A Song Of Ice and Fire (Spoilers for all Published Books)

[Mecca]

Biggest Rogue?

Red Viper
Bronn
Bloodraven
Craster
Bittersteel
The Night's King
The Hound

who could it be?!

[epilogue]

And now they're talking about a movie. Really, George? You couldn't take the hint when everyone on the show said seven MAYBE eight seasons? Just fucking write, bro.

[Mecca]

And now they're talking about a movie. Really, George? You couldn't take the hint when everyone on the show said seven MAYBE eight seasons? Just fucking write, bro.

the movie idea was expanded on a little with the possibility of it being a Dunk and Egg movie

[epilogue]

And now they're talking about a movie. Really, George? You couldn't take the hint when everyone on the show said seven MAYBE eight seasons? Just fucking write, bro.

the movie idea was expanded on a little with the possibility of it being a Dunk and Egg movie

A Dunk and Egg movie could be super cool. But a wrap up the series with a movie movie is a terrible idea.

[bada]

Every successful show broaches the idea of finishing it up with a movie. Doesn't happen.

[Mecca]

Every successful show broaches the idea of finishing it up with a movie. Doesn't happen.

[bada]

Yeah I guess Sex and the City too huh? X-Files. Serenity. Oh well.

[Mecca]

Yeah I guess Sex and the City too huh? X-Files. Serenity. Oh well.

we all make mistakes, bada. the important thing is that we learn from them

[psychobain]

i love the first x-files movie

[epilogue]

i love the first x-files movie

Me too. But that one wasn't a "finish the series with a movie" movie, either.

[epilogue]

Yeah I guess Sex and the City too huh? X-Files. Serenity. Oh well.

HBO has a definite track record with this kind of thing.

[15showsandcounting]

Who is Coldhands? Gonna be part of Season 4? Did I miss him in Season 3? Is he/it Benjen?

[Simple Torture]

Most Coldhands theories I read point to some passages where he describes himself/is described as very old, ancient almost, so probably not Benjen. But definitely some brother mentioned in the hostories of the Watch.

[Mecca]

Who is Coldhands? Gonna be part of Season 4? Did I miss him in Season 3? Is he/it Benjen?

He's likely not in season 4 and the skip right to the Children of the Forest leading Bran to Brynden

[Mecca]

Most Coldhands theories I read point to some passages where he describes himself/is described as very old, ancient almost, so probably not Benjen. But definitely some brother mentioned in the hostories of the Watch.

the theory that I lean towards is the Night King.

[psychobain]

I dont remember oberyn enjoying boys on the book

[Mecca]

I dont remember oberyn enjoying boys on the book

I think he's just being portrayed as super sexual

[15showsandcounting]

I felt like Oberlyn came and went pretty quickly in the book (FfC?), so it feels like a lot of people are overly excited about his presence.

Doesn't he have a bunch of daughters that are going to raise hell? Should we expect them in Season 5 of GoT?

[epilogue]

Oberyn dies pretty quickly from what I recall. But not before he does some serious damage. Pretty sure it's in the third book, too. But I might be wrong about that.

[EJ]

Yep, he had a brief, but highly impactful role in A Storm of Swords. A very intriguing character.