Post Your One Disc White Album

[Lament]

1. "Helter Skelter"

that was easy.

Be careful not to cut yourself with all that edge

Trolling Beatles threads is strictly for the hardcore.

We can't all take truly brave and daring stances like Jorge's "I don't like Bono" stance.

[Wendy Carlos's Twin]

I take your point but, unlike Not Guilty, they didn't go to the trouble of recording those in the studio for the album:

Bullshit fraud!

This is the REAL "Not Guilty"...

[EJ]

Tried this, gave up.

Rules be damned, I feel like Not Guilty absolutely has to be on there.

Rev 9 too.

Might as well add Sour Milk Sea and Junk then.

Post Your Three Disc White Album!

Junk could've really been something. Really like that one.

[Kevin Davis]

"Junk" is a wonderful song.

I think one of the reasons I recoil at the old "single disc White Album" discussion is because the people doing the cutting inevitably go straight for the pop trifles, and I prefer the grotesque fusion of extremes as it exists to the more streamlined, comparatively static version of the record that keeps all of Lennon's snark and seriousness and axes all of McCartney's bounce and harmony. As single disc versions go, I like Joey's idea--just assume the single disc is an 80 minute CDR, cut "Revolution 9" and a couple other non-personal favorites, and keep most of the rest. But I will confess that it pains me a little inside that no one so far has kept "Martha My Dear."

[mastaflatch]

i love Martha My Dear! my sister plays it on the piano.

[Norah]

I love that song so much.