A Song Of Ice and Fire (Spoilers for all Published Books)

[Mecca]

why change a memorable line like "Only Cat." to "your sister"?

[psychobain]

didnt bothered me

[Mecca]

didnt bothered me

im not outraged by it or anything, but why change the line? it isn't a better line by any means. Why deviate?

[fitzy]

why change a memorable line like "Only Cat." to "your sister"?

to piss off the smarks.

[Mecca]

Lysa killed Jon Arryn with Tears of Lys. Littlefinger kills her, which leads to tears of Lysa. Sorry, I'll see myself out.

[psychobain]

that fight was a beauty

very faithful to the book

[Simple Torture]

I guess with Arya already being in the Vale, it's going to be pretty easy for her to jump on a ship and head to Bravos. But there's going to have to be a big swerve for her not to run into Sansa (if they avoid running into each other).

[Mecca]

my reaction to that ending:

Spoiler: show

[Simple Torture]

Do you all feel that people in the show thread can get a bit too touchy sometimes? I don't think "I bet the Lord of Light plays an important role down the line" is something to get bent out of shape about; it's not like I said, "Big moment for Jon and Ygrette coming up!" or something like that. What I said doesn't preclude the fact that big things have happened since this moment in the story. Ah, well, I guess I'll stay out of that thread for now.

[Mecca]

they just suffered quite the gut punch, so they can be a bit touchy

[epilogue]

Arya is my favorite. That scene.... MAN! I can't wait for next season. I'm more excited to see her in Bravos (and where the show takes Sansa, because it already feels different) than I am about the final episodes of this season.

[epilogue]

Do you all feel that people in the show thread can get a bit too touchy sometimes? I don't think "I bet the Lord of Light plays an important role down the line" is something to get bent out of shape about; it's not like I said, "Big moment for Jon and Ygrette coming up!" or something like that. What I said doesn't preclude the fact that big things have happened since this moment in the story. Ah, well, I guess I'll stay out of that thread for now.

I felt the same way. Brush it off. Or just lie and tell people you stopped reading after book three.

[Monkey_Driven]

Looks like this week's episode will be entirely composed of the Battle on the Wall.

Does this mean the final scene of the finale will be Tywin/Tyrion?

[lowlight79]

Looks like this week's episode will be entirely composed of the Battle on the Wall.

Does this mean the final scene of the finale will be Tywin/Tyrion?

Either that or LSH or maybe trion meeting young griff?

[McParadigm]

Do you all feel that people in the show thread can get a bit too touchy sometimes?

Don't denigrate. It took those people a lot of time and effort to not read those books.

[kreng]

Looks like this week's episode will be entirely composed of the Battle on the Wall.

Does this mean the final scene of the finale will be Tywin/Tyrion?

Either that or LSH or maybe trion meeting young griff?

maybe the former, the latter would be WAY too soon.

[Fuzzy_Dunlop]

Does this mean the final scene of the finale will be Tywin/Tyrion?

I think they have to get to Tywin/Tyrion, I feel like they've already dragged out the end of book 3 long enough. It's only like a quarter of the book from the Red Wedding until Tyrion escapes, right? Maybe it only felt that way bc I couldn't stop reading the book at that point.

[Monkey_Driven]

Does this mean the final scene of the finale will be Tywin/Tyrion?

I think they have to get to Tywin/Tyrion, I feel like they've already dragged out the end of book 3 long enough. It's only like a quarter of the book from the Red Wedding until Tyrion escapes, right? Maybe it only felt that way bc I couldn't stop reading the book at that point.

The encounter has to happen in the finale. They've done a great job building to it all season.

[epilogue]

I'm hoping it will end with Tyrion/Tywin, then LSH.

[Monkey_Driven]

I'm hoping it will end with Tyrion/Tywin, then LSH.

Ooo. Isn't the actress who plays Cat busy with another show now?