March Madness 2015: Do the Evolution wins!

[Fuck You Jobu]

I'm a bit surprised that DTE was able to take it all the way, but I'm totally satisfied with the result. Party on RM.

I am too. It's not a song I would ever consider to be pearl jam's best. But it's a great song nonetheless

I wouldn't even call it the best song on Yield.

Right now, if just for this moment, it is.

Amongst this small PJ community, right now, for this moment, yes

[stip]

I'm a bit surprised that DTE was able to take it all the way, but I'm totally satisfied with the result. Party on RM.

I am too. It's not a song I would ever consider to be pearl jam's best. But it's a great song nonetheless

I wouldn't even call it the best song on Yield.

I would

[BurtReynolds]

A laughable result. I am ashamed of you, rm.

[tommymtcom]

I'd like to point out that Last Exit is the real winner here. Stip said it was sudden death and Jessica Fletcher cast the next vote for Last Exit.

[LetMeSleep]

It's stupid that a 2 month tourney which was down to one vote gets to sudden death. Leave it open till there's a 5% swing.

Ah ignore me, I'm still bitter about NAIS.

[stip]

There wasn't sudden death. All I said was that if it was tied at 9am (when I've been closing the rounds) we would extend voting for three hours RATHER than go to sudden death.

[tommymtcom]

You're right, I didn't read the posts preceding your post explaining sudden death.

Well, either way you got this one wrong RM.

Fuck all of you.

You can all go eat a big bowl of shit.

[LetMeSleep]

Okay. Fair enough.

It seems I'm not as bitter as Mr Tom.

[stip]

I'm just relieved it wasn't faithfull

[epilogue]

I'm just relieved it wasn't faithfull

Rank the songs you're thankful didn't win.

[stip]

1. Faithfull
2. In the Moonlight
3. No Way
4. Off He goes
5. All or None

[epilogue]

So glad to see In My Tree miss your top 5.

[E.H. Ruddock]

I'm just relieved it wasn't faithfull

Rank the songs you're thankful didn't win.

1. In My Tree
2. Faithfull
3. Insignificance

[Sgt. Crackpot]

Welcome to "compromise", my friends.

[BurtReynolds]

Welcome to "compromise", my friends.

I think next year we need a round robin tournament. Each song against every other song. It's the only way to be sure.

We may also need to introduce a rating system to insure "really loving" a song counts more than merely "liking" it.

[stip]

So glad to see In My Tree miss your top 5.

it doesn't deserve it, but it is a very good song. Overrated, but still worth something.

[Sgt. Crackpot]

Welcome to "compromise", my friends.

I think next year we need a round robin tournament. Each song against every other song. It's the only way to be sure.

We may also need to introduce a rating system to insure "really loving" a song counts more than merely "liking" it.

Yes. A scoring system on a scale of 1 to 100 would suffice. We'll require scores to be applied to the third decimal point, i.e. 97.251

This could take a while, if we want to finish in March 2016 we better start now.

Stip, your thoughts?

[stip]

Is chud against? If so, I'm all for it!

[PryTo]

I wouldn't be remotely surprised if DTE won the fake March Madness over at the official. Oh well, at least it wasn't Alive. This year.

[darth_vedder]

Shit, I forgot to vote. I was still leaning towards Last Exit. Sorry team.

http://forums.theskyiscrape.com/viewtop ... 04#p507604

Will you ever forgive me?