Yeah I only started listening 2-3 days ago, listened to the first 9, and jumped on today's episode the minute it was uploaded. Next week's sounds fascinating, although I'm skeptical...
...of the theory that Adnan is a psychopath. It's an extremely rare condition (from what I understand), and next week is going to tread into some dangerous waters (i.e., diagnosing from a distance). But, of course, I'll listen.
Simple Torture wrote:Yeah I only started listening 2-3 days ago, listened to the first 9, and jumped on today's episode the minute it was uploaded. Next week's sounds fascinating, although I'm skeptical...
...of the theory that Adnan is a psychopath. It's an extremely rare condition (from what I understand), and next week is going to tread into some dangerous waters (i.e., diagnosing from a distance). But, of course, I'll listen.
Yeah, that is a touchy subject, but I guess she has to explore that angle. There just isn't a whole lot more to discuss in the actual case. I read your theory, and I'm in agreement with you. The first 5 eps did a great job of casting doubt on the state's case (which seems like it'd be enough to rule not guilty).
But, the more I've thought about it and listening to Adnan's reactions to Jay himself really changed my opinion of the case. He should have absolute hatred for this guy. He doesn't.
I think Jay knew ahead of time and may have even been present when it happened. And, like you said, since he was an accomplice, he has a better shot of just implicating Adnan immediately knowing Adnan wouldn't reveal anything.
My knee jerk reaction is that since it seems like he'd been in many relationships, yeah, what's one more notch on his bedpost? The jilted lover angle seems slim--and, I would assume, it's almost impossible to prove it "beyond a reasonable doubt" in court. But then again, drawing from personal experience--there are some people who do react strangely to new relationships at new times in their lives, and transition years--like the last year and a half of high school--make people do strange things that are out of character. So while I don't find the state's explanation of motive provable, I do find it plausible.
Simple Torture wrote:Yeah I only started listening 2-3 days ago, listened to the first 9, and jumped on today's episode the minute it was uploaded. Next week's sounds fascinating, although I'm skeptical...
...of the theory that Adnan is a psychopath. It's an extremely rare condition (from what I understand), and next week is going to tread into some dangerous waters (i.e., diagnosing from a distance). But, of course, I'll listen.
Yeah, that is a touchy subject, but I guess she has to explore that angle. There just isn't a whole lot more to discuss in the actual case. I read your theory, and I'm in agreement with you. The first 5 eps did a great job of casting doubt on the state's case (which seems like it'd be enough to rule not guilty).
But, the more I've thought about it and listening to Adnan's reactions to Jay himself really changed my opinion of the case. He should have absolute hatred for this guy. He doesn't.
I think Jay knew ahead of time and may have even been present when it happened. And, like you said, since he was an accomplice, he has a better shot of just implicating Adnan immediately knowing Adnan wouldn't reveal anything.
...that is, Adnan's feelings towards Jay, is that I kinda buy his non-hatred, his calm, and so on as a result of a return to religion. That's a super-common theme among people committed of a crime. But just from what I've seen, usually this comes along with an admission of guilt, a way to sort of reform their image in the eyes of everyone else. That is: "I may have done some bad things...but look, I'm saved! I've come back to Jesus/Allah!" Adnan's case is strange because he's presenting himself as coming back to Islam after this whole ordeal, but there's no admission of guilt. Buuuuut there was that phone call to Sarah where he said, "I've made mistakes," and after Sarah presses him, he's silent for a while and then comes back with something about the people he associated himself with, letting someone borrow his car, etc. I feel like Sarah may jump on that in the next episode. Is that his worst slip-up, or maybe his only slip-up?
Simple Torture wrote:Yeah I only started listening 2-3 days ago, listened to the first 9, and jumped on today's episode the minute it was uploaded. Next week's sounds fascinating, although I'm skeptical...
...of the theory that Adnan is a psychopath. It's an extremely rare condition (from what I understand), and next week is going to tread into some dangerous waters (i.e., diagnosing from a distance). But, of course, I'll listen.
Yeah, that is a touchy subject, but I guess she has to explore that angle. There just isn't a whole lot more to discuss in the actual case. I read your theory, and I'm in agreement with you. The first 5 eps did a great job of casting doubt on the state's case (which seems like it'd be enough to rule not guilty).
But, the more I've thought about it and listening to Adnan's reactions to Jay himself really changed my opinion of the case. He should have absolute hatred for this guy. He doesn't.
I think Jay knew ahead of time and may have even been present when it happened. And, like you said, since he was an accomplice, he has a better shot of just implicating Adnan immediately knowing Adnan wouldn't reveal anything.
...that is, Adnan's feelings towards Jay, is that I kinda buy his non-hatred, his calm, and so on as a result of a return to religion. That's a super-common theme among people committed of a crime. But just from what I've seen, usually this comes along with an admission of guilt, a way to sort of reform their image in the eyes of everyone else. That is: "I may have done some bad things...but look, I'm saved! I've come back to Jesus/Allah!" Adnan's case is strange because he's presenting himself as coming back to Islam after this whole ordeal, but there's no admission of guilt. Buuuuut there was that phone call to Sarah where he said, "I've made mistakes," and after Sarah presses him, he's silent for a while and then comes back with something about the people he associated himself with, letting someone borrow his car, etc. I feel like Sarah may jump on that in the next episode. Is that his worst slip-up, or maybe his only slip-up?
Simple Torture wrote:Yeah I only started listening 2-3 days ago, listened to the first 9, and jumped on today's episode the minute it was uploaded. Next week's sounds fascinating, although I'm skeptical...
...of the theory that Adnan is a psychopath. It's an extremely rare condition (from what I understand), and next week is going to tread into some dangerous waters (i.e., diagnosing from a distance). But, of course, I'll listen.
Yeah, that is a touchy subject, but I guess she has to explore that angle. There just isn't a whole lot more to discuss in the actual case. I read your theory, and I'm in agreement with you. The first 5 eps did a great job of casting doubt on the state's case (which seems like it'd be enough to rule not guilty).
But, the more I've thought about it and listening to Adnan's reactions to Jay himself really changed my opinion of the case. He should have absolute hatred for this guy. He doesn't.
I think Jay knew ahead of time and may have even been present when it happened. And, like you said, since he was an accomplice, he has a better shot of just implicating Adnan immediately knowing Adnan wouldn't reveal anything.
...that is, Adnan's feelings towards Jay, is that I kinda buy his non-hatred, his calm, and so on as a result of a return to religion. That's a super-common theme among people committed of a crime. But just from what I've seen, usually this comes along with an admission of guilt, a way to sort of reform their image in the eyes of everyone else. That is: "I may have done some bad things...but look, I'm saved! I've come back to Jesus/Allah!" Adnan's case is strange because he's presenting himself as coming back to Islam after this whole ordeal, but there's no admission of guilt. Buuuuut there was that phone call to Sarah where he said, "I've made mistakes," and after Sarah presses him, he's silent for a while and then comes back with something about the people he associated himself with, letting someone borrow his car, etc. I feel like Sarah may jump on that in the next episode. Is that his worst slip-up, or maybe his only slip-up?
Simple Torture wrote:Yeah I only started listening 2-3 days ago, listened to the first 9, and jumped on today's episode the minute it was uploaded. Next week's sounds fascinating, although I'm skeptical...
...of the theory that Adnan is a psychopath. It's an extremely rare condition (from what I understand), and next week is going to tread into some dangerous waters (i.e., diagnosing from a distance). But, of course, I'll listen.
Yeah, that is a touchy subject, but I guess she has to explore that angle. There just isn't a whole lot more to discuss in the actual case. I read your theory, and I'm in agreement with you. The first 5 eps did a great job of casting doubt on the state's case (which seems like it'd be enough to rule not guilty).
But, the more I've thought about it and listening to Adnan's reactions to Jay himself really changed my opinion of the case. He should have absolute hatred for this guy. He doesn't.
I think Jay knew ahead of time and may have even been present when it happened. And, like you said, since he was an accomplice, he has a better shot of just implicating Adnan immediately knowing Adnan wouldn't reveal anything.
...that is, Adnan's feelings towards Jay, is that I kinda buy his non-hatred, his calm, and so on as a result of a return to religion. That's a super-common theme among people committed of a crime. But just from what I've seen, usually this comes along with an admission of guilt, a way to sort of reform their image in the eyes of everyone else. That is: "I may have done some bad things...but look, I'm saved! I've come back to Jesus/Allah!" Adnan's case is strange because he's presenting himself as coming back to Islam after this whole ordeal, but there's no admission of guilt. Buuuuut there was that phone call to Sarah where he said, "I've made mistakes," and after Sarah presses him, he's silent for a while and then comes back with something about the people he associated himself with, letting someone borrow his car, etc. I feel like Sarah may jump on that in the next episode. Is that his worst slip-up, or maybe his only slip-up?
Kumail Nanjiani's "The X-Files Files" seems promising; I've listened to the first two episodes. I just hope that after a few more, they quit talking about how awesome the show is for 30 minutes before getting to the actual episodes.
Simple Torture wrote:Yeah I only started listening 2-3 days ago, listened to the first 9, and jumped on today's episode the minute it was uploaded. Next week's sounds fascinating, although I'm skeptical...
...of the theory that Adnan is a psychopath. It's an extremely rare condition (from what I understand), and next week is going to tread into some dangerous waters (i.e., diagnosing from a distance). But, of course, I'll listen.
Yeah, that is a touchy subject, but I guess she has to explore that angle. There just isn't a whole lot more to discuss in the actual case. I read your theory, and I'm in agreement with you. The first 5 eps did a great job of casting doubt on the state's case (which seems like it'd be enough to rule not guilty).
But, the more I've thought about it and listening to Adnan's reactions to Jay himself really changed my opinion of the case. He should have absolute hatred for this guy. He doesn't.
I think Jay knew ahead of time and may have even been present when it happened. And, like you said, since he was an accomplice, he has a better shot of just implicating Adnan immediately knowing Adnan wouldn't reveal anything.
...that is, Adnan's feelings towards Jay, is that I kinda buy his non-hatred, his calm, and so on as a result of a return to religion. That's a super-common theme among people committed of a crime. But just from what I've seen, usually this comes along with an admission of guilt, a way to sort of reform their image in the eyes of everyone else. That is: "I may have done some bad things...but look, I'm saved! I've come back to Jesus/Allah!" Adnan's case is strange because he's presenting himself as coming back to Islam after this whole ordeal, but there's no admission of guilt. Buuuuut there was that phone call to Sarah where he said, "I've made mistakes," and after Sarah presses him, he's silent for a while and then comes back with something about the people he associated himself with, letting someone borrow his car, etc. I feel like Sarah may jump on that in the next episode. Is that his worst slip-up, or maybe his only slip-up?
