TV: Nathan For You

Books, movies, television...
User avatar
epilogue
We All We Got, We All We Need
Posts: 85741
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 5:33 pm
Location: Ghorman
Contact:

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by epilogue »

I'm still trying to wrap my head around how I feel about this movie. It depends on how real it actually is, I think. Leaving the theater I was pretty sure the whole thing was completely fake and therefore, the movie is stupid. I've been listening to some interviews with Lance and Nathan and also reading some reviews and essays about it, and I might be turning around to the idea that it is a real documentary. If that's the case? I love it.

Really wish I hadn't seen it in a packed theater, though. The audience reactions nearly killed it for me. But John Turturro was there. So, that was fun. I wonder if he liked it.
User avatar
VinylGuy
jeeeesus relax already
Posts: 44280
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 5:10 pm

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by VinylGuy »

did your wife liked it?
BONE FUCKIN´ TOMAHAWK.
User avatar
Norah
Poster of the Year
Posts: 37769
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:04 pm
Location: September 2020 Poster of the Month

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by Norah »

i think it's real, i just think liz and billy were putting on a show
User avatar
epilogue
We All We Got, We All We Need
Posts: 85741
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 5:33 pm
Location: Ghorman
Contact:

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by epilogue »

VinylGuy wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 4:45 pm did your wife liked it?
She did, yes. We talked about it for hours after and I think she liked it on its face more than I did. But we agree that it all depends on how much of it is real or not.
User avatar
epilogue
We All We Got, We All We Need
Posts: 85741
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 5:33 pm
Location: Ghorman
Contact:

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by epilogue »

Norah wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 5:14 pm i think it's real, i just think liz and billy were putting on a show
They are, but I never expected anything else from them. It's the Nathan of it all.

If it were revealed one day that the entire thing was fabricated, it wouldn't shock me. I'm trying not to be too cynical about it. I want it to be real... but it just has this vibe that I can't shake. I really don't trust Fielder. Which is weird, because this is literally the first thing I've ever seen that he's done.
User avatar
Mecca
slower than 82% of US
Posts: 8793
Joined: Wed December 19, 2012 7:17 pm

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by Mecca »

It’s both a real documentary and fake. That’s what my takeaway of the last lines and shot were
User avatar
The Argonaut
I've been POOSSTTIiiEEnngeeaahh
Posts: 12093
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 1:53 pm
Location: in the air tonight

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by The Argonaut »

I don't think Nathan Fielder has any interest in just straight up fabricating anything. I saw Tim Heidecker describe Fielder the other day as basically a magician and an illusionist, so I think it's certainly true that what you see is not always exactly reality (for example, I think it's pretty clear that there weren't passengers on the jet that he landed in Rehearsal Season 2).

But neither is it like Herzog's "ecstatic truth" which is supposedly truer than truth because it is not true.

Fielder definitely did not collude with Holmes or ever tell her or Billy what to say or do, nor did he stage any scenes or anything like that, including that final shot. I get why it feels like that, but that's because of how he set it up. Get the footage then tell the story gives you something different than having a story and going to get footage to help you tell it. If not for that tiny moment, he might not have mentioned that she mentioned turkey jerky at all. But because he did mention it, that moment takes on importance and looks staged. But it's not fake, I feel confident of that

It might be a manipulated truth, where certain things are ignored or emphasized, but that's everything. Definitely not fabricated, though
Please consider voting for me
User avatar
epilogue
We All We Got, We All We Need
Posts: 85741
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 5:33 pm
Location: Ghorman
Contact:

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by epilogue »

Mecca wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 7:48 pm It’s both a real documentary and fake. That’s what my takeaway of the last lines and shot were
It can't be both
User avatar
epilogue
We All We Got, We All We Need
Posts: 85741
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 5:33 pm
Location: Ghorman
Contact:

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by epilogue »

The Argonaut wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 8:43 pm I don't think Nathan Fielder has any interest in just straight up fabricating anything. I saw Tim Heidecker describe Fielder the other day as basically a magician and an illusionist, so I think it's certainly true that what you see is not always exactly reality (for example, I think it's pretty clear that there weren't passengers on the jet that he landed in Rehearsal Season 2).

But neither is it like Herzog's "ecstatic truth" which is supposedly truer than truth because it is not true.

Fielder definitely did not collude with Holmes or ever tell her or Billy what to say or do, nor did he stage any scenes or anything like that, including that final shot. I get why it feels like that, but that's because of how he set it up. Get the footage then tell the story gives you something different than having a story and going to get footage to help you tell it. If not for that tiny moment, he might not have mentioned that she mentioned turkey jerky at all. But because he did mention it, that moment takes on importance and looks staged. But it's not fake, I feel confident of that

It might be a manipulated truth, where certain things are ignored or emphasized, but that's everything. Definitely not fabricated, though
The final shot is literally the only thing in the movie that I know is real. And it never once crossed my mind that it was.
User avatar
Mecca
slower than 82% of US
Posts: 8793
Joined: Wed December 19, 2012 7:17 pm

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by Mecca »

epilogue wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 9:10 pm
Mecca wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 7:48 pm It’s both a real documentary and fake. That’s what my takeaway of the last lines and shot were
It can't be both
And yet it is. There’s an earnest documentary in it that ends the moment Amanda is brought in. The problem it exposes is that docs can be influenced by the filmmaker having preconceived notions, developing a connection to the subjects, or the subject having a financial interest in the final product. Nathan frolicked in the ocean with Elizabeth, which is intentionally revealed after Amanda asks if he was holding anything back that made her look bad because he cares about her. It almost seemed like Amanda knew more about Elizabeth from studying her to her play her. Nathan was an unreliable narrator, especially when it came to the re-enactments, which is the fake part of it
User avatar
BurtReynolds
An enigma of a man shaped hole in the wall between reality and the soul of the devil.
Posts: 46767
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 5:13 pm
Location: 6000 feet beyond man and time.

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by BurtReynolds »

I never bought for a second that Nathan actually gave a shit. It's a show.
RM's resident disinformation expert.
User avatar
epilogue
We All We Got, We All We Need
Posts: 85741
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 5:33 pm
Location: Ghorman
Contact:

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by epilogue »

BurtReynolds wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 10:09 pm I never bought for a second that Nathan actually gave a shit. It's a show.
Yeah... the whole "what did I just experience!" thing feels really fabricated to me.
User avatar
epilogue
We All We Got, We All We Need
Posts: 85741
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 5:33 pm
Location: Ghorman
Contact:

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by epilogue »

Mecca wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 9:55 pm
epilogue wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 9:10 pm
Mecca wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 7:48 pm It’s both a real documentary and fake. That’s what my takeaway of the last lines and shot were
It can't be both
And yet it is. There’s an earnest documentary in it that ends the moment Amanda is brought in. The problem it exposes is that docs can be influenced by the filmmaker having preconceived notions, developing a connection to the subjects, or the subject having a financial interest in the final product. Nathan frolicked in the ocean with Elizabeth, which is intentionally revealed after Amanda asks if he was holding anything back that made her look bad because he cares about her. It almost seemed like Amanda knew more about Elizabeth from studying her to her play her. Nathan was an unreliable narrator, especially when it came to the re-enactments, which is the fake part of it
I'm just not sure there's much that's earnest about the pre-Amanda stuff. At least, not in my read of the film.

But even if there is that doesn't negate the point. While all docs are "fabricated" to some degree because of POV and editing and all of that, there is still an element of authenticity or trying to accurately capture a subject or a moment in an honest or non-tricky way.

Nathan wanted to be a magician. This whole thing is (maybe) sleight of hand. And if that's the case, the movie bums me out.
User avatar
Mecca
slower than 82% of US
Posts: 8793
Joined: Wed December 19, 2012 7:17 pm

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by Mecca »

Coincidentally it was a meeting at the Magic Castle that led to Nathan getting attached to this project
User avatar
epilogue
We All We Got, We All We Need
Posts: 85741
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 5:33 pm
Location: Ghorman
Contact:

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by epilogue »

Mecca wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 10:36 pm Coincidentally it was a meeting at the Magic Castle that led to Nathan getting attached to this project
Sort of. He and Lance already knew each other and were looking for a project to do together. The Magic Castle thing ended up being a bit of a coincidence because Lance had heard recently that A24 was approached by Liz to do a doc but it had fallen through. Then the Magic Castle thing happened and it lead to Nathan then reaching out to A24 to see if it was true that Liz had approached about a doc.
User avatar
Mecca
slower than 82% of US
Posts: 8793
Joined: Wed December 19, 2012 7:17 pm

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by Mecca »

epilogue wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 10:44 pm
Mecca wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 10:36 pm Coincidentally it was a meeting at the Magic Castle that led to Nathan getting attached to this project
Sort of. He and Lance already knew each other and were looking for a project to do together. The Magic Castle thing ended up being a bit of a coincidence because Lance had heard recently that A24 was approached by Liz to do a doc but it had fallen through. Then the Magic Castle thing happened and it lead to Nathan then reaching out to A24 to see if it was true that Liz had approached about a doc.
Yeah, like I said, it led to him getting attached to the project
User avatar
epilogue
We All We Got, We All We Need
Posts: 85741
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 5:33 pm
Location: Ghorman
Contact:

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by epilogue »

Mecca wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 11:25 pm
epilogue wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 10:44 pm
Mecca wrote: Wed October 28, 2026 10:36 pm Coincidentally it was a meeting at the Magic Castle that led to Nathan getting attached to this project
Sort of. He and Lance already knew each other and were looking for a project to do together. The Magic Castle thing ended up being a bit of a coincidence because Lance had heard recently that A24 was approached by Liz to do a doc but it had fallen through. Then the Magic Castle thing happened and it lead to Nathan then reaching out to A24 to see if it was true that Liz had approached about a doc.
Yeah, like I said, it led to him getting attached to the project
Yeah, like I said, sort of.
User avatar
lennytheweedwhacker
The Master
Posts: 49372
Joined: Wed January 02, 2013 3:21 pm

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by lennytheweedwhacker »

I trust Nathan with every fiber of my being
And they say that a hero could save us
I'm not gonna stand here and wait
User avatar
Farmer John
Misplaced My Sponge
Posts: 6821
Joined: Wed January 02, 2013 9:25 pm

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by Farmer John »

I think Nathan was presented with the opportunity and went into it without any sort of ‘agenda’ other than to see what would happen.

That experience is presented to us in a way that raises the same questions that they were asking themselves as they were going through it. And I believe him when he says he still doesn’t know what to make of it all.
Nathan Fielder is still wondering why Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans invited the 'You Can See Everything' crew into their household:

"Why us? Why are we there? I mean, I like myself enough, but I would not want me there for my last month of freedom, if that makes sense. What was also weird about it is we felt like there was some game going on that even we couldn’t make sense of, but we were like, 'Well, let’s just go along with this and see what comes out, I guess.'"

On whether he has any more clarity now:

"Fuck no."
User avatar
Mecca
slower than 82% of US
Posts: 8793
Joined: Wed December 19, 2012 7:17 pm

Re: TV: Nathan For You

Post by Mecca »

lennytheweedwhacker wrote: Thu October 29, 2026 12:06 am I trust Nathan with every fiber of my being
Do you trust magicians?
Post Reply