The greatest RB of all time is...

[Iholdthepain]

Ok, ok... I'll concede that Sweetness was better than Emmitt, but the BS argument is just that... some old bullshit!

[Lament]

Samkon Gado is the right answer.

[Kaius]

I was just wondering where all the packer fans were...

[BurtReynolds]

Geaux Saints!

[Lament]

I was just wondering where all the packer fans were...

We're having a private meeting where we rank the franchise's 13 World Championship teams.

[darth_vedder]

No love for Riggo?

[nyquillyn]

I loved Riggins. He just shouldn't be in this conversation.

24 rushing TDs in 1983.

[BigRedLedbetter]

The top fives that have been posted are hard to argue with. I'll say Jamaal Charles actually has a chance to be top 5 before it's all said and done. He's averaged almost 6 ypc. in this era and is one of the better receiving RBs that have existed.

Totally agree with this. He is a home run threat every time he touches the ball.

I also find it weird that LT gets no love here, but I know a lot of people hold his playoff performances against him.

I think LT is a clear 6-10.

I would agree with that for sure. Played on some awful teams early in his career.

James Stewart was solid for a couple of seasons.

Kevin Smith says hello haha.

I thought Reggie Bush was going to be better than he ended up being.

Same here. I thought he would be kinda what like Charles has become. Bush is one of the best I have ever seen on the college level.

Lawrence Phillips killed a guy.

It's true.

LP could have been the next Eric Dickerson if he was anywhere close to a respectable human being.

I remember reading that Barry could dunk a basketball without getting a running start. Dude's 5'8".

Is it weird I grew up having a man crush on his legs? Oh well.

We obviously need a whatif football tournament to settle this debate.

I'm down. A fun story line could be if Skitch and I could coexist with a Lions team.

Keith Woodside is the right answer.

Fixed it for you.

[Kaius]

I was just wondering where all the packer fans were...

We're having a private meeting where we rank the franchise's 13 World Championship teams.

Hey, we have 10...

[BigRedLedbetter]

Geaux Saints!

God I love RW. He doesn't give a fuck what people think of him. It's refreshing.

[Lament]

Hey, we have 10...

[darth_vedder]

I loved Riggins. He just shouldn't be in this conversation.

24 rushing TDs in 1983.

Agree, I'd say Sweetness or Barry Sanders. But...If I'm making my own fantasy football team, I just very well may take the Hogs + the Diesel, and put them up against any other super fantasy best of team.

[Self]

I saw Peyton Manning run the ball once, so we could probably throw him in the mix.

how many yards did he lose?

None on this one!

http://a.video.nfl.com/films/s2013/nflc ... _3200k.mp4

This is way overrated around here, but if were posting guys who can't run...

[Kaius]

Hey, we have 10...

I was born in 86

[Kaius]

And since I can't trash the pack without going back more than 2 decades, I'm going to concede that Samkon Gado is in fact the best rb of all time n

[MattA75]

7 pages and no mention of Eric Dickerson at all?

[verb_to_trust]

OJ

[Mecca]

OJ

[verb_to_trust]

OhJay

[BurtReynolds]

whatever happened to that guy?