Rank the Albums Again. This Time Weighted! #1: Vitalogy

[Norah]

Or maybe I'd subtract from Ten and Pearl Jam and leave VS at 10. Either way, Riot Act should have 2 more points.

BUT IT WOULDN'T MOVE IN THE RANKINGS

I know, but it would put Riot Act closer to the the top group and further from the middle group.

[tragabigzanda]

pearl jam sucks now

[bada]

1. Vitalogy 20
2. Ten 20
3. Vs. 15
4. No Code 12
5. Yield 12
6. Binaural 10
7. Riot Act 6
8. S/T 3
9. Backspacer 1
10. Lightning Bolt 1

[Kevin Davis]

So Lament didn't do the 100 point thing, eh?

No I very much did, but I later told 4/5 that if he didn't want to include it, I wouldn't be offended.

Gotcha. I apologize for being a tool about it when it first came up.

Thanks 4/5 for the explanation and for running this - it's been fun.

[E.H. Ruddock]

hey 4/5, since school is back in session and you have a bunch of free time on your hands, you gonna do this system for each album and it's songs?

[CopperTom]

hey 4/5, since school is back in session and you have a bunch of free time on your hands, you gonna do this system for each album and it's songs?

I was going to ask the same thing.

[CopperTom]

1. Vitalogy 17
2. Ten 15
T3. Vs. 12
T3. Yield 12
5. Riot Act 11
6. Binaural 9
7. No Code 8
T8. Avacado 6
T8. Lightning Bolt 6
10. Backspacer 4

[Lament]

hey 4/5, since school is back in session and you have a bunch of free time on your hands, you gonna do this system for each album and it's songs?

I was going to ask the same thing.

4/5 is gonna do this for every song in the catalog, and then turn each song's scores into baseball stats and have a whatif tournament based on those stats.

[CopperTom]

hey 4/5, since school is back in session and you have a bunch of free time on your hands, you gonna do this system for each album and it's songs?

I was going to ask the same thing.

4/5 is gonna do this for every song in the catalog, and then turn each song's scores into baseball stats and have a whatif tournament based on those stats.

Pilate is Fred MrGriff and NOT Lance Johnson

[PHATJ]

hey 4/5, since school is back in session and you have a bunch of free time on your hands, you gonna do this system for each album and it's songs?

I was going to ask the same thing.

4/5 is gonna do this for every song in the catalog, and then turn each song's scores into baseball stats and have a whatif tournament based on those stats.

Pilate is Fred MrGriff and NOT Lance Johnson

Lance fucking Johnson

[chewm]

1. Yield 16
2. Binaural 15
3. Vitalogy 13
4. No Code 12
5. Vs 10
6. S/T 9
7. Riot Act 9
8. Ten 7
9. Lightning Bolt 5
10. Backspacer 4

[stip]

hey 4/5, since school is back in session and you have a bunch of free time on your hands, you gonna do this system for each album and it's songs?

I was going to ask the same thing.

I totally want this to happen!

[BurtReynolds]

1. No Code 30
2. Yield 23
3. Vitalogy 12
4. Vs. 10
5. Ten 9
6. Binaural 7
7. Riot Act 5
8. S/T 3
9. Lightning Bolt 1
10. Backspacer 0

Congratulations to No Code still being the best. As always.

[Leatherhead]

Soon Forget and I'm Open are alright.

Agreed, I've always liked 'em. People seem to really dislike the lyrics of both, but I feel there's much worse in the PJ catalog.

[Kevin Davis]

hey 4/5, since school is back in session and you have a bunch of free time on your hands, you gonna do this system for each album and it's songs?

I was going to ask the same thing.

I totally want this to happen!

Yeah, that would be a lot of fun.

[LoathedVermin72]

1. Vs. 40
2. Ten 20
3. No Code 10
4. Yield 10
5. Binaural 10
6. Riot Act 10
7. Vitalogy 0
8. S/T 0
9. LB 0
10. BS 0

And before anyone says anything, I love Vitalogy. I just knew it was going to win and I love the other 6 albums more.

[CopperTom]

You're such a dingbat.

[LoathedVermin72]

You seem to spend a lot of RM time trying to provoke me, Tom. You feeling okay?

[CopperTom]

Honestly, I delete the worst ones. Not just ones aimed at you though.

[BurtReynolds]

we just need to accept the reality that St. Anger is better than Vitalogy