about perception and money.
For example, when Wicked was up for best musical, it lost to Avenue Q. Not because critics/The League thought Avenue Q was "better" but because the common thinking was that Wicked would be able to run even without the award but that Avenue Q would close early without winning. This turned out to be exactly true. Wicked is still running and Avenue Q ended up getting more money/exposure with the win and ran another year when it was expected to close.
The same thing happened with Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder. I was working on Beautiful at the time and the Broadway League told us (literally told the producers of the show) that we were the critical favorite to win but that they also knew we would run even without winning but Gentleman's Guide was a fan favorite and would close if it didn't win. It won. And Beautiful ran for another 5 years. Gentleman's guide ran for a little longer but closed way before we did.
There have been a ton of shows/examples of people winning, not because they deserve it, but rather because they were promised a win to convince them to come to Broadway. It comes down to what's best for The League overall, not what is necessarily the best piece/performance/etc based on pure artistic merit.
That's not always the case, of course, but that's the default setting. Sometimes things surprise or overcome. Hamilton is a great example. Basically, Hamilton didn't let the Tony voters see the show for free (which is always the case). Hamilton said, nah, you can either come on very specific perfs to see the show for free or you can pay like everyone else. There was a big backlash about it. But in the end it didn't' matter. Hamilton was too big of force to fuck with. It won everything and most Tony Voters actually paid to see it. But Hamilton was a cultural phenomenon. There was no way the Tony committee was going to vote against it.