Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

[chinofstone]

This song is awesome. Favorite since Binaural. Maybe Force of Nature right with it.

[HardTI]

Just admit it, this song is lame as hell.

Yeah, this one's no good.

i'm really disappointed in both of you.

But the thing is they're both right. This song goes nowhere and does nothing. It's like Artex in the swamp of sadness. It's just sinking and dying and doesn't give a shit. Fuck this song.

[BurtReynolds]

I like the idea of this song, but you're right, it goes nowhere (because they were too busy bloating up Sirens probably).

[Birds in Hell]

I have no beef with music that "goes nowhere"; most of my favourite music meanders in one mood in interesting ways.

Regardless of whether this song is going anywhere or not, I find the journey insufferably dull.

This song sucks.

[Norah]

Guys, spenno is right.

[BurtReynolds]

shut up chud!

[HardTI]

I have no beef with music that "goes nowhere"; most of my favourite music meanders in one mood in interesting ways.

Regardless of whether this song is going anywhere or not, I find the journey insufferably dull.

This song sucks.

That's basically what I meant by "does nothing". I just meant it does nothing interesting. Dull sums it up, yet I still keep on trying to like it. I wonder if it will ever happen.

[BurtReynolds]

I have no beef with music that "goes nowhere"; most of my favourite music meanders in one mood in interesting ways.

Regardless of whether this song is going anywhere or not, I find the journey insufferably dull.

This song sucks.

I'm fine with that, too. This song begs to be a song like Long Road, but they seem to be against songs like that on principal, now.

This song sounds both unfinished and cut down. Like someone (ED) didn't want to do anything with it. I think the bones are there, but it needs less structure and more room to explore.

edit: Also, Brendan O'brien is like cancer, if I haven't mentioned that this month.

[Norah]

Eddie tries too hard with his voice to pull of the somber meandering beauty of a song like Long Road these days.

[Dr. Van Nostrand]

This song is awesome. Favorite since Binaural. Maybe Force of Nature right with it.

Always nice to see love for force of nature

[Birds in Hell]

This song is awesome. Favorite since Binaural. Maybe Force of Nature right with it.

Always nice to see love for force of nature

I think that one's absolutely awful too.

[BurtReynolds]

This song is awesome. Favorite since Binaural. Maybe Force of Nature right with it.

Always nice to see love for force of nature

I think that one's absolutely awful too.

absolutely

[Dr. Van Nostrand]

This song is awesome. Favorite since Binaural. Maybe Force of Nature right with it.

Always nice to see love for force of nature

I think that one's absolutely awful too.

absolutely

Of course you guys do, which is why i like to see people who have love for it

[Norah]

This song is awesome. Favorite since Binaural. Maybe Force of Nature right with it.

Always nice to see love for force of nature

I think that one's absolutely awful too.

Me too. The weird thing is, Doc's top three Pearl Jam albums are Yield, No Code, and Binaural. Yet...

[Norah]

To be fair, I really enjoyed Force of Nature when Backspacer first came out. But in hindsight I think I was trying way too hard to find things about that album that I liked.

[Dr. Van Nostrand]

This song is awesome. Favorite since Binaural. Maybe Force of Nature right with it.

Always nice to see love for force of nature

I think that one's absolutely awful too.

Me too. The weird thing is, Doc's top three Pearl Jam albums are Yield, No Code, and Binaural. Yet...

Well, and force of nature isn't in my top 20 or anything, but i love the song

[Birds in Hell]

To be fair, I really enjoyed Force of Nature when Backspacer first came out. But in hindsight I think I was trying way too hard to find things about that album that I liked.

I think we were all doing that to some extent.

It made sense to do so at the time. While S/T was hardly universally adored among the more discerning fans, it had its strong points and it decidedly still felt somewhat like a Pearl Jam record (and the shows from that time were some of the band's tightest).

I'm sure I listened to Backspacer a lot more when it was released than I have Lightning Bolt so far, largely because my expectations of a new Pearl Jam record have been permanently adjusted now - I can't give the band the same benefit of the doubt.

That isn't to say I don't like the new material. I think Lightning Bolt is, on the whole, a better album than Backspacer but I'm just not willing to spend the time trying to uncover hidden depths in songs that I'm already certain aren't any good.

[Norah]

To be fair, I really enjoyed Force of Nature when Backspacer first came out. But in hindsight I think I was trying way too hard to find things about that album that I liked.

I think we were all doing that to some extent.

It made sense to do so at the time. While S/T was hardly universally adored among the more discerning fans, it had its strong points and it decidedly still felt somewhat like a Pearl Jam record (and the shows from that time were some of the band's tightest).

I'm sure I listened to Backspacer a lot more when it was released than I have Lightning Bolt so far, largely because my expectations of a new Pearl Jam record have been permanently adjusted now - I can't give the band the same benefit of the doubt.

That isn't to say I don't like the new material. I think Lightning Bolt is, on the whole, a better album than Backspacer but I'm just not willing to spend the time trying to uncover hidden depths in songs that I'm already certain aren't any good.

I agree with everything you just said.

Spoiler: show

Fuck you, Burt.

[stip]

you know what's a great song. Force of Nature.

[Dr. Van Nostrand]

you know what's a great song. Force of Nature.