Finals: Corduroy vs. Insignificance

[giveway]

Corduroy is undeniably one of the band's absolute best songs. They play it at nearly every show, it's on the greatest hits album, etc. It's already won March Madness, too. RM has fully acknowledged its greatness.

Insignificance is also fantastic and from one of PJ's finest but also most underrated albums. It has not won here previously. I cast my vote for Insignificance because of my love for that song and more generally for Binaural. Both the song and album are vastly underrated, by the band and by the mainstream fans. This is a chance to put the spotlight on the greatness that is Binaural. In the best possible scenario, the band may begin to rethink their near-total shunning of this spectacular album. Team Binaural.

Yes

YES

[Heathen]

oh man stip is gonna be so pissed off

[stip]

Team Pineapple... Corduroy is definitely the better song, but Insignificance has never won.

i trust I can rely on your support for my The Fixer campaign next year. i'm not sure its ever even won a match. It will be the king of underdogs!

[stupidmop]

It's instillllllleeedddd to wanna kick corduroy's ass

[dimejinky99]

Insignificance is winning? Seriously?

Bloody hipsters

[Thejambi]

Corduroy is all time.

[ABNorman]

I voted for Corduroy, because I'm not insane, but I fully support there being a different winner this year, even if that winner is not in my top 20.

[stip]

everyone gets a trophy

[B]

I really don't care for Binaural, and Vitalogy is often my favorite album. So my vote pained me, but I think Insignificance has a slight edge over Corduroy.

[Got Some]

Both Ed songs

[darth_vedder]

So glad Insignificance topped Immortality.

This is a strong final representing the Pearl Jam of the past at their best, vs. the "newer" MC era PJ at their best.

I'm going with Insignificance all the way. Corduroy has had it's day. Everyone knows it's a great song, it's now Insignificance's turn to be king.

[Jorge]

I really don't see why someone would vote for a song if they don't think it's the best in a matchup. Doesn't that defeat the purpose of this whole thing? So what if the same song wins every year?

I do prefer "Insignificance", but both songs are worthy finalists

[McParadigm]

I really don't see why someone would vote for a song if they don't think it's the best in a matchup. Doesn't that defeat the purpose of this whole thing?

The integrity of our entire song tournament is at stake, here, people

[Jorge]

McParadigm would like you to know etc.

[B]

I really don't see why someone would vote for a song if they don't think it's the best in a matchup. Doesn't that defeat the purpose of this whole thing? So what if the same song wins every year?

I do prefer "Insignificance", but both songs are worthy finalists

I might understand that if it was Corduroy every year for 4 years, but it's one of several former champions, and Black has already set a precedent of winning twice.

Vote your heart, folks!

[McParadigm]

McParadigm would like you to know

Listen to the mustn'ts, child. Listen to the don'ts. Listen to the shouldn'ts, the impossibles, the won'ts. Listen to the never haves....then, listen close to me. Anything can happen, child. Anything can be.

[CopperTom]

Corduroy

[Iholdthepain]

I really don't see why someone would vote for a song if they don't think it's the best in a matchup. Doesn't that defeat the purpose of this whole thing? So what if the same song wins every year?

I do prefer "Insignificance", but both songs are worthy finalists

Me, either.

[ABNorman]

I really don't see why someone would vote for a song if they don't think it's the best in a matchup. Doesn't that defeat the purpose of this whole thing? So what if the same song wins every year?

I do prefer "Insignificance", but both songs are worthy finalists

I was just saying I'm fine with Insignificance winning because it's something different - it's just nice to see a bit of variety at the top. I voted for Corduroy, which I think is easily the better song.

If Corduroy was up against one of those songs that everybody overrates (I Got Shit), I'd be far less cool about it losing.

[epilogue]

Insignificance.