Match GE: Nothing As It Seems vs. Not For You

[knee tunes]

I have never took a pee break during "not for you" tho,
wait, or do you guys call it piss break.

I have never tinkled during NFY

[stip]

G dangit, listen to this version and know for certain you would be making the right decision:

http://www.pearljambootlegs.org/modules ... 3D&ext.m3u


The vocals. Mikes wailing guitar. Cameron just pounding it home. The best.

that's a nice version, full of moments that are almost as good as Not For You. But there's nothing in NAIS as good as the start of NFY. The slowly burning fuse, the languid anger, it's just soooooo good. Listen to remind yourself. You've been living with this song for 20 years. It's easy to forget

[Norah]

But there's nothing in NAIS as good as the start of NFY

Um...

[stip]

As I said, it's almost as good. that is a great great solo nonetheless. It's too bad it's surrounded by 4 minutes of pretty good.

[stip]

I'd be so much better at internetting if I'd learn how to use MS paint and stuff that lets me just post a few second of something

[Norah]

Yeah well ya don't.

[Strat]

This thread is pissing me off.

[stip]

Yeah well ya don't.

I'd do something about it but I hate learning new things by myself.

[LetMeSleep]

NAIS has an awesome snare sound. Not For You has a pretty good snare sound.

[Jorge]

Not For You is Not That Good.

[stip]

it's not one of their very best, but neither is NAIS. They're both at the bottom of the top tier.

[LetMeSleep]

NAIS is top 5.

[Heathen]

Not For You is the most overrated song in the entire catalog

[delanoche]

Current Not For You live is silly.

Not For You in the context of Vitalogy or live versions from '94-'95 (and on occasion through 2000) is a bottle of emotion that gets smashed against the wall. That's the version that gets my vote.

[@SkitchP]

GOD DAMN IT.

[WtOB?]

Not For You is Not That Good.

phony, self-involved eddie at his self-involved phoniest.