There was a time for me when Smashing Pumpkins could do no wrong. This fits squarely into that era, and even to this day, it’s absolutely phenomenal for a b-sides collection. Starla is an all timer for them. Whir and Obscured examples of a band that don’t always need their heavy distortion of the era, and Frail & Bedazzled, Pissant, and A Girl Named Santos showing that when they do turn it all the way up, they are amazing. Really all the songs here for the most part are top notch - deserving of inclusion on the A side of albums, so getting their proper due here. I feel like this is the one under appreciated album of theirs that belongs high on their list.
Ello Sailor wrote: Thu November 12, 2026 1:43 am
"Sandoz" is cool, but it is a cover. I think "Kitty Kat" and "Blue" leave it in the dust regardless.
Otherwise completely agree with your highlights. Also, please consider checking out the Deluxe Edition extras. They're extremely high quality.
I almost never listen to the deluxe versions because I generally find them to be a grind even on albums I really love. I will at some point give it a go though. I also am not concerned over Sandoz being a cover. I feel like I lost any aversion to covers a long time ago here - but also it’s a b-sides album so there’s no rules with those.
Ello Sailor wrote: Thu November 12, 2026 1:43 am
"Sandoz" is cool, but it is a cover. I think "Kitty Kat" and "Blue" leave it in the dust regardless.
Otherwise completely agree with your highlights. Also, please consider checking out the Deluxe Edition extras. They're extremely high quality.
I almost never listen to the deluxe versions because I generally find them to be a grind even on albums I really love. I will at some point give it a go though. I also am not concerned over Sandoz being a cover. I feel like I lost any aversion to covers a long time ago here - but also it’s a b-sides album so there’s no rules with those.
I've thought before on your "rules" as far as this journey goes with respect to album versions. These days any balbum worth it's salt has at least 5 variations or deluxe versions, so surely you have to have some consistent rules, the most obvious being original releases only. But of course this must depend on what is easily available to you.
Once again the sheer magnitude of your endeavour here astounds me.
This band is a sort of abrasive punk and noise rock group that at times recalls Sonic Youth and at others maybe even closer to Nirvana in their catchiness. I liked this album well enough, and really liked the middle section of Hexenzsene, the instrumental Abstraktions, and All Souls Day. They are not the tightest group, though certainly that’s by design, but they do make up for it in creative structures and sound.
Ello Sailor wrote: Thu November 12, 2026 1:43 am
"Sandoz" is cool, but it is a cover. I think "Kitty Kat" and "Blue" leave it in the dust regardless.
Otherwise completely agree with your highlights. Also, please consider checking out the Deluxe Edition extras. They're extremely high quality.
I almost never listen to the deluxe versions because I generally find them to be a grind even on albums I really love. I will at some point give it a go though. I also am not concerned over Sandoz being a cover. I feel like I lost any aversion to covers a long time ago here - but also it’s a b-sides album so there’s no rules with those.
I've thought before on your "rules" as far as this journey goes with respect to album versions. These days any balbum worth it's salt has at least 5 variations or deluxe versions, so surely you have to have some consistent rules, the most obvious being original releases only. But of course this must depend on what is easily available to you.
Once again the sheer magnitude of your endeavour here astounds me.
#liebzzforRMeroftheyear(s)
I’ve focused almost exclusively on the original album for volume purposes. Like you said, nearly every album that’s more than 10 years old has a deluxe, super deluxe, remaster, etc, and it’s nearly impossible to go through all that. I also like the self-contained nature of the album as originally released as a marker on its original impact. I think the only album I did that for may have been Nebraska because the ‘82 version had just come out.
Scary enough, I started this thread on December 1, 2024, so we’re knocking on 2 years of this with no intentions of slowing down if I can help it.
This is another really good album from Suede. It has a combination classic rock and glam rock feel - it certainly reaches for the rafters in these giant song climaxes, as in This Hollywood Life, The Asphalt World, and The Power, and kicks into high octane rock on We Are the Pigs. There’s sometimes a bit too many quiet moments here, but there’s really not a bad song here. Like the weirdness of David Bowie channeling U2 or something.
This was an interesting combo of punk and hard rock that worked pretty well across the album. Earlier in the album I was prepared for a more abrasive punk rock withYes, Ifwhiteamerica…, and Of Walking Abortion, but the second half felt more alternative rock on songs like This Is Yesterday and Die in the Summertime. The Intense Humming of Evil takes it further into almost noise rock territory. They actually in hindsight had some pretty cool range. Also enjoyed Archives of Pain and 4st 7lb. Solid album all around.
This was an interesting combo of punk and hard rock that worked pretty well across the album. Earlier in the album I was prepared for a more abrasive punk rock withYes, Ifwhiteamerica…, and Of Walking Abortion, but the second half felt more alternative rock on songs like This Is Yesterday and Die in the Summertime. The Intense Humming of Evil takes it further into almost noise rock territory. They actually in hindsight had some pretty cool range. Also enjoyed Archives of Pain and 4st 7lb. Solid album all around.
The Essential Track: The Intense Humming of Evil
Up Next: Pulp - His n’ Hers
Such a great record, it's soo dark. Some brutal lyrics
I don’t know that it’s been typical of me with Pulp albums, but it took me a few songs here before I could really get into it. The first song that really flipped the switch for me was Babies, which I really enjoyed, and I was in a good spot from there through Do You Remember the First Time?, and then it fell off a little again. It’s one of those things where you recognize a band for being really good at what they do, but it just misses clicking. During some of the songs, Joy Division seemed to pop into my brain as a point of comparison, and that can’t be a bad thing. I guess I just fell in the middle here.
This is such a weird feeling listening to this band. First and foremost, they sound pretty good in utilizing their repetitive patrlterns to create some balance between an indie rock, alt-country mashup with a Beck-like eccentricity and a Kurt Vile-like laid back vibe. The songs were also pretty enjoyable, with the instrumental The Moon is the Number 18, Pan American Blues, New Orleans, and Rebel Jew leading the way. Somehow though, at the same time, it also sort of feels like this band needs to be punched in the face. I am not sure I can explain why. But it’s a good album.
I almost forgot about this one. I owned this album as a teenager, but ultimately I think my takeaway at the time was this is Zombie and a bunch of other songs. I mean, Empty, Ridiculous Thoughts, Yeat’s Grave, and Daffodil Lament are pretty good, but I am not so sure I was wrong - Zombie is undoubtedly the most memorable song here and it’s not really close. Really their first album holds up a lot better over the long haul, and this ain’t bad, but almost forgetting it is also just about on point as well.
I probably wouldn’t go so far as to call it a bait and switch, but this album and this band sounds almost nothing like their big single, Possum Kingdom. Where that song has a late 90s power pop/rock vibe, the rest of the album is much more similar to the post-grunge coming out at the time, with the songs feeling like they want to groove like Stone Temple Pilots but with the drive of a Pearl Jam. I mean, they are a reasonably decent band in the end, and their songs mostly pretty good - though like a band such as Bush, there seems to lack a reason to really listen hard.
This is one of those albums that never stuck with me. I have heard it a few times, but really while taking in a lot of Pink Floyd, and I don’t know that it was always fair to listen to this alongside those rather than as its own entity. It finally got that chance this morning, which I think elevates this album considerably. The first four tracks here are outstanding, as well as the last three, and Take It Back - meaning really 3/4th of this came off so much better than in the past. Great to finally have an album click, in large part because of all the albums I have taken in here.
This is another alternative rock band that I heard about in their day but didn’t really explore. I knew that some of them would be poached ultimately and join Foo Fighters for their second album and beyond, but that is really the extent of it. In fact, you could hear some of the Foo Fighters DNA in here on some of the playing. They are yet another band that is good on the surface but definitely a product of their times, making a decision on why they need to be heard a litle tough to answer. It could be a cacophony of a similar sound, or I just didn’t properly invest myself here - it’s good but for me doesn’t quite click beyond its basic enjoyment. It also brings us to the end of our core listening to 1994, which went on for a long time.
This feels heavy and light somehow at the same time. This alternative pseudo punk approach is on a theme of exactly what the title suggests: a trip down the mental rabbit hole of a severe crush, apparently for a rock or pop star that is not defined. The wheels feel like they are coming off, but in a way that adds to the theme. It can feel a little juvenile at moments but fits the subject well. It’s also a fascinating album sonically.
The Essential Track: In the Back of My Mind
Up Next: Presidents of the United States of America
This feels heavy and light somehow at the same time. This alternative pseudo punk approach is on a theme of exactly what the title suggests: a trip down the mental rabbit hole of a severe crush, apparently for a rock or pop star that is not defined. The wheels feel like they are coming off, but in a way that adds to the theme. It can feel a little juvenile at moments but fits the subject well. It’s also a fascinating album sonically.
The Essential Track: In the Back of My Mind
Up Next: Presidents of the United States of America
Not sure who suggested this deeper cut, but good work
This feels heavy and light somehow at the same time. This alternative pseudo punk approach is on a theme of exactly what the title suggests: a trip down the mental rabbit hole of a severe crush, apparently for a rock or pop star that is not defined. The wheels feel like they are coming off, but in a way that adds to the theme. It can feel a little juvenile at moments but fits the subject well. It’s also a fascinating album sonically.
The Essential Track: In the Back of My Mind
Up Next: Presidents of the United States of America
Not sure who suggested this deeper cut, but good work
I don’t recall but this could be one of the releases I found on some list somewhere and threw it on.
Back in the 90s, this was a fun band, largely remembered for Lump and Peaches. Both are on this album, which is even more irreverent than the singles even capture. We Are Not Going to Make It is legitimately hilarious, Dune Buggy is fun, Naked and Famous ridiculous. Kitty, Boll Weevil, and the cover of Kick Out the Jams also highlights. Despite never quite getting this album as a teenager, I enjoyed this listen.