Rank the Albums Again. This Time Weighted! #1: Vitalogy

[chewm]

S/T is better than Ten.

[bada]

This is fun thanks 4/5.

[The Argonaut]

The revealed albums so far were three of my bottom four. I gave PJ and Backspacer 7 each, and I gave LB just the one point (for Infallible). I listen to both PJ and Backspacer still and enjoy them, but there's no magic there. That's why 7.

[PHATJ]

I'm digging this thread 4/5! It was a good idea and your reveals and attached info make it pretty damn fun. Well done indeed.

I figured the three that were revealed so far would come in where they have, the rest of the list should be very interesting. Keep those results coming!

[stip]

Riot act will be next. After that I'm not sure.

[PHATJ]

Riot act will be next. After that I'm not sure.

That's my guess too.

[Norah]

The revealed albums so far were three of my bottom four. I gave PJ and Backspacer 7 each, and I gave LB just the one point (for Infallible). I listen to both PJ and Backspacer still and enjoy them, but there's no magic there. That's why 7.

I went:

Self Titled 2
Backspacer 0
Lightning Bolt 0

[PHATJ]

The revealed albums so far were three of my bottom four. I gave PJ and Backspacer 7 each, and I gave LB just the one point (for Infallible). I listen to both PJ and Backspacer still and enjoy them, but there's no magic there. That's why 7.

I went:

Self Titled 2
Backspacer 0
Lightning Bolt 0

7. Lightning Bolt 6
8. Pearl Jam 6
9. ?????????? 5
10. Backspacer 0

[Leatherhead]

I gave S/T a 10. Fuck yea, it's pretty good.

[4/5]

How many total surveys, 4/5?

Based on LB bested BS by 1 vote and their scores were 3.33 to 3.30, I believe the score was 110 to 109 and there were 33 surveys.

This is exactly right.

Can you provide the median and mode?

Sure. I can probably do that later today.

[CopperTom]

The revealed albums so far were three of my bottom four. I gave PJ and Backspacer 7 each, and I gave LB just the one point (for Infallible). I listen to both PJ and Backspacer still and enjoy them, but there's no magic there. That's why 7.

I went:

Self Titled 2
Backspacer 0
Lightning Bolt 0

7. Lightning Bolt 6
8. Pearl Jam 6
9. ?????????? 5
10. Backspacer 0

T8. Avacado 6
T8. Lightning Bolt 6
10. Backspacer 4

[stip]

4: Backspacer -12
5: Lightning Bolt -11
6: S/T-8

[E.H. Ruddock]

How many total surveys, 4/5?

Based on LB bested BS by 1 vote and their scores were 3.33 to 3.30, I believe the score was 110 to 109 and there were 33 surveys.

[CopperTom]

How many total surveys, 4/5?

Based on LB bested BS by 1 vote and their scores were 3.33 to 3.30, I believe the score was 110 to 109 and there were 33 surveys.

Yup. That's about right. He has better social skills.

[vedder316]

This is a pretty good thread. I was on vacation or I would have voted something like this:

Ten 17
Vs 16
Vitalogy 15
Yield 12
NC 11
LB 7
BS 7
Bin 6
RA 5
PJ 4

[4/5]

7.


Riot Act is our #7 album with an average score of 7.5 points.

If S/T was our most groupthink album, Riot Act may well be the least.

Riot Act was ranked as high as 2 and as low as 10 and received at least two votes of everything in between.

The most common ranking was 7th, with about 39% of participants ranking it 7th.

The highest score was 15 points, which two users gave it.

RA was most commonly given between 5 and 11 points.

It is the last album to receive any last place votes (9%).

RA is kind of all alone in the rankings. The three most recent albums are clearly the least-liked albums overall, while the first six are clearly the most-liked albums. RA seems to operate in its own space among PJ albums. It would probably be equally accurate to say it's the most well-liked of the last 4 albums or to say it's the least-favorite of the first 7 albums, depending on your perspective. I don't think the numbers would really allow you to lump S/T with the favorites or our #6 album in with the least favorites, so RA is somewhat unique in that regard.

[Norah]

Riot Act 11
??????????
??????????
Self Titled 2
Backspacer 0
Lightning Bolt 0

[PHATJ]

7. Lightning Bolt 6
8. Pearl Jam 6
9. Riot Act 5
10. Backspacer 0

[E.H. Ruddock]

Riot Act 7
S/T 10
Backspacer 0
Lightning Bolt 5

[CopperTom]

5. Riot Act 11
T8. Avacado 6
T8. Lightning Bolt 6
10. Backspacer 4